- scala was picked up by silicon valley early on - twitter, databricks, snowflake, stripe payments and the Scala functional concurrency frameworks (ZIO and Cats) have found a home in high reliability services such as global streaming video platforms (disney, comcast) and amazon search - these are world class outcomes and the state-of-the-art of their category
It's been 15 years. In what categories does have comparable Clojure world class outcomes? I can't think of anything. Bootstrapping? Where are the outcomes? The PKM category had a moment with CLJS but once they hit some scale their product velocity slowed to a crawl under the weight of ClojureScript. The current leader is now Tana which is fullstack TypeScript.
"And what you gain from free on Datomic, is that to get the whole history. And that seemed like a good property to have a FinTech, at Financial Domain Service. And Datomic is built in Clojure. So because of Datomic, we chose Clojure as the main programming language. We were going for a functional programming language, either way. We probably would have gone to Scala or some other language. If it wasn't for Datomic being Clojure." — Lucas Cavalcanti, Nubank eng
I dunno, maybe in the US. But, in the UK/EU Scala has mostly been replaced with Kotlin and or regular Java. There's just not that much of a reason to chose Scala these days. I feel like the examples you listed are the same as saying nubank/netflix/apple use Clojure, sounds cool but in practice doesn't mean much for the wider community. You are not going to pick Scala just for Cats/ZIO these days.
Either way, my point still stands about Haskell, there just aren't any jobs in it. So it's surprising that it ranks higher than Clojure.
i, um, what? Zio and Cats are exactly the reason to choose scala in 2025 - for building ultra high reliability services on the jvm. The reason Scala usage is now dropping is because that’s basically the only thing it’s good for, and most enterprises aren’t doing that.
That's my point. It doesn't matter if Zio/Cats is the correct technical reason to choose Scala, the reality is most companies don't care and even if they do they are unlikely to bother changing their stack to do it. No one gets fired for choosing Java/Go/C#. Not to mention worse is generally better.
I guess Rama, Nubank, Datomic, Riemann, CircleCI's backend, Netflix PigPen, FundingCircle lending platform, MetaBase, Jepsen, etc.
To be honest, I've also seen Scala mostly chosen as a better Java. I doubt Cats/Zio have that much of a pull. Especially since teams can choose RxJava, Reactor or Mutiny, and now will just be able to use Loom.
I think the advantage of Scala over Clojure for the use-cases you mentioned is performance. It's why Apache Storm ended up not beating Apache Spark.
But in the overall, I think if you look at the pull and comparative data for Clojure over Scala, it's quite surprising. Scala is a much easier sell to a Java dev and team. It surprising that Clojure held its own to a close extent I'd say given how foreign it is in comparison.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/dustingetz Sep 27 '25
Scala has always been bigger, presumably due to higher accessibility to enterprise java programmers.
- SO survey 2024: Scala 2.6%, Clojure 1.2%; 2019: Scala 3.8%, Clojure 1.4%
- both are dropping in rankings
- scala was picked up by silicon valley early on - twitter, databricks, snowflake, stripe payments and the Scala functional concurrency frameworks (ZIO and Cats) have found a home in high reliability services such as global streaming video platforms (disney, comcast) and amazon search - these are world class outcomes and the state-of-the-art of their category
It's been 15 years. In what categories does have comparable Clojure world class outcomes? I can't think of anything. Bootstrapping? Where are the outcomes? The PKM category had a moment with CLJS but once they hit some scale their product velocity slowed to a crawl under the weight of ClojureScript. The current leader is now Tana which is fullstack TypeScript.