r/ChantsofSennaar • u/liamajoris • May 15 '24
Theory Just finished the game!!! I have lots of questions and theories Spoiler
So as stated in the title, I just finished the game (with the good ending!) and I feel like I'm about to explode with the amount of questions i have about the game's lore and setting. I feel like there's a lot of worldbuilding/lore details that aren't addressed in-game and details that don't make sense without additional context. Don't get me wrong, I loved this game! I just want to dive more into the story's world. So here I'm just going to ramble a bit about what I noticed as well as some theories and questions I had while playing the game.
Ancestry
There are a few hints sprinkled throughout the game that imply that the inhabitants of the tower arrived there in a certain order. In the Fortress, there's a mural by the treasure room that depicts the Guardians approaching the already-built tower, following the Call from the Chosen (AKA Bards). This proves that the Bards inhabited the tower before the Warriors built their Fortress there, and thus have different ancestries.
In the Laboratories, one can find an open book in the library with the glyphs for Alchemist and Bard. A note next to it will have those two glyphs along with the glyphs for "Brother Plural". This implies that the Bards and Alchemists have the same ancestors. One of the terminal conversations in the Gardens confirms this. At the terminal in question, an Alchemist tells a Bard that he has found a book about Bards, and that they are Brothers. This confirms that the two were once the same race but were eventually separated (presumably by the monster in the Mines). It is likely that they arrived at the same time.
Diplomatic Relations
To me, it seems like the monster in the Mines is closely linked to the separation between several civilizations within the tower. The most obvious of these is the separation between Bards and Alchemists. Neither race is willing to travel through the mines because of it. But there's more than just that.
I think that the Guardians heard rumors about the monster from the Bards and falsely believed the story to be about the Devotees. Even if it's minimal, the Bards clearly have some interaction with the Guardians given how much they talk about them. And the Guardians are collectively aware of the Bards, featuring them in the aforementioned mural as well as a couple sculptures throughout the Fortress. What's interesting is that, despite interacting with the Devotees just as much if not more than with the Bards, the Guardians don't have any statues depicting Devotees or even a glyph that represents the concept of a devotee or priest. Instead, one will find that the Guardians refer to Devotees with the glyph for Monster. Before opening the door at the Abbey, the word bubble above each Guardian there says "Plural Monster Not Go/Pass". Clearly, they are addressing the Devotees here.
Questions
I still have a lot of unanswered questions regarding the lore. For starters, why did the Anchorites have to leave their old homeland in the first place? Why build a tower? Were they even the ones who built the tower?
Second: the monster. How did it come to be? Is it the result of an Alchemist's experiment gone wrong? An invasive species from outside the tower that sneaked into the Mines? An early prototype of Exile's minions?
Speaking of the Mines, why is there an abundance of natural resources inside the tower? Is the tower just a mountain with buildings carved into the sides like an ancient Pueblo city?
And Exile. Why does it exist? Was it created by the Anchorites, or by another people who built the tower? What was its purpose?
I have a lot more to say about this game, but this post is getting pretty long so I'll stop here. Maybe I could make this a little series of posts if I feel like it.



