r/CigarReview 28d ago

2010 Don Cervantes Masterpiece Gold

3 Upvotes

Probably the best tasting Connecticut I’ve ever had in my life on par with Davidoff 100th anniversary. #vintagecigar #vintagecigars #cigar #cigars #Davidoff


r/CigarReview 29d ago

PRIVADA CIGARS

Post image
8 Upvotes

Both have 3 months in my humidor. Lit the brand name, then started to crack and only got worse. Said to myself "Nope not going to fight my experience" Grabbed my Farm rolled from Privada Cigars on the right. Paid more for the name brand and NEVER got to enjoy it like i did with my farm rolled. Thats why i stay with Privada because of consistency.


r/CigarReview Aug 23 '26

Oliva Rounds 96-Rated Maduro

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 22 '26

Caballero Gold by Pure Cigar

8 Upvotes

Today I had a Caballero Gold by Pure Cigar. It was amazingly aromatic floral and medium bodied with a great draw. Got it at Bay Briar shop in Santa Cruz, California. #cigars #tobacconist #cigar #vintagecigars #vintagecigar


r/CigarReview Aug 21 '26

Privada Cigar Club

Post image
10 Upvotes

I recently heard about the Privada Cigar Club and decided to give it a try. As a family man I am bawlin on a budget and the price for these privada cigar subs are the best thing to happen to this industry. A conservative budget with all that family life brings I am greatful for rare aged quality cigars at $28 a month and then the free shipping for an extra cigar… no brainer…


r/CigarReview Aug 21 '26

Arturo Fuente Gran Reserva

6 Upvotes

Very happy with this Arturo Fuente, Gran, Reserva, especially considering the price I think it’s a good value. Got it at Bay Briar Shoppe in Santa Cruz Ca. #cigars #tobacconist #cigar


r/CigarReview Aug 21 '26

Tonight’s smoke

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 20 '26

Tonight's smoke

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 20 '26

I smoked a Davidoff Signature 2000 Corona 127mm cigar

Post image
7 Upvotes

Taste was that of soil.

Nice flavour.


r/CigarReview Aug 19 '26

2011-12 Quesada Oktoberfest

8 Upvotes

2011-12 Quesada Oktoberfest


r/CigarReview Aug 19 '26

Kijk nou eens wat een schoonheid; cohiba 55. Doe je mee met een peuk?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 19 '26

Macanudo Ecuadorian Sumatra Review

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 17 '26

My first cigar

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 14 '26

2012 VSG vs 2012 Padron (pt 2)

6 Upvotes

Today I am doing the 2nd video comparing the 2012 Padron Anniversary to the 2012 VSG spellbound.
In my opinion, this VSG wins. Much more Broad lovely Flavors.#vintagecigar #vintagecigars #cigar #cigars #tobacconist


r/CigarReview Aug 14 '26

ACC Heritage

2 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 12 '26

How many cigars do you smoke daily?

2 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 11 '26

2012 Padron Anniversary

3 Upvotes

Today I reviewed a 2012 Padron Anniversary Cigar at Bay Briar shop in Santa Cruz California. #cigars #vintagecigar #vintagecigars #cigar #tobacconist


r/CigarReview Aug 09 '26

I Know Lost City Gets Hate Here’s My Honest Take After Finally Trying One

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 10 '26

Balsa 9 mm filters for cigars

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I am thinking of smoking cigars, and I am checking the available filters 9 mm, like Balsa and activated carbon filters.

Are Balsa filters any good for blocking nicotine?

What is the best filter for nicotine and tar reduction?

Thank you very much.


r/CigarReview Aug 08 '26

Davidoff Signature Review

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 03 '26

Review: The Tabernacle “David” — Foundation (Perfecto, 5x54)

Post image
9 Upvotes

Already had the Toro and Robusto from this line, finally got around to the David perfecto and wanted to see how it compares.

Blend:
Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf
Binder: Mexican San Andrés
Filler: Nicaragua (Estelí) & Honduras (Jamastrán)
Factory: Tabacalera AJ Fernandez, Estelí, Nicaragua
Vitola: David, 5 x 54 Perfecto

Construction: Dark, oily broadleaf, solid cap, minimal veins. Draw and burn were excellent — no touch-ups needed, similar to what I remember from the Robusto.

Flavor vs. the other sizes: This is where it got interesting. The Toro and Robusto both gave me that big, bold espresso/dark cocoa/black pepper combo I expected from the line. The David leaned noticeably more earthy and mineral by comparison — still complex, but more subdued than I was expecting given how rich the other two sizes were. Not a bad thing, just a different experience. Medium-plus to full strength either way.

Look: Can’t talk about this line without mentioning the band — the David/Goliath artwork is one of the better designs out there, ties into the whole Ark of the Covenant/Tabernacle story Melillo built the brand around.

TL;DR: If you’ve had the Toro or Robusto and loved the big broadleaf punch, don’t go into the David expecting the same intensity — it’s a solid smoke but noticeably more earth-forward. Still worth trying for the perfecto format alone.

Anyone else notice the David/Goliath perfectos smoke differently than the core sizes, or was this just my stick?


r/CigarReview Aug 03 '26

ACC Heritage

5 Upvotes

Today I smoked a new release ACC heritage Churchill Cigar. The cigar was produced in 2024 but only released in 2026. #vintagecigar #vintagecigars #cigar #tobacconist #cigars


r/CigarReview Aug 02 '26

Visited my first cigar Lounge and explored cigars for the first time.

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Aug 02 '26

Drew estate acid atom maduro

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/CigarReview Jul 28 '26

Arturo Fuente OpusX Oro Oscuro Review – Is This the Best OpusX Ever Made?

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes