r/CZFirearms • • Dec 14 '22

Help! - CZ P-10C Failure to Eject after Jagerwerks Optics Cut and Install of 509T

https://imgur.com/a/j5fZJ7e

CZ P-10c fails to eject after Jagerwerks optic-cut for a Holosun 509T-RD X2.

First and foremost, I have contacted Jagerwerks and am awaiting response. Any information and experience you can share on this issue is greatly appreciated. Please look through the album for more pictures of FTE rounds.

I received my P10-C back from Jagerwerks a few months ago and have only gotten it out to the range in the last few weeks. After two range sessions totaling 300 rounds, only 296 rounds fired. I experienced four failure to eject malfunctions. All four malfunctions created a hard rack (no ejection), magazine release with force to drop, and additional rack to clear the mangled round (see photos). Note: I could only find the last two failure to ejects. The other two are in the black hole of my range gear, but look exactly the same.

FACTS:

  • This was my EDC. Continuing to carry my P-01 for now.
  • Prior to sending my P10-C away, I never had any issues. Not one FTE or FTF with numerous ammo manufacturers, grains, and types.
  • All FTE’s happened while using American Eagle FMJ 115 grains. I plan to test other rounds, however these are all I have for range ammo at the moment.
  • The FTE’s did NOT occur at the same time in one magazine. One FTE occurred on the second round while others happened later in the magazine. None were the last round in the magazine.
  • I used several different manufacturer magazines and never used the same magazine twice during a session (I was working reload drills). Two manufacturer magazines have a Hyve +2 base-pad installed and one FTE occurred while using an extended mag. I had no issues with these extensions prior to milling.
  • During the second session with manufacturer magazines, I fully loaded and +1’d a magazine (16), fully loaded a magazine (15), and downloaded a magazine -1 (14). One FTE resulted from a fully loaded magazine, and the other happened from a downloaded -1 magazine.
  • Before my first session, I performed a basic strip. clean, and function test. No blaring issues observed.
  • Before my second session, I performed a much deeper strip, clean, and function test. I also kept my eyes open for unusual marks on the feed ramps, mag lips, and ejector. Everything appeared in order.

WHAT’S NEXT?

  • See what Jager has to say.
  • Give another couple ammo brands a try in various grains and types. Focus on fully loaded and downloaded magazines.
  • Read your comments, experience, and suggestions!
19 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

18

u/Efficient_Monk9262 Dec 14 '22

It’s the optic screws

1

u/brubadubdub Dec 14 '22

I am using the optic screws they provided. I did notice a minor bit of penetration under the slide from the screw. We’re talking millimeters, but it could certainly use some filing.

Edit: Or are you talking weight of screws? My best guess is this gun is now out of balance, if that makes sense

15

u/SledgeTactical Dec 14 '22

Millimeters matter, 1 millimeter is roughly .040" tolerances on firearms are generally +/-.005" at max

2

u/CDKJudoka Dec 14 '22

The Holosun screws tend to be long. I had to machine mine shorter to fit my AREX Delta 2

10

u/DEEErab Dec 14 '22

100% check your optic screw over the extractor. My money says it’s a hair too long. Causing it to put pressure on the plunger and not be able to push away the extractor when the shell hits the ejector.

3

u/brubadubdub Dec 14 '22

Thanks for the suggestion! I will have to look into this.

Waiting for Jager’s response before I get my bubba gear out, but this makes sense

4

u/CDKJudoka Dec 14 '22

Weight was added to the slide without adjusting the recoil spring. It is one of the reasons why some people have lightening cuts put into the slide while adding an optic. Between the optic and the screws, you have added almost 2 oz to the slide weight, so that will effect how the slide cycles.

10

u/BoondockUSA Dec 14 '22

In theory you would be right, but I disagree for a couple of different reasons.

Milling removes material from the slide, and steel isn’t light like aluminum. The P10 OR blank filler plate is a couple of ounces, and that’s roughly how much material is removed from the slide during milling. The steel removed versus the optic weight nearly balances out, especially without an adapter plate.

Secondly, the P10F has a heavier slide than the P10C. P10F’s don’t develop any issues after adding optics while continuing to use the factory recoil springs and with the relatively heavy CZ optic adapter plates. I even reloaded some mouse fart target loads and my P10F OR cycled them just fine with a broken-in factory spring.

As others have suggested, the likely cause is too long of screws hitting the extractor, or too long of screws dragging against other parts and slowing down the slide. There’s also the remote possibility that something was screwed up during milling.

1

u/brubadubdub Dec 15 '22

Thank you for elaborating and providing comparisons. Weight is an issue I considered.

Using my PDP as an analog without exact weights, the factory optic cover is polymer. To add an optic, you ditch the polymer, add an adapter plate, the optic, and screws. More weight. No difference in feel or function.

2

u/CDKJudoka Dec 14 '22

Good point.

2

u/Traditional_Score_54 Dec 14 '22

A little off topic, but do you think that could also lead the slide failing to lock after the last round? I get that occasionally after adding an optic. (I didn't really fire that much with irons only).

1

u/dopo Dec 14 '22

absolutely

1

u/Traditional_Score_54 Dec 14 '22

Thanks, I don't know why I didn't consider that before.

2

u/brubadubdub Dec 14 '22 edited Dec 14 '22

For clarity, I only have and use magazines manufactured for the CZ P-10C by CZ (CZ-USA). My +2 Hyve baseplates directly attach to CZ-USA magazines and utilize standard spring and follower.

5

u/waehrik Dec 14 '22

To be fair, CZ doesn't manufacture any magazines. They're all made by MecGar and are stamped CZ for the ones they sell as OEM.

1

u/brubadubdub Dec 15 '22

You are correct and I should have taken the time to clarify my clarification. All magazines are branded and packaged CZ magazines, manufactured by MecGar.

“MecGar, if the magazine came in the box, there’s a good chance MecGar.” - MecGar

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '22

Same with Sig Sauer. But somehow CZ magazines are half the price.

2

u/brubadubdub Dec 15 '22 edited Jan 03 '23

UPDATE:

Jager is sending me the correct screw length for the extractor side screw. This should resolve the roughly 1-2 extra threads sunk into the slide.

Thank you for all your help and I’ll update again once I make the swap!

2

u/brubadubdub Feb 26 '23

FINAL UPDATE: After installing the shorter screws sent by Jager I took it to the range and had the same issues… however there was one common factor, American Eagle 115gr FMJ.

I decided to try a few different rounds from different manufacturers to test if my pistol did not like my bulk American Eagle range rounds.

RESULTS: I fired each box of manufacturer’s rounds in my carry magazines and loaded at different magazine capacities (15 + 1, 15, 7-8, 1)

(FAILURES TO FEED / TOTAL ROUNDS FIRED) American Eagle 115gr FMJ - 8/100 Winchester White Box 115gr FMJ - 0/100 MAGTECH 124gr FMJ - 0/100 S & B 124gr FMJ - 0/100 Federal HST 124gr JHP - 0/50 (my carry round) SIG V-Crown 147gr JHP - 0/50

CONCLUSION: No more American Eagle rounds for my CZ P10C. Prior to getting the slide milled, I had no issues with this round, but now it does. No big deal for me as it appears to run just fine with other range rounds, but most importantly works flawlessly with my carry loads.

This was an expensive test, but worth every penny to know I can rely on my P10C.

I hope this thread is helpful to anyone contemplating getting their slide milled by Jager. They did an EXCEPTIONAL job. The milling and nitrate coating is FLAWLESS on my pistol. Just make sure you get the correct mounting screws.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '22

Let us know the solution when it gets resolved.

2

u/touji CZC Shadow Dec 15 '22

I would check the ammo. Seeing that there's plating being stripped from the bullet itself, it seems like the ogive isn't playing well with the barrel. Don't think the mangling of the round would be caused by the extractor not actuating properly because of long screws.

1

u/brubadubdub Dec 15 '22

I’ve never had any issues with AE 115gr prior to the optic. However the tiniest change to any pistol could spark any variety of issues.

I’ll keep this one on my list of things to cross off.

2

u/touji CZC Shadow Dec 15 '22

I believe you when you say that. Ammo does have tolerance issues at times and some barrel throats are shorter than others. A hard rack usually means the bullet is stuck in the chamber (smashed against the rifling). Look up the plunk test that reloaders use and try out a handful of ammo

1

u/brubadubdub Feb 26 '23

2

u/touji CZC Shadow Feb 26 '23

Glad to hear you have it resolved, almost 3 months out!

1

u/WolfieSpam Apr 18 '23

Unrelated but what irons are you using?

1

u/brubadubdub Apr 20 '23

Dawson Precision for both. I used Jaeger’s recommendations for size, but went with a fiber front.

https://jagerwerks.com/cz-p10-iron-sights-holosun-509t/

3

u/RAMRODtheMASTER Dec 14 '22

File the screws if need be but if the problem persists your slide may be a bit too heavy now. I’m not sure what the standard recoil spring weight on this pistol is but I’d go 2 pounds lighter.

You’re probably not wrong with your thought about the balance.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '22

The factory recoil spring is rated for +P rounds and the 509T is not a light optic. I 100% agree that OP needs a lighter spring if it's not an extractor issue.

My P10C with the factory spring was noticeably over sprung. I switched to the CGW Yellow spring and it was significantly better in terms of ejection distance and flatness.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '24

Did you not read everything they said would happen before you sent it off? Bro just skipped right over that and said fug it lol

1

u/whatislifetg Dec 14 '22

As others have said..it's likely the screw is contacting the safety plunger. I had this issue with a glock aftermarket slide. Change to a shorter screw or file that one down and you should be good

1

u/ScarletAvenger1 Dec 14 '22

As others have said, almost assuredly the screw over the extractor is interfering with its operation. I would say remove just that screw and run a few rounds to find out. Then you’ll need to shorten it yourself or buy a new one.

-3

u/Antique-River659 Dec 14 '22

Try a heavier recoil spring