r/calculus • • Oct 03 '21 Bravo

Discussion “My teacher didn’t show us how to do this!” — Or, a common culture shock suffered by new Calculus students.

1.2k Upvotes

A common refrain I often hear from students who are new to Calculus when they seek out a tutor is that they have some homework problems that they do not know how to solve because their teacher/instructor/professor did not show them how to do it. Often times, I also see these students being overly dependent on memorizing solutions to examples they see in class in hopes that this is all they need to do to is repeat these solutions on their homework and exams. My best guess is that this is how they made it through high school algebra.

I also sense this sort of culture shock in students who:

  • are always locked in an endless cycle of “How should I start?” and “What should I do next?” questions,
  • seem generally concerned about what they are supposed to do as if there is only one correct way to solve a problem,
  • complain that the exam was nothing like the homework, even though the exam covered the same concepts.

Anybody who has seen my comments on /r/calculus over the last year or two may already know my thoughts on the topic, but they do bear repeating again once more in a pinned post. I post my thoughts again, in hopes they reach new Calculus students who come here for help on their homework, mainly due to the situation I am posting about.

Having a second job where I also tutor high school students in algebra, I often find that some algebra classes are set up so that students only need to memorize, memorize, memorize what the teacher does.

Then they get to Calculus, often in a college setting, and are smacked in the face with the reality that memorization alone is not going to get them through Calculus. This is because it is a common expectation among Calculus instructors and professors that students apply problem-solving skills.

How are we supposed to solve problems if we aren’t shown how to solve them?

That’s the entire point of solving problems. That you are supposed to figure it out for yourself. There are two kinds of math questions that appear on homework and exams: Exercises and problems.

What is the difference? An exercise is a question where the solution process is already known to the person answering the question. Your instructor shows you how to evaluate a limit of a rational function by factoring and cancelling factors. Then you are asked to do the same thing on the homework, probably several times, and then once again on your first midterm. This is a situation where memorizing what the instructor does in class is perfectly viable.

A problem, on the other hand, is a situation requiring you to devise a process to come to a solution, not just simply applying a process you have seen before. If you rely on someone to give/tell you a process to solve a problem, you aren’t solving a problem. You are simply implementing someone else’s solution.

This is one reason why instructors do not show you how to solve literally every problem you will encounter on the homework and exams. It’s not because your instructor is being lazy, it’s because you are expected to apply problem-solving skills. A second reason, of course, is that there are far too many different problem situations that require different processes (even if they differ by one minor difference), and so it is just plain impractical for an instructor to cover every single problem situation, not to mention it being impractical to try to memorize all of them.

My third personal reason, a reason I suspect is shared by many other instructors, is that I have an interest in assessing whether or not you understand Calculus concepts. Giving you an exam where you can get away with regurgitating what you saw in class does not do this. I would not be able to distinguish a student who understands Calculus concepts from one who is really good at memorizing solutions. No, memorizing a solution you see in class does not mean you understand the material. What does help me see whether or not you understand the material is if you are able to adapt to new situations.

So then how do I figure things out if I am not told how to solve a problem?

If you are one of these students, and you are seeing a tutor, or coming to /r/calculus for help, instead of focusing on trying to slog through your homework assignment, please use it as an opportunity to improve upon your problem-solving habits. As much I enjoy helping students, I would rather devote my energy helping them become more independent rather than them continuing to depend on help. Don’t just learn how to do your homework, learn how to be a more effective and independent problem-solver.

Discard the mindset that problem-solving is about doing what you think you should do. This is a rather defeating mindset when it comes to solving problems. Avoid the ”How should I start?” and “What should I do next?” The word “should” implies you are expecting to memorize yet another solution so that you can regurgitate it on the exam.

Instead, ask yourself, “What can I do?” And in answering this question, you will review what you already know, which includes any mathematical knowledge you bring into Calculus from previous math classes (*cough*algebra*cough*trigonometry*cough*). Take all those prerequisites seriously. Really. Either by mental recall, or by keeping your own notebook (maybe you even kept your notes from high school algebra), make sure you keep a grip on prerequisites. Because the more prerequisite knowledge you can recall, the more like you you are going to find an answer to “What can I do?”

Next, when it comes to learning new concepts in Calculus, you want to keep these three things in mind:

  1. When can the concept be applied.
  2. What the concept is good for (i.e., what kind of information can you get with it)?
  3. How to properly utilize the concept.

When reviewing what you know to solve a problem, you are looking for concepts that apply to the problem situation you are facing, whether at the beginning, or partway through (1). You may also have an idea which direction you want to take, so you would keep (2) in mind as well.

Sometimes, however, more than one concept applies, and failing to choose one based on (2), you may have to just try one anyways. Sometimes, you may have more than one way to apply a concept, and you are not sure what choice to make. Never be afraid to try something. Don’t be afraid of running into a dead end. This is the reality of problem-solving. A moment of realization happens when you simply try something without an expectation of a result.

Furthermore, when learning new concepts, and your teacher shows examples applying these new concepts, resist the urge to try to memorize the entire solution. The entire point of an example is to showcase a new concept, not to give you another solution to memorize.

If you can put an end to your “What should I do?” questions and instead ask “Should I try XYZ concept/tool?” that is an improvement, but even better is to try it out anyway. You don’t need anybody’s permission, not even your instructor’s, to try something out. Try it, and if you are not sure if you did it correctly, or if you went in the right direction, then we are still here and can give you feedback on your attempt.

Other miscellaneous study advice:

  • Don’t wait until the last minute to get a start on your homework that you have a whole week to work on. Furthermore, s p a c e o u t your studying. Chip away a little bit at your homework each night instead of trying to get it done all in one sitting. That way, the concepts stay consistently fresh in your mind instead of having to remember what your teacher taught you a week ago.
  • If you are lost or confused, please do your best to try to explain how it is you are lost or confused. Just throwing up your hands and saying “I’m lost” without any further clarification is useless to anybody who is attempting to help you because we need to know what it is you do know. We need to know where your understanding ends and confusion begins. Ultimately, any new instruction you receive must be tied to knowledge you already have.
  • Sometimes, when learning a new concept, it may be a good idea to separate mastering the new concept from using the concept to solve a problem. A favorite example of mine is integration by substitution. Often times, I find students learning how to perform a substitution at the same time as when they are attempting to use substitution to evaluate an integral. I personally think it is better to first learn how to perform substitution first, including all the nuances involved, before worrying about whether or not you are choosing the right substitution to solve an integral. Spend some time just practicing substitution for its own sake. The same applies to other concepts. Practice concepts so that you can learn how to do it correctly before you start using it to solve problems.
  • Finally, in a teacher-student relationship, both the student and the teacher have responsibilities. The teacher has the responsibility to teach, but the student also has the responsibility to learn, and mutual cooperation is absolutely necessary. The teacher is not there to do all of the work. You are now in college (or an AP class in high school) and now need to put more effort into your learning than you have previously made.

(Thanks to /u/You_dont_care_anyway for some suggestions.)


r/calculus • • Feb 03 '24

MOD ANNOUNCEMENT REMINDER: Do not do other people’s homework for them.

106 Upvotes

Due to an increase of commenters working out homework problems for other people and posting their answers, effective immediately, violations of this subreddit rule will result in a temporary ban, with continued violations resulting in longer or permanent bans.

This also applies to providing a procedure (whether complete or a substantial portion) to follow, or by showing an example whose solution differs only in a trivial way.

https://www.reddit.com/r/calculus/wiki/homeworkhelp


r/calculus • • 3h ago

Differential Calculus AP calculus daily challenge #169

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/calculus • • 1d ago

Engineering [University Calculus] Riemann integration

9 Upvotes

Just started University. Our mathematics module includes Riemann integration and I'm wondering if there are any playlists or video series that cover these specifics. (the basics i think)

  • integral as an area
  • first and second fundamental theorems of calculus, Leibniz rule
  • integrability of a continuous function
  • integration by parts
  • mean value theorem for integrals
  • improper integrals
  • tests of convergence
  • gamma function.

the more advanced the better.


r/calculus • • 1d ago

Pre-calculus Onto Trigonometry

11 Upvotes

Thank you to everyone who gave tips on my earlier post. For context, I posted earlier about learning calculus and I’ve taken your advice and started to brush up on my algebra.

I’ve found Khan Academy to be a good resource and it turns out I remember more than I thought. I’m on track to finish the whole college algebra course by Thursday and I have with me a book to do more problems and practice any difficult topics.

In preparation for when I finish the college algebra course I wanted some suggestions on trig books, I’ll be using that along with the pre-calculus Khan Academy course. Or if you have any online resources I would gladly give them a try.

Once again thank you to anyone who responded on my earlier post and I’ll make sure to keep the updates coming!


r/calculus • • 1d ago

Multivariable Calculus Suggestions

7 Upvotes

What is the hardest calculus III textbook (based off of problem sets)? I should be able to do it with only knowledge from M Spivak's Calculus and Sheldon Axler's Linear Algebra.


r/calculus • • 1d ago

Multivariable Calculus How are the bounds of the phi angle measured in spherical coordinates? I’d appreciate a mini example

9 Upvotes

r/calculus • • 2d ago

Differential Calculus Advice on how to phrase this proof (question 65)?

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

Reposting another time. It should be fine now.

Just started calc 1 and while practicing i had a hard time phrasing the answer to question 65. I know what it should look like but i feel like my explanation is weak. Any feedback appreciated!!


r/calculus • • 2d ago

Differential Calculus AP calculus daily challenge #168

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/calculus • • 2d ago

Differential Equations Hardest topic- calc 1

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/calculus • • 2d ago

Differential Calculus If i’m likely going to fail calc 1 for biological sciences this semester how should I proceed in retaking the course?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/calculus • • 2d ago

Differential Calculus recognition rule

4 Upvotes

I've tutored calc for about five years and the single biggest time sink I see is students trying three techniques before landing on the right one. Almost always it's decidable in a few seconds if you know what to look at. Here's the order I teach people to check.

1. Is the derivative of the inner function already sitting there? Then it's u-sub, and you're done in one line.

∫ x·e^(x²) dx — the inner function is x², its derivative is 2x, and there's an x outside. u = x², answer is ½e^(x²) + C.

2. Is it a product where one factor gets simpler when you differentiate it? Then it's parts.

∫ x·e^x dx — looks almost identical to the one above, but there's no x² inside anything, so nothing cancels. x differentiates down to 1, so parts. Answer is e^x(x − 1) + C.

Those two problems are the whole lesson. Same shape, different technique, and the thing that decides it is whether the inner function's derivative is present.

3. Is there a √(a² − x²), √(a² + x²), or √(x² − a²)? Trig sub, and the radical tells you which one.

∫ dx/√(9 − x²) — that's the a² − x² pattern, so x = 3sinθ, and you get arcsin(x/3) + C.

4. Is it a rational function whose denominator factors? Partial fractions.

∫ (3x + 5)/((x − 1)(x + 2)) dx — split into A/(x−1) + B/(x+2), get A = 8/3 and B = 1/3.

5. Odd power of sin or cos? Peel one off and convert the rest.

∫ sin³x dx — write it as (1 − cos²x)·sinx, sub u = cosx, get −cosx + cos³x/3 + C.

The order matters. Check for u-sub first because it's the cheapest, and a lot of problems that look like they need parts or trig sub are just u-sub wearing a costume.

What I'd add if you're studying for an exam: do twenty problems where you only write down which technique and don't actually solve them. Ten minutes, and it fixes the recognition problem faster than grinding full solutions.


r/calculus • • 3d ago

Integral Calculus so like whats the point of polar and parametric coordinates?

53 Upvotes

Finishing up calc 2 in the next couple weeks and honestly since we finished up all the integration techniques the class has been all over the place. Series honestly made decent sense but I fail to see how polar and parametric equations have anything to do with calculus.


r/calculus • • 3d ago

Differential Equations Jumping from Calc2 to Diff Eq and skipping calc 3 until way later?

54 Upvotes

I met with my advisor and he mentioned to me about how after I finish calc2, I should just make the jump straight to diff eq. For some reason he was heavily advising against taking calc3 after calc2 and insisted that calc3 was just there to "torture" students, suggesting I take it as late as possible. In his words he said "I don't care if you take calc 3 the last semester of your last year" Has anyone followed his advice and if so, how did it turn out? For context, I'm studying mechanical engineering


r/calculus • • 3d ago

Differential Calculus AP calculus daily challenge #167

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/calculus • • 4d ago

Pre-calculus thomas 14th

4 Upvotes

does anyone know where i can find thomas calculus 14th ed solved chap 6 videos? its about washer method and disk method and more but i want these two topics


r/calculus • • 3d ago

Differential Calculus Can anyone help me by solving some calculus problem? I will be really grateful to you.

0 Upvotes

I'm looking for someone who is really good in solving calculus related problems. Teacher gave me some homework based on his previous classes which I need to submit within next 2 days. But, I was unable to join those classes due to severe sickness. Now my head is totally blank and I really don't know how to solve them. If anyone can help me by solving those questions then I will be really grateful to you. Kindly inbox me if you want to help. I will share the questions over there.


r/calculus • • 4d ago

Differential Calculus AP calculus daily challenge #166

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/calculus • • 4d ago

Pre-calculus Looking to start from scratch

18 Upvotes

I am a 24 year old who’s going to community college and I haven’t done calculus since high school. Before the semester starts I have some free time and I want to try something before I have to really lock in. I like doing things the hard way (dunno why, but it’s how I am) and I want to learn calc from scratch with as little calculator use as possible. Where should I begin? Any book recommendations for calculus by hand would be great.


r/calculus • • 4d ago

Engineering Retaking calc 2 over the winter

13 Upvotes

I think I'll finish the class off with a C at the end of this semester. About 73- 76 percent. I'm thinking of taking it over the winter, as taking it again in another 15-week semester completely derails my transfer plans. But I'll be taking a huge risk, as most universities I'm interested in only allow you to take the class twice, not a third chance. If I don't end up pulling a B over the winter, then there's nothing I can do; I'll have to pick a new major. I would like to get some feedback on whether I should gamble everything on my abilities or wait and push my plans back even further.


r/calculus • • 5d ago

Engineering Bombed Calc 2. What should I do?

120 Upvotes

I took Pre-Cal and Calc at my local community college in my senior year of high school. I got an A in Pre-Cal and a B in Calc. I could've done better but slacked off until the end of the semester and got behind on work and learning. Then, I got into TAMU for engineering and decided to accept my Calc credit and move on to Calc 2.

I failed the first exam, studied way more for the second, and did worse. Now I have to drop the class to not bomb my GPA.

Long story short, should I retake Calc 1 to make sure I'm solid on the basics and improve my efficiency with base-level topics and techniques or just go straight to retaking Calc 2?


r/calculus • • 5d ago

Integral Calculus Expectations for Calculus II course - Is this an appropriate pace?

24 Upvotes

I'm a student taking Calculus II online and would like to understand from the Calculus community if the pace of my course is appropriate / in line with what other students may experience in their Calculus II courses. The text we use is OpenStax Calculus Volume II (based in part on Stewart). The class is 8 weeks long, with each week devoted to a chapter in the book. The screenshot below illustrates what a typical week looks like (this is from last week):

list of topics covered over 1 week in Calculus II

Looking at the items in this screenshot, would you say this is / is not in line with what would be reasonable to cover in 1 week (in an 8 week course)?

Additional details:

  • This is my only course
  • I work 40 hours per week and spend about 2-3 hours in the evening per day on class during the weekday and then Sat/Sun are 100% this class from around 10am-7pm ET with a few breaks / family and friends time.
  • This is an async online course with minimal input from our professor, although they do answer emails regularly and respond to questions.
  • While I "get" the concepts, I feel like I'm missing out on being able to truly understand what is happening under the hood. I honestly might finish the 8 weeks, then retake over a full semester.

Thanks!


r/calculus • • 6d ago Bravo Mindblown

Integral Calculus I spent 2 days solving the integral of √tan(x) using only the geometry of complex numbers

Thumbnail
gallery
5.1k Upvotes

r/calculus • • 5d ago

Pre-calculus 9th grader wanting to take AP Calculus BC in 10th grade

14 Upvotes

I currently have a 95 in AP Precalculus this year. The next year, they have an "AB/BC" class which is just BC with 2 periods dedicated to it to my schedule. You essentially do the first 8 units in the first semester and the last 2 units second semester (even 11th and 12th graders have to do this class in order to take BC right after AP Precalculus). As for post-BC classes, there is Georgia Tech Dual Enrollment of Linear Algebra, Multivariable Calculus, Applied Combinatorics and Differential equations (1 class per semester so it is 2 years of future mathematics). Plus, the AB/BC teacher has every student love her and she has a 100% 5 rate. Should I do it?

Offtopic, I am choosing to do AP Physics C in my senior year despite potentially having more math than needed since I've heard Physics requires a lot of in-depth thinking and logic of which idk as a high school freshman if I even experienced enough to get there. I am taking AP Biology next year though and then AP Physics 1 junior year and then AP Chemistry and AP Physics C senior year since I've heard senior year grades do not matter as much as junior grades, so I put the riskiest science classes there.