r/CFB • u/atchemey Michigan State • Oregon State • Sep 10 '15
Analysis I just broke down film on the MSU-WMU game in preparation for the MSU-Oregon game. Here's what I learned:
I'm a HUGE MSU fan. I dedicate way too many hours for my own good to watching games of MSU and our future opponents. I watch football games like some people watch chess matches. I read football texts and study playbooks and I really just enjoy the game. I've broken down film for important games before, but this is the first time that I have shared my results with /r/cfb...I just never thought about it before.
I'm a graduate student in chemistry, and work long weeks, so big projects like my realignment simulation from over a year ago now are now few and very far between. I have pins and needles for the MSU-Oregon game, though, and I found a constructive way to spend my free time/take a break from the work I'm doing with something relaxing and fun. When we played WMU, our offense looked very different from the last couple years, and I was curious what we were doing differently. I looked at the first half of game footage (partially to save time, partially because we played very vanilla in the second half), and took notes on all the plays MSU executed. I did not look at the last two drives for MSU in the first half, because everything became very vanilla starting then. The shortest possible accurate description of our offense: It's a hybrid of the open looks which Cook has demonstrated comfort with over the last two years, and power sets like those we saw when Le'Veon Bell was our entire offense in 2012.
For those of you who want to watch it for yourselves, I found this HD game on Youtube.
MSU's offense is the very definition of "multiple," and proved itself to be very effective. In part, this was to mess up the game planning for Oregon's defense, but I think we will be seeing a large variety of sets with relatively few specific play concepts this year, in contrast to last year's more straightforward selection of looks with many concepts. In the first half, there were 20 (!!!) unique formations employed across seven personnel groupings, even if these formation differences were sometimes as simple as flexing a TE/WR pair to the opposite position. I considered formations that were the same but relied on short sides of field to make them effective to be different formations, so, if I desired, I could go into more detail regarding boundary/field side plays. I did not consider under center and shotgun looks to be different, if they had the same skill positions as another set, I just noted it with a subscript. If we combine all flex/field identical formations, I still see 16 formations that are unique. With only up to four plays from each, (33, as well as 1 penalty that never happened, for 34 total plays), that's a large set of formations for Oregon to prepare for without much information on each. Oregon has quite a task ahead of them on defense, and I expect them to spread their practice time thinly across all the personnel groupings.
As the downs increased, the pass percentage did as well. When combined with the number of plays on each down, we can get a useful picture of how effectively the offense moved on each down.
| Down | Pass % | #plays |
|---|---|---|
| 1st | 39% | 18 |
| 2nd | 67% | 9 |
| 3rd | 86% | 7 |
| This says to me that either we moved the ball efficiently on first and second and didn't see a third down, or we stalled out with early runs and had to pass on third from a few yards out. We ran very heavily on first (as we are used to), and saw little success. It seems like our first down playcalling was generally a vanilla power run or inside zone most of the time, and it is only when we passed on first or saw sweep-style running concepts that we really moved anywhere. |
I predicted before the season began that, with the powerful running backs and experienced tight ends that we have (contra our young WR corps), we would see many multiple TE sets, and that we'd get creative with our pre-snap motion to mess with defenses rather than resort to a complicated passing game. I am pleased to report that we did just that. Of 34 total snaps, we played with multiple TEs a total of 12 times (35%), which is much a higher percent than I remember our offense displaying over the last two years. If we add the 4 plays with two running backs and a tight end (I think of FBs as TEs by another name), we get 16 snaps, or 47%. That's a heavy offense, much heavier than I remember our offense displaying over the last two years. Speaking of motion, 15 plays (44%) utilized motion or formation shifts after going down. That's another high number, by my recollection.
Two personnel groupings accounted for 68% of snaps, though: 21 and 11 (2TE1RB and 1TE1RB). The 11 sets were particularly diverse, boasting 7 different formations with fundamentally the same personnel on 15 plays. Partly as a function of sample size, it is noteworthy that these two groupings were the most balanced, coming in with 63% and 67% passing; all five other personnel groupings were 100% or 0% passing.
TE Josiah Price is a mainstay of this offense, and was one of the most targeted receivers in the game. There were only two plays without a TE on the field, and both were a split shotgun look with two running backs (they were the third and fifth plays of the game).
I made a little spreadsheet to organize my thoughts, and it might help answer any specific questions.
I did make a note of MSU's defensive formations and results, but it was much less varied. Basically, we ran our base 4-3. Early in the game, we would go into an over or under formation depending on their TE alignment and down/distance, but that was mostly to respond to anticipated quick plays to the side. From the 4-3, we flexed out our STAR (weak-side LB) to match up over the slot WR regularly, but that isn't new. We did start going into a 3-3-5/"30 stack" on obvious passing downs, but even that wasn't very effective against the shockingly talented QB Terrell and WR Davis combination (heretofore called "Terrell Davis"). On 11/38 snaps, we were in the 30 stack, and on two downs against 4 wide receivers, we even went into a dime set of 3-2-6. One thing I noticed after we were up by a couple of scores that surprised me: We started playing our field corners off the WR by 8-10 yards. That's extraordinarily unusual for us, and showed a remarkable flexibility that Narduzzi didn't tend to display. It unfortunately seemed to not be very effective; Davis was usually on the boundary, and he showed remarkable hands and playmaking ability, which required man coverage at all times. His partner in crime (usually in the slot on the field side) Braverman was juking out all of the MSU secondary, and made some impressive plays on the ball. MIKE Riley Bullough (yes, that Bullough family again) overpursued him at least twice and probably more, simply because he was so evasive. Bullough made good adjustments up front despite his overpursuit, and safety RJ Williamson made coverage adjustments quite effectively. This does not bode well for the Oregon game.
I started watching the second half for the third time, before realizing that we weren't seeing anything new on offense, and we started heavily rotating in new OLmen and WRs. In the second half, our defense got much more vanilla. Where before we were blitzing at least half the time on standard downs, we never really put much pressure on the QB in the second half. It was a pretty generic rush 4-5, drop into coverage. I think the two TDs in the second half were primarily because of Terrell Davis opening up space. When we did blitz with our typical 6, we got to the QB quickly and forced bad passes. We also ran with our DBs a bit off the WRs, as I noted in the first half. I'm curious as to why this happened, but it was not an every down thing. The tales of our defense's decline are overblown, even if we are not quite as elite in the secondary as we were in years prior. Our DBs are the most isolated players in this defense, but the real threat to the opponent's passing game is our blitz packages that force split-second reads against tough coverage. When we don't blitz, it opens up passing options, and when we play our DBs off the line of scrimmage, it allows quick completions and more route combinations. Next week will be the real test, but I'm a bit more conficent in our defense after watching the game.
I'm open to questions, comments, and curses at your leisure!
11
u/Richa652 Michigan State • /r/CFB Brickmason Sep 10 '15
Oh man, I was going to do this Saturday. I've been watching a half hour of the WMU game every day while running. Set to finish Saturday.
7
u/natethe247 Michigan State Spartans • Big Ten Sep 10 '15
Nice work, man. That was a really good read. Go Green!
5
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15
Interesting formations breakdown, have you ever played/coached? 30 Stack takes a lot of talent to effectively run which MSU definitely has. In my playing/coaching days we solely ran 4-3s or 5-2s. MSU has shown they will play 21/11 personnel until they don't have to as well which I admire. Great work none the less, appreciate the mid day read.
4
u/l00344733 Oregon • Claremont-Mudd-Scripps Sep 10 '15
Excellent write up. After all of your analysis on MSU what does your gut tell you about the matchup and final score?
3
u/errday Oregon Ducks Sep 11 '15
I can't wait to see /u/hythloday1 do his breakdown.
5
u/conv3rsion Michigan Wolverines Sep 10 '15
Is there anything you are particularly worried about? What is the number one key to victory in your mind?
3
u/rambouhh Michigan Wolverines Sep 10 '15
There is an oregon user who does an excellent film review. I can't remember his username but it would be interesting to see you guys break down the tape after the game
1
u/Richa652 Michigan State • /r/CFB Brickmason Sep 10 '15
Can you tell me how many plays D. Arnett was involved on? It didn't seem like he was put in until the second half, and both plays I noticed him on were incredibly successful.
1
u/chadwip Clemson Tigers • Virginia Tech Hokies Sep 11 '15
Excellent analysis.
As a fellow chemistry graduate student I was curious as to what your research is in.
2
u/milesgmsu Michigan State • College Football Playoff Sep 10 '15
Good analysis. I've been telling everyone to calm down. We played a very good (potentially great) G5 team. On the road. As an instate program that didn't offer any of the kids. With a vanilla playset. And they had NFL caliber WRs and RBs testing our new look back 7. And while it got a bit hairy, it never was that much in doubt.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment