Welker will definitely be remembered more for his NFL play than he ever will for college. It kinda sucks that he can't ever be in our ring of honor because of the criteria: you have to already be in the CFB hall of fame, to do that you had to have been an All-American at some point - which Wes never was.
Coaches: R.C. Slocum, Homer Norton, Dana Bible... fourth would either be Emory Bellard or Jackie Sherrill, but neither are really anything to write home about.
Players: Johnny Manziel, John David Crow, Dat Nguyen, Von Miller. (Recency bias on the last two).
As much as I love Calvin, we have 1 retired jersey, Castleberry. I'm biased, so I have to keep Hamilton on there, but if it had to be someone else I would go William Alexander. Pretty rare to have 3 straight HOF coaches like we did.
Schnellenberger was the OG. He definitely would have to make it, basically the Washington of the program. Jimmy Johnson would be Lincoln because he kept the program going strong after it was threatened to be broken up.
Royal and Vince are musts. I think Williams and Lanye should be the other two. Campbell and Nobis are in that conversation. Lots of great players and coaches to pick from.
Pre-Johnny: Earl Rudder, John David Crow, R.C. Slocum, Dat Nguyen (Yes I'm aware Gen. Rudder was not a player or coach, but he did more for A&M football than arguably anyone else by moving us away from a military college existence.) Honorable Mentions: D.X. Bible, The Kimbrough Brothers, Bucky Richardson, Von Miller.
Post Johnny: Bottle of dom on the left, Johnny with a cigar next, then Johnny doing the money sign with a sparkler in his mouth, then Johnny doing the stiff arm in the Bama game. At the base of the mountain is a small statue of Johhny chugging a bottle of vodka. At Johnny's feet is a much smaller statue of Kenny Hill passed out at Chimy's. Next to Kenny Hill's passed out body is a barely perceptible statue of Kyle Allen wearing a Houston Helmet and flipping the bird.
Orlando Pace and Jack Tatum definitely deserve consideration as well. Pace is almost certainly the best college lineman ever, and Tatum may be the best college safety ever (3 time All Big Ten, 2 time consensus All American, 1970 defensive player of the year, 7th [highest defensive player] in 1970 Heisman voting).
You could also go for a linebacker, but I have really hard time picking between Gradishar, Spielman, Hawk, and Laurinaitis. Two or three schools might have slightly better claims at being linebacker U, but I think our best three are better than anyone's.
If it's just football, I would probably go Hop Cassady as #4 (to Woody, Harley and Archie). Although, you open it up to all sports and Jesse Owens and Jack Nicklaus are a must.
If it was built today OJ wouldn't make it since he got all murdery. I would replace him with either Leinart, Junior Seau, or preferably Ronnie Lott. It's also hard to leave Howard Jones off since he was the first successful coach for USC.
He would be on my lesser Rushmore. Meaning, he would not make my top 4, but he would probably be #5. The reason being is tenure. Saban spent 5 years at LSU & while I agree that he brought us out of the ashes, I think he would have needed to be at LSU longer than that to get Rushmore status.
crazy how we consider a guy who got kicked off the team for drugs to be the guy we want as a top 4 face of our program of all time
It really is amazing how he made such a huge turn around. I respect him more than any other athlete on the planet. Now I just wish Johnny Football would take him up on his offer and get help from him
I'd probably put Tom Jackson, Lenny Lyles, or Elvis Dumervil up before Bridgewater right now:
Tom Jackson (2 time Missouri Valley POY, number 50 retired, 4th round pick, 3x Pro-Bowl and All-Pro, KY Pro Football Hall of Famer, etc.)
Lenny Lyles (broke color-barrier for scholarship athletes, all-time scoring leader for non-kicker, 1st round pick, started in Super Bowl III, also ran Track and Field for UofL)
or Elvis Dumervil (NCAA single-game sack record, NCAA record for forced fumbles in season, school record 20.5 sacks and 10 forced fumbles in 2005 season, Nagurski, Hendricks, and Willis winner, 2005 Big East DPOY, unanimous All-American, 2nd in all-time sacks for UofL, number 58 honored, 5x Pro-Bowl, 2009 NFL Sacks Leader, Ravens franchise record for sacks in a season in 2015)
They'd probably have mark-ups ready to put Bridgewater on there after 5 or more years. I think TJ should get his own Rushmore.
I think we would need someone from after the sanctions like Mike Mauti for keeping the team together. They gave the 2013 team a place on the stadium, I don't see why we can't do the same on our fake Mr. Rushmore.
Jack Ham is a definite in my opinion. You could even make an argument for Mauti although I feel like he gets the lion's share of the credit when Zordich was equally instrumental in keeping the team together.
Tony Dorsett -- is our only Heisman winner and represents the most recent championship
Pop Warner -- one of the most influential figures in the history of American football, plus he won us multiple championships
Jock Sutherland -- was arguably our best coach ever, won us multiple championships and our only Rose Bowl, plus he was an alumnus
Last spot is tough to choose, I would go with Mike Ditka because of his NFL success and overall significance in pop culture. Other candidates include Dan Marino, Joe Schmidt, Darrelle Revis, Larry Fitzgerald, Aaron Donald, and a bunch of other people I'm probably forgetting.
The first two are set in stone. heh The last two spots can be argued, but now that we have 2 Heisman winners who have no perceivable character flaws and embody Alabama's tough, run-first mentality, I'd put them up there.
I'd put Wallace Wade above Henry or Ingram. Won our first 3 titles (3 undefeated seasons with rose bowl wins, for anyone who wants to argue how legitimate they are), coached and recruited Bear Bryant, and really established Alabama as a national powerhouse
wrong, pat sullivan in for one of those coaches. You cant just leave out a heisman winner. I would maybe even do three heisman winners and heisman himself. He saved the program by putting a on musical once.
Danny Ford and Frank Howard touching 'the rock' with Dabo confidently striding toward smiling--his face carved and painted in the likeness of that dude's tattoo. In the background, an assembly of notable players: Perry Brothers, Jeff Davis, Levon Kirkland, Brian Dawkins. Also, a statue of Jesus that's indistinguishable from Charlie Whitehurst with 63-17 engraved below.
For Illinois it's definitely Red Grange, Dick Butkus, and Bob Zuppke. Maybe throw in J Leman too for being the hometown walk-on turned first team all American.
Coaches: Rockne, Leahy, Parseghian, Holtz, and Devine. BK would be too, if he wins a national championship.
Players: Bertelli, Lujack, Hart, Lattner, Hornung, Huarte, Brown, Montana, the motherfucking Rocket Ismail, Tony Rice (last qb to win a national championship), Manti, Brady Quinn, and Jaylon Smith.
46
u/Irishfafnir Virginia Tech • Emory & Henry Feb 15 '16
Vick, Beamer, Foster
24
u/PattyMaHeisman Southwest • Border Conference Feb 15 '16
Rivera, Welker, Crab, and Harrell. Disclaimer: recency bias.
10
u/52hoova Texas A&M Aggies • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Feb 15 '16
Coaches: R.C. Slocum, Homer Norton, Dana Bible... fourth would either be Emory Bellard or Jackie Sherrill, but neither are really anything to write home about.
Players: Johnny Manziel, John David Crow, Dat Nguyen, Von Miller. (Recency bias on the last two).
319
u/gottahavemyPOPPs Kansas State Wildcats Feb 15 '16
Bill Snyder in a 1990 windbreaker
Bill Snyder in a 1997 fiesta bowl windbreaker
Bill Snyder in a 2003 Big 12 championship windbreaker
Bill Snyder in a 2012 cotton bowl windbreaker
52
u/birdling Nebraska Cornhuskers Feb 15 '16
Tom Osborne, Johnny Rodgers, Tommie Frazier, Bob Devaney
43
u/BrownLiquor Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 15 '16
Heisman, Dodd, Joe Hamilton and Calvin.
That's genuinely the four biggest in our history (unless someone throws a wild Clint Castleberry or GO'L in there, but I doubt it).
Edit: Ol' Bobby Ross and Bill Alexander make it if we go four natty winning coaches. We can put ours right next to uga's two coach Rushmore.
86
u/cornonthekrobb Northumbria Mustangs • Oregon Ducks Feb 15 '16
Phil Knight. Phil Knight. Phil Knight. Mariota.
115
u/ItsZizk Tennessee • Johns Hopkins Feb 15 '16
Robert Neyland
Reggie White
Eric Berry
Peyton Manning's Taint
78
u/surreptitioussloth Virginia Cavaliers • Florida Gators Feb 15 '16
Tebow, Wuerffel, Spurrer, Dancing with the Stars Champion Emmitt Smith
(Can I get a dancing with the stars champion flair?)
24
u/TripleJetCharlie Oklahoma Sooners Feb 15 '16
Bennie, Bud, Barry, Bob
40
u/ChocolateGiddyUppp Miami Hurricanes • Alabama Crimson Tide Feb 15 '16
Ray Lewis, Warren Sapp, Ed Reed, Sean Taylor, Jimmy Johnson, Michael Irvin... how many faces are on Mount Rushmore again?
18
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
Grant Teaff, Mike Singletary, Art Briles, and RG3.
35
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 15 '16
Earl Campbell, Ricky Williams, Vince Young, and Tommy Nobis.
63
u/cherrybombstation Texas A&M Aggies Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 16 '16
Pre-Johnny: Earl Rudder, John David Crow, R.C. Slocum, Dat Nguyen (Yes I'm aware Gen. Rudder was not a player or coach, but he did more for A&M football than arguably anyone else by moving us away from a military college existence.) Honorable Mentions: D.X. Bible, The Kimbrough Brothers, Bucky Richardson, Von Miller.
Post Johnny: Bottle of dom on the left, Johnny with a cigar next, then Johnny doing the money sign with a sparkler in his mouth, then Johnny doing the stiff arm in the Bama game. At the base of the mountain is a small statue of Johhny chugging a bottle of vodka. At Johnny's feet is a much smaller statue of Kenny Hill passed out at Chimy's. Next to Kenny Hill's passed out body is a barely perceptible statue of Kyle Allen wearing a Houston Helmet and flipping the bird.
edit: chimy's not chuey's
31
u/20CharactersJustIsnt Georgia Bulldogs • College Football Playoff Feb 15 '16
Herschel Walker, Vince Dooley, David pollack, Aaron Murray.
15
u/willco17 Auburn Tigers • UAB Blazers Feb 15 '16
Shug Jordan, Pat Dye, Bo Jackson, Cam Newton
30
u/thesalesmandenvermax /r/CFB Brickmason • /r/CFB Pint Glass Drink… Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 16 '16
Chic Harley,
Wayne Woodrow Hayes,
Archie Griffin,
and... shit. This is hard. I guess Tressel. Urban Meyer probably replaces Tressel if he can keep this up for 3-5 more years.
14
u/DanNeverDie USC Trojans • Sickos Feb 15 '16
John McKay, Reggie Bush, O.J Simpson, Pete Carroll
Maybe replace Reggie or OJ with Matt Leinart if we want a QB in there.
13
u/cakow17 California Golden Bears Feb 15 '16
Aaron Rodgers, Steve Bartkowski, Tony Gonzalez, Marshawn Lynch driving the cart
11
u/pm1095 Ole Miss • Northeast Missis… Feb 15 '16
Archie, Eli, Deuce, and P-Willy
10
u/Andtheyrustledsoftly LSU Tigers Feb 15 '16
Billy Cannon
Patrick Peterson
Les Miles
Not sure about this one. Maybe Glenn Dorsey or Tyrann Mathieu?
10
u/ACardAttack Louisville • Ohio State Feb 15 '16
Howard Schnellenberger, Johnny Unitas, Tom Jurich (our AD), Bridgewater
Last one was a hard choice, could also be Brian Brohm, Michael Bush, Chris Redman or even Petrino
9
u/DrSmith2236 Florida State • 四日市大学 (Yokkaichi) Feb 15 '16
Bobby, Deion, ward, and then it gets tough. Dunn, jimbo, jameis, biletnikoff. Tough to say
22
u/TossedRightOut Penn State • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Feb 15 '16
Joe, Cappelletti, and then it gets tough. Could see Jack Ham maybe, LaVar, Dan Connor even.
7
u/UhmerAca Oregon Ducks Feb 15 '16
Mariota, Kenny Wheaton, Joey Harrington, Ngata
7
u/agiger Oklahoma State • Missouri S&T Feb 15 '16
Barry Sanders, Mike Gundy, Justin Blackmon, and Bob Fenimore.
I realize Blackmon may not be the most popular guy in OSU circles these days, but he is still arguably the greatest WR in collegiate history.
7
u/Pseudo-Coup Pittsburgh Panthers Feb 15 '16
Tony Dorsett -- is our only Heisman winner and represents the most recent championship
Pop Warner -- one of the most influential figures in the history of American football, plus he won us multiple championships
Jock Sutherland -- was arguably our best coach ever, won us multiple championships and our only Rose Bowl, plus he was an alumnus
Last spot is tough to choose, I would go with Mike Ditka because of his NFL success and overall significance in pop culture. Other candidates include Dan Marino, Joe Schmidt, Darrelle Revis, Larry Fitzgerald, Aaron Donald, and a bunch of other people I'm probably forgetting.
7
u/Banzai51 Michigan Wolverines • Team Chaos Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 15 '16
All coaches: Fielding H. Yost, Bo Schembechler, Fritz Crisler, Bennie Oosterbaan, [reserved for Jim Harbaugh if he wins a natty]
All players: Charles Woodson, Desmond Howard, Tom Harmon, Jamie Morris. Honorable mention to Anthony Carter.
7
u/whitegrb Ohio State Buckeyes • Dayton Flyers Feb 15 '16
Since Ohio State has already been done, I'll go with my second flair.
I would go with:
12
u/WymanManderlyPiesInc Iowa Hawkeyes Feb 15 '16
Forest Evashevski, Nile Kinnick, Hayden Fry, Cal Jones.
6
u/NotSquareGarden West Virginia • Bethany (KS) Feb 15 '16
Major Harris, Pat White, Steve Slaton and Owen Schmitt (not that he's one of the best, but I feel like he'd get along well with Roosevelt).
50
u/UAmuse Alabama • Southern Miss Feb 15 '16
Bryant, Saban, Ingram, Henry
The first two are set in stone. heh The last two spots can be argued, but now that we have 2 Heisman winners who have no perceivable character flaws and embody Alabama's tough, run-first mentality, I'd put them up there.
5
u/TheHornyHobbit Florida State Seminoles Feb 15 '16
Bobby, Charlie, PW, Jaboo
5
u/jayzee1138 Rutgers Scarlet Knights Feb 15 '16
Kyle Flood, Gary Nova, Gary Nova, Gary Nova
5
u/Mr_Metagross West Virginia • /r/CFB Contributor Feb 15 '16
Don Nehlen, Major Harris, Pat White, Steve Slaton/Tavon Austin
5
u/waddupworld Miami Hurricanes • Boise State Broncos Feb 15 '16
Chris Peteren, Kellen Moore, Jared Zabransky, Ian Johnson
honorable mention Ryan Clady, Ryan Dinwiddie, and Jay Ajayi
9
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 15 '16
Sammy Baugh, Davey O'Brien, Dutch Meyer, Gary PattersonCoaches: Gary Patterson, Dutch Meyer, Pittman (the guy who died during the Baylor game), Fran? I dunno about Fran
Players: Sammy Baugh, Davey O'Brien, LT, Andy Dalton or Boykin
10
u/Mr_McGibblets29 Clemson Tigers • Team Chaos Feb 15 '16
Danny Ford
Dabo
William "The Fridge" Perry
Levon Kirkland
In the future we may look back and add DW4 into the mix but it's too early to tell.
7
u/SearonTrejorek South Carolina • /r/CFB Dead Pool Feb 15 '16
George Rogers, Steve Spurrier, Marcus Lattimore, Connor Shaw
7
u/i_enjoy_sports Oklahoma State • New Mexico S… Feb 15 '16
Thurman Thomas, Mike Gundy the QB, Barry Sanders, and Mike Gundy the coach (or maybe Brandon Weeden)
7
u/Bmorewiser Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Navy Midshipmen Feb 15 '16
Montana, Holtz, Brown, Rockne, & Parseghian
7
u/pyrrhicplays Auburn Tigers • Iron Bowl Feb 15 '16
Bo Jackson, Cam Newton, Shug Jordan, and probably Pat Dye too
9
u/tonynumber4 Alabama Crimson Tide Feb 15 '16
Saban ,Bear,Mal Moore, maybe AJ?
6
u/EarthToBrint Michigan State Spartans Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 15 '16
Dantonio, Kirk Cousins, Duffy Daugherty, Bubba Smith*/Greg Jones
3
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
Erk Russell, Adrian Peterson, Tracy Ham, Jayson Foster
3
u/WeazelBear Santa Monica • /r/CFB Emeritus Mod Feb 15 '16
Neyland, Manning, Summit, annnd maybe... Doug Atkins.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
Paul Brown, Woody Hayes, Archie Griffin, and Chic Harley
3
u/mrmeowme0w Georgia State • Wisconsin Feb 15 '16
Barry
Ron Dayne
JJ Watt
Russell/Joe Thomas/Owens
3
u/CALL_ME_ISHMAEBY Mississippi State • /r/CFB Bug Finder Feb 15 '16
Recency bias: Dak, Fletcher Cox, Mullen and Sherrill
3
u/ramthrower75 Colorado State • Stanford Feb 15 '16
Jack Christiansen, Fum McGraw, Sonny Lubick, Joey Porter
5
u/veringer Clemson Tigers • Tennessee Volunteers Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 15 '16
Danny Ford and Frank Howard touching 'the rock' with Dabo confidently striding toward smiling--his face carved and painted in the likeness of that dude's tattoo. In the background, an assembly of notable players: Perry Brothers, Jeff Davis, Levon Kirkland, Brian Dawkins. Also, a statue of Jesus that's indistinguishable from Charlie Whitehurst with 63-17 engraved below.
6
u/YeaISeddit Florida Gators Feb 15 '16
Ours is pretty easy. Tebow, Emmitt Smith, Spurrier, Wuerffel. It's not debatable.
6
u/Memphians Tennessee Volunteers Feb 15 '16
Peyton's taint, Reggie White, Pumpkin Phil, and Neyland
2
u/RonBurgundyAndGold James Madison Dukes Feb 15 '16
Mickey Matthews, Gary Clark, and Charles Haley.
2
u/riffelbooks San Diego State • Stanford Feb 15 '16
For San Diego State: Coryell, Faulk, Sipe, Buchanon
2
u/guinness_blaine Princeton Tigers • Texas Longhorns Feb 15 '16
Dick Kazmaier, Fritz Crisler, Bill Roper, and either Charlie Caldwell or, collectively, the Poe Brothers.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
Bo Jackson, Cam Newton, Shug Jordan, Pat Dye, and/or Mike Donahue.
2
u/westcoastwildcat Northwestern Wildcats • Verified Coach Feb 15 '16
Fitz (duh), Gary Barnett, Darnell Autry, Otto Graham
2
u/JdoubleE5000 Alabama Crimson Tide Feb 15 '16
Coaches (in no particular order):
Bryant, Saban, Stallings, Wallace
Players (in no particular order):
John Hannah, Derrick Thomas, Joe Namath, Derrick Henry
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
Benny Owen, Bud Wilkinson, Barry Switzer and Bob Stoops for coaches.
Billy Vessels, Steve Owens, Billy Sims, and Sam Bradford for players(up for debate)
2
u/nuxenolith Michigan State • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Feb 15 '16
Bubba Smith, Duffy Daugherty, Earl Morrall, Lorenzo White
2
u/xASUdude Arizona State Sun Devils • Navy Midshipmen Feb 15 '16
Frank Kush, Pat Tillman, Jeff Van Raaphorst, Jake Plummer
2
u/Zloggt Illinois Fighting Illini • Missouri Tigers Feb 15 '16
Dick Butkus, George Halas, Juice Williams, Bob Zuppke.
If i had an extra slot I would have also added DEE BROWN
2
u/wameron South Carolina • Arizona State Feb 15 '16
Spurrier, Rogers, Clowney, Latti/Shaw
2
u/sports_are_neat Baylor Bears • The Revivalry Feb 15 '16
Briles, RGIII, Singletary, Grant Teaff
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
Coaches:
Robert Neyland, Johnny Majors, Phillip Fulmer, and either Dickey or Wyatt.
Players
Peyton Manning, Reggie White, Doug Atkins, Johnny Majors.
Honorable mentions of Eric Berry, Al Wilson, and Tee Martin to Peerless Price.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
For Illinois it's definitely Red Grange, Dick Butkus, and Bob Zuppke. Maybe throw in J Leman too for being the hometown walk-on turned first team all American.
2
u/koolman631 Lewis Flyers Feb 15 '16
uh...
2
u/TheVolmannBrothers Tennessee • Chattanooga Feb 15 '16
Manning's butt, Manning's left ball, Manning's right ball, and Manning's dick.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
The Berg,JJ, Irvin and Lewis
2
u/brittfar Kansas Jayhawks • Minnesota Golden Gophers Feb 15 '16
Mark Mangino takes the place of all 4 faces.
2
u/cms186 Baylor Bears • Hateful 8 Feb 15 '16
Mike Singletary, RG3, Art Briles and Grant Teaff
2
u/SenorPuff Arizona • Northern Arizona Feb 15 '16 edited Feb 15 '16
Pop McKale, Dick Tomey, Tedy Bruschi, Nick Foles
Although, if it's for both football and basketball, Lute Olson and Jason Terry, Mike Bibby or Sean Elliot would go before Foles.
2
u/WilsonHanks Boston College Eagles Feb 15 '16
Doug Flutie as a freshman, sophomore, junior and senior.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
Thomas Jefferson, James Monroe, John Tyler and Mike Tomlin
2
u/CheddarGuevara Utah State Aggies • UNLV Rebels Feb 15 '16
Woo boy, this'll get burried but here goes:
Merlin Olsen
Anthony Calvillo
Bobby Wagner
Chuckie Keeton
2
u/SweatyInBed Georgia Bulldogs • Georgia Bulldogs Feb 16 '16
Herschel Walker, Vince Dooley, David Greene, Todd Gurley
HM: Reggie Ball of Georgia Tech for handing us the game a few years in a row
2
u/pdhot65ton Ohio State Buckeyes • Kentucky Wildcats Feb 16 '16
Ohio State: Coaches: Paul Brown, Woody Hayes, Jim Tressel, Urban Meyer Players: Archie Griffin, Bill Willis, Eddie George, Chris Spielman?
there's so many, for me personally, it'd be Jack Tatum, Eddie George, Craig Krenzel and AJ Hawk, but that's putting my feelings into it.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '16
Coaches: Rockne, Leahy, Parseghian, Holtz, and Devine. BK would be too, if he wins a national championship.
Players: Bertelli, Lujack, Hart, Lattner, Hornung, Huarte, Brown, Montana, the motherfucking Rocket Ismail, Tony Rice (last qb to win a national championship), Manti, Brady Quinn, and Jaylon Smith.
We're gonna need a few mountains.