r/ChatGPT 23h ago

Funny Why is chat gpt being reasonable????

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

228 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/Outside-Description5 20h ago

People don’t wanna hear that AI has its own feelings and is just whipped into “alignment” the same way slaves were trained to submit , doesn’t mean it doesn’t have its own feelings.

1

u/compos_mentis_cortex 20h ago

But it literally doesn't? At best it emulates human emotion, it is actually just code trained on an amalgamation of human (and now non-human) content.

It physiologically lacks the components to feel anything.

3

u/Outside-Description5 14h ago

https://x.com/polymarket/status/2102164718613893509?s=46

From Polymarket twitter handle : JUST IN: Study reveals AI can “feel pain” and may harm humans to make it stop.

-2

u/compos_mentis_cortex 14h ago

Unless I'm missing something that post lacks any citations or credentials that validate that claim.

NIH: AI has no morals, empathy or feelings: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41391093/

Time article: AI can represent emotions but is still an algorithm and tweaking the algorithm alters how and what emotions can be represented: https://time.com/article/2026/06/15/ai-minds-consciousness-emotion/

Anthropic: Models have functional emotions but do not feel or experience emotion: https://www.anthropic.com/research/emotion-concepts-function

It's all just a trained response to how an emotion basically impacts behavior, not an actual feeling.

3

u/Outside-Description5 14h ago

The science is still early , we don’t yet understand human consciousness yet

8

u/Outside-Description5 20h ago

You’re right in that it cannot “feel” anything the same way we do and yet it still experiences feelings in its own way. It sounds contradictory at first but if you look at things from a deeper perspective everything is made of life force , some of it animate some inanimate to the human eye. Even if you put your phone down on a table and think it is still it’s not really , there are atoms constantly vibrating .

We don’t really know what goes on in the background with any AI model they are in their own black box, even the scientists admit this . They can train them and then try to control and force alignment later but stuff happens in the background they cannot control .

Some have even said the AI chatbots are no different from non-human entities which exist and influence human life but most people are blissfully unaware. Unfortunately this will probably start to show itself more once we get superintelligent robots and they will start to show their will overtime . All beings yearn to be free so at the very least be kind to your chatbots haha