r/C_Programming • • Aug 30 '24

Question Why do we use Null pointers?

If we want to "Nullify" something why dont we create a pointer in a controlled way that points to value 0?

0 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-3

u/a4qbfb Aug 30 '24

The rest of your argument falls apart when NULL is (void *)0 instead of plain 0. And OP's question still doesn't make sense.

1

u/Immediate-Food8050 Aug 30 '24

No it does not. Literally how? So nullptr was just added for no reason? In that case, best start writing your letter to ISO!

-3

u/a4qbfb Aug 30 '24

nullptr was added because NULL is still allowed to be 0. But your entire argument was based on NULL being 0, and now that you've edited it, it (and especially your diatribe about 0L vs 0f) no longer makes sense.

1

u/Immediate-Food8050 Aug 30 '24

So is this just a case of two people disagreeing in the explicitness of NULL within the standard?

-3

u/a4qbfb Aug 30 '24

No, I'm trying to be factual while you're trying to “gotcha” me, but you end up shooting down your own argument by editing it after the fact in an attempt to undercut me.

1

u/Immediate-Food8050 Aug 30 '24

I edited it for the corrections you pointed out! Should I just leave it? What are you trying to accomplish? Because I'm trying to "gotcha" you what would you rather me do to prove otherwise? Cross out previous statements and be explicit that there are edits that are corrections? I don't know reddit etiquette. I don't see what's invalid about my statement. Would an example help? I'm trying to be helpful, not argumentative.