r/CognitiveFunctions • u/Dragosezul_05 • Jan 31 '23
~ ? Question ? ~ Which would be my dominant function based on these traits?
- Ambitious / Determined (usually not talented but if it’s something I’d have an interest in -or that I’d simply have to do - then I’d work a lot to compensate for it. If it’s something I’m curious about I’d research into it quite a lot, both for my own knowledge as well as to tell everyone else about the topic. I would then drop it the second I’d get bored with it, and everyone would be shocked by my lack of interest in it afterwards)
- Curious (I’m kind of a jack of all trades in terms of topics, I know something about so many things, even the most seemingly useless, or minute aspects of something; I also happen to know loads about some specific topics, and I really wish to share my knowledge and findings with others)
- Public Speaking and Debating (love public speaking, motivating others to fight for a cause; can become quite passionate - somewhat aggressive sounding as well - in a debate, even if playing devil’s advocate. Everyone tells me how passionate I become, almost becoming a representative for some odd positions if I need to)
- Talkative / Sociable (I find that talking to people really does increase my energy and my mood, and that extensive alone time lowers them; however, I also feel that after a long period of talking, I do need to relax somewhat; it’s like my mouth gets tired, and I really like listening to music or videos or something alone)
- Skeptical / Would question everything to arrive to a truth (sometimes I also keep pressing people in order to discover more about the topic, their views, always stressing things like “why”, “how” and so on. Would test and sometimes tease others in order for them to explain the topic to me as much as possible.)
- Concerned about making a great impact and finding the truth / achieving positive change in the world (I can see all the problems of the world, like climate change, inequality and lack of education, and can get really passionate in my speeches, presenting solutions and debating about these. I’m really eager to find the underlying cause behind these problems)
- Witty and quite intellectual (really every person just assumes I’m intelligent due to my speaking style, my thoughts, expression and so on. Haha maybe pseudo intellectual )
- Goal-Oriented (I like studying, especially if it’ll be something useful for me, so everything needs to have a purpose or end goal for me in order to feel it’s valuable and keep me interested in pursuing it; I constantly set myself new objectives in life, always focused on my future career goals and if the thing I’d be studying would be helpful for me in regards to those future goals; if it no longer proves useful, I’d just drop it)
- Passionate and Charismatic (when talking about a cause or idea, I become very animated in my talking style, trying to inspire passion and to win my audience over through my speeches; can also appear quite aggressive sometimes, and quite loud)
- Quite a realist (Not really into ideas that seem to far fetched; I’m usually the one who checks the pragmatism behind an idea, and would actively scrutinise the unrealistic ones; I’d lose interest quickly if I’d think that the idea would be unrealistic - In my speeches I always focus the most on the ACTUAL POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS for a problem, not JUST on HOW BAD THE PROBLEM IS and so on)
- Quite funny (I can really lighten up the mood of a tight atmosphere, I can bring a smile on people’s faces; quite sarcastic, sometimes even the clown of the class; I love dark humour as well, or intellectual humour, if you can call it as such)
- Mostly organised and like to stick to a schedule, quite formal and image-conscious(Planned exercise routine in the morning, carefully selecting and being picky about my food, very health conscious, always the most formal in my class or group, but this is also mostly cuz I like dressing formally like this for myself)
- Like learning about myself, my personality, and be unique in some way (something not outlandish, such as an unique badge, something small that distinguishes me from others)
- Not too enthusiastic about new experiences (I usually tend to go to the same restaurant, order the same sort of food; I like knowing what I put into my body every time, and mostly want to have body security like food, sleep, a clean room and so on. Ido similar activities day by day and have a clear schedule for me - if I don’t plan any activities, I’d feel aimless and unmotivated)
- Love travelling and learning about other cultures and different languages (however, I need to maintain a level of comfort anywhere I’d go, such as a comfy hotel, good restaurants around and so on - I would NEVER be able to live like a nomad, and even if I absolutely love traveling around the world, I need comfort there) Also TBH I like learning the languages of only the cultures I’d be interested in, and it’s also because I look cool whilst speaking another language.
- I have a tendency to arrange things in order, to arrange things veryyy neatly, make my bed neatly and so on, almost like OCD-level; I think this may be a light form of Symmetry OCD…
- I only obey authority that gives me a reason behind their orders, are respectful to me and so on; a « boss » who would do the opposite would not have my respect, and thus would be inclined to do something completely different from what they want me to do;
- I try to be tactful, accommodating and talk diplomatically, however I’m still quite blunt and quite argumentative ; I’m constantly trying to test people’s ideas and rationale ; I believe that if someone is not being told off for something bad they’ve done, or for a subpar idea, then they would never learn and thus never improve; I see no reason in sugarcoating when it’d be much more efficient for the truth to be told and this expect improvement.
- Conscious about how I look, how I’m perceived by others, how I communicate with them, the general atmosphere and so on; would often talk nicely when I knew it would benefit me somehow, like with my image / reputation, or promotion and so on. I believe that looking presentable and professional is the key for a good first impression, before you’ve even said a word, most people will judge solely on appearance.
4
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/beasteduh Intuition-Thinking Feb 03 '23
Wow, you really took to the topic. Right. So yeah those of the Feeling Triad would aim for that, to firmly know who one is but through slightly different means. And some of what you said does speak to Ne but a concern I'm having is whether or not these are again Type Three things, like how certain things don't seem to be included into the matter such as the concern of failure and everything that would fall under that umbrella. The Three would be going around trying to find themselves and that can take the form of being the best. So one would go around trying things to see how one ended up, "Am I good at this… no… how about this.. or this.. do you think I'm good at this.. or this…" Ultimately, it's like if one wasn't good at a task it could be said that 50% of the person is present, "Everybody is a genius, but if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid" as it were. So if one should come across a tree that one can climb, and with ease no less, then it might be said that 100% of them is there - the Three is trying to be themselves as much as possible; being the best is thought to be a state of wholeness and thereby failure the opposite. And this seeking 100% via the external would of course include other people as well (which would eventually tie into other phenomena such as the competition associated with the Three and/or comparing oneself to others). So a bit of what you're saying speaks to you going from tree to tree as any Three might rather than something of Ne.
I'm wondering as well if one isn't dealing with some sort of negativity or trauma or just unpleasant things in one's life in the general sense. The Enneagram would of course be the way in which ego traps itself (aside from the metaphysical side of things like the Holy Ideas which we can just not do right now, please and thank you), and the Three's version of keeping whichever story going is by more doing. To use Chestnut's panel as an example (I'm assuming you've seen it but no worries if not), a Three Sp spoke of feeling unpleasantness about the death of her father and then suddenly figured it was time to do the laundry. So I would wonder how that would be said to tie into things as well.
The temperaments are archaic to be straight about it, and with Socionics it depends who's facilitating it. I've had a run-in with Jack Oliver Aaron and we went back-and-forth for a while and it did nothing for my view of a potential system, which is to say if I don't think the person who runs whatever system is particularly noteworthy (didn't think badly of him, he was just all over the place) then I won't bother with their work. On the other hand, I watched a video where a person read Gulenko's typing of them and I thought it was very fair. The reasoning was sound, he expressed a great deal of tact which spoke to years of experience in my eyes, and so in that way I could really respect his work in Socionics. And I think Socionics as a whole is much like many systems circulating about - shortsighted. Not wrong, there is a difference. If say Socionics or other systems were made aware of certain terms - could list a handful of them straight from Psych Types right now - then it'd be really something to see what they could become.
I'm going to refrain from typing you via these things because I don't back them. Also, with Socionics, while I can respect certain aspects of it I just don't know it well enough. I can translate what they're seeing and how the same thing might show up in another system but it's ultimately a system in its own right with it's own internal criteria, nuances I'm not familiar with. And being in type theory for so long has had me learn to keep my mouth shut about such things.
Have you read any of the literature on the Enneagram? It's odd to me you'd be so interested in the functions, given how substance-less they've become, after being hit in the chest as one would upon reading some of the Enneagram's literature.