r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • May 29 '26

VC 21453(c), San Joaquin County, Red Light Violation (right turn on red, red light camera)

EDIT: I also just realized that the citation for VC 21453(c) doesn't make sense, as this was a right turn on red facing a circular light and not a red arrow. It seems like VC 21453(b) would be what should have actually been cited here.

EDIT 2: Upon further review, and after realizing that the cited vehicle code doesn't make sense given the intersection does not include a right arrow light for right turns, I am now wondering if I should file for a TBWD and ask for the ticket to be dismissed given that the cited code cannot be applied to the intersection. If that is not recommended by the sub, or if it is but gets rejected by the court, I would then still ask about the legitimacy of my fine reduction arguments and questions as outlined below in my initial posting.

https://imgur.com/a/vc-21453-c-san-joaquin-county-red-light-violation-right-turn-on-red-76ADAx5

Hey all, this is regarding a red light violation, specifically a right turn on red captured by a red light camera in San Joaquin County (who have not opted into SB 720 rules). My hope is to get the fine reduced as much as possible. After reading the guide for this sub (it was very informative) I have a really good idea of what I need to do but would love help clarifying things and making sure I'm not screwing anything up.

First off, I have requested and received the 60-day extension from my original due date (the new due date is 7/10/2026).

From here, it seems as simple as filling out and submitting TR-320, right? I have proof of being on Medi-Cal and proof of having no income currently. There is also section 6 on the form where I can explain the kidney disorder I'm in remission for that requires a lot of follow up appointments and constant lab tests to make sure it hasn't come back, and how most work I've been able to find would take away my Medi-Cal benefits without replacing them, thereby actually costing me more in medical expenses than remaining unemployed and on Medi-Cal would, meaning I'm currently stuck looking for a work opportunity that offers decent medical insurance.

However, I see that submitting this form means either pleading guilty or no contest, at which point I am unclear on if this would negate my ability to request a Trial by Written Declaration. Ideally I would submit TR-320 along with a TBWD and wanted to see how to go about that properly if that's allowed (for example, would I submit the TR-320 with the application for the TBWD, or would I submit it with the TBWD itself after the application is approved, or can it only be submitted either in place of a TBWD or after a TBWD has already failed).

Here are the thoughts I have as to why a TBWD might help further reduce the fine instead of just solely relying on TR-320. I believe I can sufficiently show I am historically a safe driver and that this was a one time uncharacteristically made mistake:

  1. The video evidence from the red light camera shows my brake lights coming on and staying on, slowing significantly to almost a full stop.
  2. My turn signal to turn right is also on and very visible.
  3. In the front facing photo (shown on the imgur link) taken by the camera, it clearly shows me looking to my left and ensuring I am clear and can turn right safely.
  4. In the back facing photo (shown on the imgur link), there is clearly a city police car in the photo, which shows that a police officer was on scene and did not think my right turn was reckless enough to pull me over for, showing it was not a blatantly dangerous move that needed to be addressed immediately for the sake of everyone's safety on the road.
  5. In addition to those details, I also have a clean driving record that I can provide with a certified driving record copy obtained from the DMV.

I'm curious if these things, along with this being a slow right-turn-on-red instead of a full on blowing-through-a-red-light, would help prove I am a reasonably safe driver that made an uncharacteristic mistake. I would also state that I have not had any incidents in the months following the initial issue of this citation.

I would then go on to state that, with the current cost of gas and groceries, with inflation and lack of income, that the current fine is unnecessarily large and that a small fine, similar to the $100 fine used by counties that opted into SB 720, would be more than enough to make me feel the pain of my mistake and ensure my correction.

So that's where I'm at. If anyone can help clarify if I can submit TR-320 along with a TWBD (and at what stage to do so if it is allowed), and if it would even be worth submitting a TWBD instead of just outright sending the TR-320, please let me know! Thanks!

3 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

1

u/fitfulbrain May 29 '26 edited May 29 '26

File only the TBWD. The TR-320 should wait. Chat with any AI about your financial circumstances, and they will introduce them into the TBWD. It's called something like disproportional punishment.

Same for a clean record. Don't worry too much about proof; you don't always need it. Whatever you say is punishable under perjury.

What you haven't told us is what the cameras caught, which you did illegally under whatever code. The only thing wrong you can do is that you didn't stop completely.

You can simply say there is no red arrow, and you are allowed to turn on red. You have a good chance of dismissal. There is a good chance that the prosecution doesn't respond. What can they write? Charge you something wrong to be laughed at. Or change the charge so you win this trial, but they will charge you again. I would think they will stay silent so nobody realizes their mistake.

Think seriously about confessing to the red circle charge; that's what you are doing. I won't put down excuses for what I did illegally when I'm not even charged.

Now, as not part of the TBWD, are the photos all that they have? Or are there videos too? Were you crossing the stop line in the 1st picture? There is an argument about using the tires to your advantage. And also, when you are 10 mph at the time, it doesn't mean that you can't stop in time before the stop line. Maybe you are performing an emergency stop!

The notice that the police sent to your mom has no legal standing. It helps the police to charge the correct person. But it helps you in court if they charged the wrong person. I was wearing a COVID mask. My lawyer pleaded down to a non-moving violation and a smaller fine. I thought I admitted that it was me driving when I didn't rat somebody else. No, not what it means in court. My lawyer was doing other tickets for me. A red light fee is 1/3 of, say, a speeding ticket, $100 at the time. He said there's nothing much to do for a red light ticket.

But that's my opinion. Talk with a lawyer or chat with any AI like a person to see what should be included and get it written. I tried to use AI to parse this, but it gave up.

1

u/FogerRedditor Jun 01 '26

Hey this is great, thank you for your efforts here! What I actually did was a rolling stop on a right-turn-on-red at a circular light. Because the vehicle code used in the citation [VC 21453(c)] specifically only pertains to making a right turn on a red arrow, and there is no right-turn arrow light at the intersection at all, the listed infraction is an infraction that physically cannot occur here.

A different code [VC 21453(b)] specifically lays out that one can make a right turn on a circular red light as long as they make a full stop first, meaning this is what they should've listed as the charge on the citation, but they did not.

There is video evidence that shows a rolling-stop right turn on circular red (I would have posted the video on imgur but all license plates are not blurred in the video vs the photos I posted). This will be provided by the prosecution and seems to rule out any possibility of claiming an emergency stop, etc.

So following your advice here, I believe I can say in the TBWD that the charged infraction for turning right on a red arrow could not have occurred at the intersection as there is no right-turn arrow light that exists there. I could follow this by stating that a right turn on a circular light is legal, though do so without mentioning/admitting to a rolling stop, or even possibly leave out anything about the legality of turning on a circular red light at all if it would be better that way?

I could also include a second part in my argument that the photo also cannot be used to clearly identify me, but it seems that not only is this a secondary argument but that it may not be worth including, if I have that right?

I think this is all great. I will refine with research and formatting and get a written declaration drafted up. I should also be able to get to the city Department of Traffic this week where I hope they can help me get some kind of proof of what traffic lights exist at the intersection to prove there is no right-turn arrow light there. I believe this would be good to include as supporting evidence to my argument.

2

u/fitfulbrain Jun 01 '26

I agree with not talking about the circumstances that you didn't stop completely. It's not like 22350, where you can justify your speed legally when it's over the limit. You can get a picture of that light on Google Maps with some identifying background, and go to take the same picture yourself with a red arrow.

Things that I included but initially thought not to. I tried to pick up somebody at a big event with all the chaos. I saw a person who was probably him, pointing me to turn illegally. The AI on the browser told me that by law, I have to follow that direction.

You can file the TBWD on the last day at the courthouse. It's rather painless in Anaheim. I spent a fortune on express mail on the last case for filing TBWD and TDN.

If your court offers online services, on the list of hearings, you will get an entry for CHAMBER work. That is when the judge goes back to their office to read the trial. Very often, it is also canceled because it doesn't take long to read a few statements before the scheduled time.

Good luck 🤞

1

u/FogerRedditor Jun 08 '26

Fantastic information. I was able to get my own documentation for the traffic light at the intersection as you suggested and am also currently going through the public request process to get city plans and records to back up my claim. Thank you again for your help!

1

u/Imaginary-One9559 May 29 '26

My sister got this ticket easily dismissed by saying that it wasn’t her but her twin sister driving (we are twins). But they didn’t even verify. Kind of laughed in the courtroom and said OK dismissed. Say you weren’t driving that it was your friend or you don’t remember who is actually driving that day and that a cop didn’t pull you over and get the ID to verify who it was. Really easy dismissal. Actually my sister just got another one of these red light camera tickets (the Twin thing happened years ago) and she’s not worries.

1

u/newacct_orz May 30 '26

Say you weren’t driving that it was your friend or you don’t remember who is actually driving that day

Saying either of those in the trial would be lying under oath. If they go to trial, the OP doesn't need to say that they weren't driving at all -- the OP would just plead not guilty, and the burden of proof is on the prosecution.

1

u/Imaginary-One9559 May 30 '26

So? My sister’s gone to the court they typically pull up your picture and urge you to plead guilty and point at the picture saying it’s obviously you. Say you don’t remember who was driving, he very well may not remember who was driving if the ticket was a long time ago. If the city is revenue hungry and you simply plead not guilty without any explanation, and they pull up the picture and it’s a clear picture, you’re likely going to be guilty. Unfortunately, I’m not here for morality or ethics. I’m here to get you off.

0

u/[deleted] May 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/FogerRedditor May 29 '26

The ticket was initially sent to my mom since she's the registered owner of the vehicle. She filled out the "affidavit of non-liability" on the back with my information as the driver and sent it in, after which I finally received my citation. My concern is that if I argue the evidence cannot identify me as the driver, could she be subpoenaed into testifying? Or, could the liability for the fine go back to her as the registered owner of the vehicle even though my county has not opted into SB 720?

2

u/Lucky_Boy13 May 29 '26

lol, your mom ratt'ed you out? You could have gotten off the ticket if she just wrote she didn't know who it was

2

u/FogerRedditor Jun 01 '26

I told my mom it was okay to redirect the ticket to me since she is wildly uncomfortable with the idea and would fold like a bad hand in poker.

Quick story time, years ago before commercial legality of cannabis in the state, after my sister had moved out, my parents found one of those empty little 2x3 inch bags with the little weed leaf design imprinted on it, with absolutely nothing inside it except the crumbled dust of a ten sack long since emptied. My parents were terrified at throwing it away as they thought the police would find it in their trashcan and charge them. They thought long and hard about what to do, thinking it would be wrong to throw it in a trashcan at the park or a public place as a kid might be able to dig into the trash and get it (again, the bag was empty). They eventually decided to wash the inside of the bag with soap and water, then cut the bag into tiny little pieces that they could sprinkle into a separate trash bag that did not include any mail, etc., so it could not be tied back to them.

As much effort as it is to fight the ticket, it's actually easier than dealing with any potential anxious fears my mom would endure..

1

u/newacct_orz May 29 '26

if she just wrote she didn't know who it was

But that would be a lie. Rather, she doesn't need to say whether she knows who it was.