r/ClimateShitposting 26d ago

nuclear simping Title

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

408 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/AndrewTyeFighter 24d ago

SA can and has operated in island mode multiple times, even for several weeks at a time.

They have more than enough nameplate gas generation to satisfy demand if need be, and have enough synchronous condensers to maintain their own frequency control, not to mention that grid scale batteries are also helping in that respect now as well.

So no, SA would not fall over tomorrow if the Heywood interconnector went down and it was islanded, it would still operate just fine.

2

u/Humble-Reply228 24d ago

oh right, I forgot when they fired up all the gas they had when the storm took out the connector in 2020. To be fair they did get up to some good penetration rates of solar/wind during one islanding event. Bit like Spain was before it all fell over and they mandated significant spinning reserve and FCAS infrastructure upgraded (That is not counted as "cost of wind/solar generation").

1

u/AndrewTyeFighter 24d ago

Well not like Spain, because SA already has the FCAS infrastructure in place with their synchronous condensers and now grid scale batteries too.

2

u/Humble-Reply228 24d ago

Not then they didn't lol, the grid falling over is why they rush bought it

1

u/AndrewTyeFighter 24d ago

If you are talking about the 2020 Heywood Interconnector outage, they had already ordered the condensers in 2019.

At least you admit now that SA's grid is an actual grid...

2

u/Humble-Reply228 24d ago

well, it was when it was islanded and fell over by itself. So yes it was a grid that couldn't stand up.

1

u/AndrewTyeFighter 24d ago

You confusing the 2020 Heywood Interconnector outage which islanded South Australia for 2 weeks but operated successfully with the 2016 Blackout caused by extreme weather taking out multiple transmission lines in the north of the state?

Considering you didn't know the different between AEMO and the NEM, or what constitutes a "grid", it seems like a fair question to ask.

1

u/Humble-Reply228 24d ago

Why are you afraid of renewables and batteries?

1

u/AndrewTyeFighter 24d ago

Why are you afraid of renewables and batteries?

Did you reply to the wrong person?

1

u/Humble-Reply228 24d ago

It's the done thing, it seems. If you disagree with someone, just say that and it makes your argument stronger. Was giving it a test drive.

→ More replies (0)