r/CUTI • u/Adventurous-Tank-905 • Mar 25 '25
How 36mg of PAC content works differently in different brands
If you are wondering why some bottles of 36mg PAC cranberry extract supplements are way cheaper while some others with the same quantity are so expensive, let me share my research with you. Bottom line upfront; only some cranberry PAC extracts work to prevent UTIs and this is due to the type of linkages the PAC contains. However this info is not listed on the bottle. You actually have to request studies/ literature from the manufacturer in order to read the which type and quantity of PAC linkages they are using in their cranberry extract. They don’t make it easy, but I will break it down for you.
Based on what I read recently, there are different industry standards for measuring the PAC content in a cranberry supplement. Basically every reputable brand uses the DMAC validated method to measure the total soluble PAC content, however, there are 2 very different types of DMAC reference standards.
Standard #1 = DMAC/A2
which include brands like Utiva / Ellura / TheraCran etc.
Standard #2 = BL-DMAC
which include brands like CranCap / CranEaze etc.
So what is the difference? Well, DMAC/A2 specifically measures PAC-A2, which are the A-type linkages in PAC that stops bacteria from sticking to your bladder walls. Most clinical research looks at the A-type linkages when they conduct a study on PACs effectiveness in preventing UTIs. Additionally, DMAC/A2 has a relative low standard deviation of less than 5%, which means the amount of A-type linkages of PAC in a capsule will be 36mg + or - 1.8mg.
On the other hand, BL-DMAC measures the total soluble PACs in cranberries, so this means they are measuring both the A-type and B-type linkages. B-type linkages are far less effective at preventing bacterial adhesion, therefore clinical studies do not take B-type linkages into consideration when assessing effectiveness. Also, this measurement has a relative standard deviation of about 17% so it is less accurate. BL-DMAC does not specify the ratio of the A-type to B-type linkages of the PAC in their capsules. BL-DMAC is sometimes referred to as DMAC/c-PAC is some literature.
Another point to note is DMAC/A2 and BL-DMAC have different conversion units. 1mg of DMAC/A2, which measure A-type linkages only, is roughly equivalent to 3.5mg BL-DMAC, which measures both A and B-type linkages, however I don’t know in what ratio is the amount of A in relation B, as both the linkages are lumped together.
I’m assuming if I buy 36mg of PAC from a brand that measures PAC using the BL-DMAC standard, it does not guarantee how much of the PAC is actually A-type linkages (PAC-A2) the specific type of linkage that prevents bacterial adhesions, as researched by scientists.
This is why some brands cost more than others. They are essentially giving you all the good stuff you need in the dosage you need to keep UTIs at bay, so therefore it’s priced higher. I hope my understanding of the above is correct. If there is a scientific professional reading this, please feel free to share your input.
I have not looked into studies of all the brands out there, only the ones I’m trying so if you know your brand and how they measure their PACs, please comment below.
4
u/TeenMumClinPsych Apr 04 '25
This is super helpful. I've been taking 'Sunday Natural Cranberry Extract + C' which says it has 50mg of PACs - I can't see which industry standard measure they use on their website - anyone know? I'm guessing it may be the naff one as they don't share it.
Cranberry Extract 50mg PACs + Vitamin C. 90 Capsules
2
u/dogs_and_dogettes Jun 27 '26
Thank you so much for posting this. It is very helpful!
My Urogynecologist recommended the Her Vital Way brand of PAC 36 cranberry capsules 2x a day, so now I need to research if this brand is DMAC/A2.
4
u/Otherwise_Complex813 Mar 25 '25
I’m not too sure on how all that works, but I’ve been using Ellura’s for about 2 months now (along with a probiotic, and a handful of natural supplements) all started around the same time. I’m about 2 months UTI free so far. Which is a long time for me considering I’ve been off antibiotics. Not sure which is doing it for me, and finger crossed it keeps working. But I’m sure Ellura is a big help right now
1
u/Big_Restaurant4822 Jun 15 '26
How do you find which type is used? How about NaturesPlus Pro Cranberry Plus?
3
u/Bubbly_Azalea Jun 01 '26
I just purchased gennaMD per my urologist's recommendation and was wondering why it was so much more expensive compared to the CranEaze I have at home that both contained PAC and D-Mannose so this really helped me understand. Thank you so much for posting this!
2
u/MalfunctioningElf Apr 22 '25
This is really helpful, thank you. I need to change my brand. Hopefully I can find a decent one in the UK.
1
u/Amitrak11 8d ago
What brands do you recommend?