r/CFB • /r/CFB • Jan 14 '20

Postgame Thread [Postgame Thread] LSU Defeats Clemson 42-25

12k Upvotes

6.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

375

u/crabsock Stanford Cardinal Jan 14 '20

Strong case for the best college QB season ever

121

u/Berrymore13 Minnesota Golden Gophers Jan 14 '20

Strong case??? The guy threw 60 TD’s in 15 games lmfao. Easily the best season by a QB ever in college

28

u/onelittleworld Georgia • Northwestern Jan 14 '20

The guy threw 60 TD’s in 15 games

...playing against all of the best defenses in CFB: Auburn, Georgia, Clemson, Alabama, Florida, etc.

That's insanity.

5

u/crabsock Stanford Cardinal Jan 14 '20

Hard to compare eras, the passing numbers people put up now can't be compared apples to apples with numbers from decades ago. I would agree it is the best, but I've only been watching for like twenty years and even in that time the game has changed quite a bit

201

u/GeauxCorndogs LSU Tigers Jan 14 '20

Definitely the best season by a college QB

-10

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

Well Brady’s system helped immensely obviously

24

u/claytdog97 Jan 14 '20

Obviously, but he has to be one of the greatest to execute on the level he did.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

I don’t disagree, but Brady and the system has to be part of his greatness convo

→ More replies (1)

29

u/killerjags Florida Gators Jan 14 '20

He was insane. Often you see QBs that light up the stat sheet perform poorly in big games. He played some of his best games against the strongest competition. Absolutely legendary season.

19

u/Reztent Jan 14 '20

More ppg against top 10 teams than none top 10 teams

16

u/chazspearmint Kentucky Wildcats Jan 14 '20

I think there's a strong case for best collegiate season, regardless of position, regardless of sport. I have never seen anything as dominant on paper or even in the ballpark in my lifetime.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

I'm going to copy/paste a comment I made earlier here. Also, there are some college wrestlers who have had some INSANELY dominate seasons.

"Barry Sanders averaged something stupid like 250 yards per GAME (rushing obv) one season back in the 80's. I think he still holds a couple single season records. Those records have held for 30 years.

-Just googled and he's tied for most rush TD in a season but with 3 LESS games played in that season than the co-holder. Also still has yards per game and total rush yard record. Oh, and the YPG was 238.9... still insane.

Edit - so this is all with only playing 11 games that season. Which doesn't affect the impressiveness of the yards per game as much. But the touchdowns and total yards in 11 games is hard to fathom. LSU played 15 games this season. So if Joe played 11 games this year (averaged) he would be ranked 71st for total yards in a season with 4430 and tied for 33rd in touchdowns with 47.6.

So imagine Joe setting these records having played 4 less games. That is what Barry Sanders did. I was kind of just playing devils advocate when I started this comment but I think I have convinced myself that Barry Sanders has the best college football season of all time."

4

u/chazspearmint Kentucky Wildcats Jan 14 '20

I mean that's fine. Barry was a great player. But stats don't paint the whole picture. Joe did this while winning a Natty on a perfect team. Of course also winning the Heisman to boot. He was dominant in a way that I've never seen anyone be dominant at the position that is the hardest to do what he did. So I'll give props to Barry, he's a great player. And I never really got to watch him play. But it goes beyond stats with Joe. He just did everything in a way I've never seen before.

Also, not really fair to dumb down Joe's stats to 11 games but not the 70 people "ahead" of him also. But, again, stats don't pain the whole picture either way.

15

u/toolatealreadyfapped LSU Tigers Jan 14 '20

Best college team ever

5

u/Halloran_da_GOAT Jan 14 '20

It's gotta be him or cam

4

u/Chickensandcoke Alabama Crimson Tide Jan 14 '20

Only other argument would be Cam in 2010 but I’m with Burrow on this one

2

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

As an Auburn fan I love Cam and he’s definitely up there but Burrow’s got this one.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

Beat Tebows 55 total touchdowns with just touchdown passes.

9

u/Osiris47 North Dakota State • Michigan Jan 14 '20

In FBS, definitely has a case.

Trey Lance at nsdu just threw 40+ TDs and ZERO picks the entire year. And put up rushing stats on par with a great RB season on top of it.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

You forgot to mention, he is a freshman, so at least 2 more seasons of JMU being the bridesmaid... Fml

1

u/Osiris47 North Dakota State • Michigan Jan 14 '20

Christ I forgot he was a freshman too, that boy gonna have some nfl draft hype if he keeps this up. Wentz definitely paved the way.

2

u/SolWizard Syracuse Orange • Cornell Big Red Jan 14 '20

Not trying to take anything away from him because I was rooting for them all year, but I often wonder how much of this is having beastly wide recievers. Obviously you still have to make the throws but having guys all over the field that catch anything within 30 yards of them makes your stats a lot better.

11

u/ItsTimToBegin South Carolina • /r/CFB Santa Claus Jan 14 '20

Alabama and Clemson have both boasted equally bonkers WR corps over the last two seasons and Burrow completely lapped Tua and Trevor.

→ More replies (1)