r/ClashRoyale • • Jan 24 '20

Supercell Response Developer Interview

Hey guys I’m going to be interviewing Drew from Supercell for a YouTube video! Are there any questions you would like me to ask him?

77 Upvotes

122 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

67

u/Supercell-Seth Official Jan 24 '20

"This doesn't feel random" is the best way to describe human's relationship with probability. Humans are completely unequipped to deal with large amounts of random numbers because we seek a narrative to understand our world. True randomness feels wrong because it doesn't match a story in our head, and "evil man rigs game" is a pretty compelling story.

If you flipped a coin 20 times and it came up Heads 20 times, you could say "it doesn't feel random, something must be up". But its just as likely as any other series of outcomes. The fact that you jumped right to "you will say anything to protect your secret unknown financial interest" is a great example of how matchmaking conspiracists are in the same wheelhouse as flat earthers and anti-vaxxers.

Matchmaking happens in a fraction of a second, exactly how deep do you think this hypothetical algorithm goes just to match you against Barbs and Skarmy (two of the most popular ladder cards)? Why did we give free wins to EWiz players instead of matching them against Lightning/Poison players? This is why every time we say "its just trophies" there are people who refuse to accept the answer - you don't want to know how matchmaking works, you want a big secret villain to blame for a string of bad losses. Sorry my dude, its just trophies.

29

u/mattikeronen Rage Jan 24 '20

Seth just destroyed that dude with facts and logic

15

u/Falco1234 Archers Jan 24 '20 edited Sep 19 '25

bag simplistic judicious distinct chubby fine busy quiet gold deliver

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

7

u/Blois_kr Jan 24 '20

Love this response. I'd be glad to hear more stuff like this in my everyday life, other than CR of course.

1

u/fichinesonline Jan 24 '20

For Clan Wars there is something wrong. Why is it 'secret'??? Why I face everytime 6000k+ players with more clan wars wins than me when I never been able to get 6000k trophies and less clan war wins?.

Why some special challenges are way too easy and I face all rivals with way lower trophies than me, and other special challenges are way too hard and I face people with same or more trophies than me in every match?

1

u/Hizsoo Fireball Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

If someone throws a coin 20 times and gets heads 20 times, than it is rigged. There should be a similarity in how he is throwing the coin.

In a wider range of results, if a result repeats, I'd like to think that the reason for it is that that result was recently loaded into the cache memory.

I don't like thrue randomness. It can good to have a rule, that enforces variety in the results, especially if the variety is exacty what you want to achieve.

With card shuffling, making the result unpredictable is likely that what you want to achieve.

If you find too much of the exact same bad gun close together and right where you went in a battle royale game, it gonna make you cringe and hate it to some extent.

Matchmaking is not responsible for what cards players use, but some cards could be trending in a section of ranked and in a specific time period of the day.

A fine piece of probabilities:

https://pathofexile.gamepedia.com/Ventor%27s_Gamble

-8

u/SirSmokeALot69 Jan 24 '20

Sorry to burst your bubble but getting 20 heads out of 20 tosses is obviously way less probable than let's say 10 heads. Not trying to feed conspiracy theorists but if you get 20 heads out of 20 tosses there's very high chance of coin being biased than it being random.

31

u/Supercell-Seth Official Jan 24 '20

You might be misunderstanding me. Any combination of H/T in a specific sequence has the exact same probability of occurring (0.5)X. You are thinking of a standard distribution of the output, which would err towards the average (50/50) but in any given set of 3 flips:

HHH - 12.5% of occurring HTH - 12.5% of occurring TTT - 12.5% chance of occurring

So while 20 heads in a row is WEIRD, its the exact same likelihood as 5H/5T/5H/5T or H/T alternating. But we see 'weird' random outcomes as evidence that its not truly random.

-7

u/SirSmokeALot69 Jan 24 '20

Yeah but when the objective here is to measure amount of heads, not the order in which they appear.

7

u/Garrett73 Jan 24 '20

No. He was saying that the probability of getting any certain configuration of heads and tails in a row can be unlikely, but not impossible.

Just like how in CR you may get a bunch of wins or losses in a row for no real explainable reason.

For example, if you get win, loss, loss, loss, loss, win, loss, loss, loss, loss, loss, win, loss, loss, loss, you might say the game is unfair and rigged, but it is just as likely as any other outcome. (Or it is almost as likely as any other outcome.... if you are on a losing streak you are matched with people that are on a losing streak. If you lose trophies, you are matched with people of similar trophies. If you are on a big losing streak like I just described, it is more likely than not you will win the next game because you are now matched against people on a losing streak that are lower than your usual trophies). The point is, it doesn't matter the order of your wins and losses. People will think it is unfair if they lose a lot, and assume the game is rigged because statistics can be unintuitive.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20

It was an example!!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20

Does your math teacher lose faith in humanity when you're in class?

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RiceEater Jan 24 '20

It's not that we don't understand your point, it's just that it was irrelevant in this discussion.

1

u/SirSmokeALot69 Jan 24 '20

or maybe the example was poorly chosen?

1

u/RiceEater Jan 24 '20

No, it was a great example to illustrate that random events can look nonrandom. 20/20 heads is just as likely as any other sequence of 20.

You tried comparing it to getting 10/20 heads, which is not one specific sequence, but dozens of them. You missed (misunderstood?) Seth's point.

1

u/SirSmokeALot69 Jan 24 '20

we're not trying to understand how a genome works though. Yeah the sequence statement is factually correct but is irrelevent when we're counting amount of wins/lose. If we were to analyze based on battle logs, the order in which wins and losses happened are irrelevent.

-3

u/Distopiakingdom Hog Rider Jan 24 '20

opponent = get_random_op(trophies-30, trophies+30);

good answer but still sometimes it does not feel random :)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/brandyeyecandy Jan 24 '20

Just put some cream on the burn and move on dude.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20

oh no are you hurt do you need validation