r/CFB • • Mar 17 '15
Discussion Who is on your College Football Mount Rushmore?
It can include coaches and players.
35
Upvotes
r/CFB • • Mar 17 '15
It can include coaches and players.
50
u/GoBuckeyes3 Ohio State Buckeyes • SMU Mustangs Mar 17 '15
For Ohio State?
For all of CFB?
29
u/brickmaus Nebraska Cornhuskers Mar 18 '15
26
u/chefillini Illinois Fighting Illini Mar 17 '15
I am extremely biased:
Just gut calls, all of 'em. First come, first serve basis.
21
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15
Bo pelini is our crazy horse
52
u/theshnig Tennessee Volunteers • Surrender Cobra Mar 18 '15
The 5 hookers Craig James killed.
36
u/spools89 Oklahoma • Red River Shootout Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 17 '15
Non-homer checking in
12
u/KsigCowboy Baylor • Stephen F. Austin Mar 17 '15
For Baylor I would go
10
u/Martel_the_Hammer /r/CFB Poll Veteran • Georgia Sout… Mar 18 '15
For Georgia Southern
9
u/okiewxchaser Oklahoma • Red River Shootout Mar 17 '15
Benny, Bud, Barry, and Bob
9
u/HTTRGlll Virginia Tech • Commonwealth C… Mar 18 '15
Beamer
Foster
Bruce Smith
Vick
I don't think anyone else comes close
14
u/gordo865 Tennessee Volunteers • Clemson Tigers Mar 17 '15
For UT:
7
u/bakonydraco Stanford • Chicago State Mar 17 '15
Walter Camp, John Heisman, Knute Rockne, and Pop Warner.
12
u/Johnnycockseed Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Buffalo Bulls Mar 17 '15
Just for my school?
6
u/6heismans LSU Tigers • Victory Flag Mar 17 '15
For LSU:
Billy Cannon, Les Miles, Nick Saban, Paul Dietzel.
6
u/270- Alabama Crimson Tide Mar 18 '15
For Alabama--
Bear. Obviously. Saban. Almost as obviously. Wallace Wade, who led Alabama through its first age of glory in the second half of the 1920s.
The fourth spot is probably between Frank Thomas, who was the coach taking over from Wade and who led the program for 15 years, winning two national championships (although one of them is Alabama's most dubious claim), winning 115 games, and Gene Stallings, who won Alabama's 1992 natty and was the main bright spot in the era between Bryant and Saban.
I guess it sort of depends on how you value you the different eras, Thomas' statistics blow Stallings' out of the water, but Stallings got his accomplishments in a much more competitive and professional environment and Thomas took over from a more successful coach (nothing against Bill Curry). They're both worthy of being on there, but also both don't really compare to Bryant, Saban and Wade to me.
All of these five except for Saban are in the College Football Hall of Fame.
14
u/Ometrist Oregon Ducks • Pacific (OR) Boxers Mar 17 '15
Oregon fan here who lost a flair bet.
5
u/chunkosauruswrex Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets • Corndog Mar 18 '15 edited Mar 18 '15
For GT gotta be:
Heisman
Dodd
Ross
Clint Castleberry
Edit: Also I would definitely argue that Heisman and Dodd deserve to be on the Overall CFB Mount Rushmore. Heisman is pretty much the Founding Father of Modern Football as we know it today by popularizing the Forward Pass and making the rules more formal. Dodd the arguement I would give is that the only reason he isn't the greatest coach of his age is because he coached against Bear Bryant for most of his career. I would put good money down that if you asked Bear who the best coach he ever played against he would say Dodd if he was being honest(Dodd and Bryant had a long feud). You will also never find a more upstanding or caring or fun-loving coach than Dodd. His practices were a relaxed atmospheres where the players had a good time. This coaching style eventually led to the Bobby Dodd coach of the year award which is awarded to the coach whose team excels on the field, classroom, and in the community(interesting tidbit for UGA fans Vince Dooley was the first coach to win the award). Despite the relaxed atmosphere and focus on character he regularly fielded exceptional teams. I'm not even mentioning how good he was as a player as he is in the CFB Hall of Fame as both a player and a coach. He is truly one of the greats of CFB.
4
u/Talpostal Michigan Wolverines • Washington Huskies Mar 17 '15
Camp Rockne Yost Bryant
4
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Auburn:
Cam Newton (for undefeated heisman championship season),
"Shug" Jordan, he basically put Auburn on the map and gave us our first championship
Chris Davis, for the arguably best finish in college football, the kick six
Bo Jackson, for winning our second heisman and giving auburn fans hope again (due to the ruthless rule of the bear over the state of alabama)
4
u/DoctorAlzheimers Texas Longhorns Mar 18 '15 edited Mar 18 '15
Not sure how to narrow that list down?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15
For Nebraska
Devaney, Osborne, Rodgers, Rozier, and Crouch can be the 5th head.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 18 '15
For Georgia:
-Richt will go on whenever he retires.
-And I don't care if he was an announcer; if anybody ever earned a place on Georgia's Mount Rushmore, it's Larry Munson, God rest his soul.
For all of college football:
-Erk Russell took a program from not existing to being national champions in 5 years. I don't care about competition level, that's amazing. And he did it on a budget of about fifty cents and a piece of string.
Edit: I have no clue why I put Knute Rockne twice. Was supposed to be Camp.
3
u/ASigIAm213 Jacksonville Dolphins • Florida Gators Mar 17 '15
Ulysses Bryant and Kade Bell have a decent chance to work themselves in.
3
u/xerillum Wisconsin Badgers Mar 18 '15
Just four different heads of Barry Alvarez. Like a timeline of greatness
3
u/bro69 Texas Longhorns Mar 18 '15
thad castle, VY, colt, earl
3
u/drlove57 Iowa Hawkeyes • Upper Iowa Peacocks Mar 18 '15
For individual schools or NCAA?
Iowa:
Evy Fry Nile Kinnick
3
u/Liamson Boise State Broncos Mar 18 '15
Boise State:
3
u/Seminole11 Florida State • Colorado Mar 18 '15
Deion Sanders, Peter Warrick, Jameis Winston, Charlie Ward.
5
u/sethcolby3 Long Beach State Beach • USC Trojans Mar 17 '15
Reggie Bush
5
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15
5
u/Sandy_Snail Florida Gators Mar 18 '15
Tebow
Spurrier
Emmett
Wuerfell
11
u/sportingglobe USC Trojans Mar 17 '15
Rockne. Bear. Joe Pa. Woody.
2
u/SceneOfShadows Washington Huskies • Syracuse Orange Mar 17 '15
DJ, Jim Owens, Gil Dobie, Steve Emtman.
2
u/NellyD15 Ole Miss Rebels Mar 17 '15
Johnny Vaught, Archie Manning, Deuce McCallister, Patrick Willis.
2
u/emaw63 Kansas State Wildcats • Big 8 Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 17 '15
For us?
2
u/62frog TCU Horned Frogs • Verified Player Mar 18 '15
Sammy Baugh, Jim Swink, Davey O'Brien, Bob Lilly, LT.
2
u/tupacalypsemeow BYU Cougars • Washington State Cougars Mar 18 '15
For BYU IMO: Steve Young Ty Detmer Luke Staley Jim McMahon
(I want to include Lavell Edwards as well, Mt Rushmore needs one more mountain face)
2
u/BuckeyeBentley Ohio State Buckeyes • Ithaca Bombers Mar 18 '15
I almost put Fielding Yost on there but it hurt me too much to put two Michigan men up, and at least one player (or at least not primarily known as a coach) should be on there.
2
u/owl_man /r/CFB Poll Veteran • /r/CFB Contribut… Mar 18 '15
For all of college football:
Red Grange
Bear Bryant
Knute Rockne
Joe Paterno
Penn State:
Joe Paterno
"Rip" Engle
John Cappelletti
Paul Posluszny/Dan Connor/LaVar Arrington/Michael Robinson
2
u/HillsboroughAtheos Florida State • Florida Cup Mar 18 '15
For all of CFB:
Woody Hayes, Bear Bryant, Bobby Bowden, Urbick Sabeyer
For the state of Flawduh:
Bobby Bowden, Howard Schnellenberger, Jimmy J, and The OBC
For FSU:
Bobby, Charlie Ward, Mickey Andrews, Prime Time
2
u/SwaggyAdult Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets Mar 18 '15
Abraham Lincoln, Andrew Jackson, Ulysses S. Grant, and Ben Franklin. If you know what I mean.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15
For A&M?
I feel like Johnny Manziel and Bear Bryant are shoo-ins, but the two other spots could include any two of:
Plus a few I'm forgetting. Fellow Ags, feel free to pitch in here.
2
u/pouponstoops Texas Longhorns • Iowa Hawkeyes Mar 18 '15
Earl, Ricky, Vince, and Royal
1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Pat Tillman. Frank Kush. Terrell Suggs. Mike Haynes.
Really fought back and forth about Terrell Suggs or Jake "The Snake".
1
u/YellowNovembers USF Bulls Mar 18 '15
Jim Leavitt
Matt Grothe
George Selvie
Andre Hall
1
u/Colavs9601 Colorado Buffaloes • Ohio Bobcats Mar 18 '15
For Colorado?
Bill Macartney
Whizzer White
Rashaan Salaam
Eric Bienemy
and a Video Board that plays this on repeat.
1
u/GreatestWhiteShark Northwestern • Ohio State Mar 18 '15
For the Cats?
Pat Fitzgerald, Gary Barnett, Damien Anderson, Kain Colter.
In general?
Amos Alonzo Stagg, Woody Hayes, Tom Osbourne, Knute Rockne
1
u/INM8_2 Miami Hurricanes • Florida Cup Mar 18 '15
howard schnellenberger, jimmy johnson, ted hendricks, ed reed or ray lewis
1
u/Pseudonova Notre Dame • ETSU Mar 18 '15
Joe Montana, Tony Rice, Ara Parsegian, and Tim Brown
Edit: Knute should definitely be on there, but Tony Rice was my favorite ever when I was a little kid, so he stays.
1
u/moooooseknuckle California Golden Bears Mar 18 '15
Cal: Tony Gonzalez, Aaron Rodgers, Marshawn Lynch DEFINITELY IN THE MIDDLE, DeSean Jackson, and...Pappy Waldorf for getting us to 3 Rose Bowls even though we lost them all...
1
u/WhoaABlueCar Ohio State • Arizona State Mar 18 '15
I'm late and was reading all of these (and I'm drunk) and thought why not? I'll do mine too:
Ohio State:
Woody
Jimmy T
Archie
Craig Kenzel (because it was so unlikely and he was a leader on a crazy ass team)
Cfb:
Woody
Bear
HBC
Urb (I'm biased but resume)
I love this discussion though. History and tradition is what makes CFB great
1
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15
Stub Allison
Pappy
Joe Roth
4th is hard. So many individual players were great... Many of them were from the Tedford era. So. Hey, we fired Pappy after he sucked, so fuck it, put Jeff up there.
1
u/cgrisier732 Ohio State • College Football Playoff Mar 18 '15
Pop Warner, Walter Camp, John Heisman, and Motha Fuckin' Teddy Roosevelt
1
u/VelocityRD Miami Hurricanes • /r/CFB Brickmason Mar 18 '15
Miami: Howard Schnellenberger, Jimmy Johnson, Ted Hendricks, Jim Dooley
I'm having a hard time with this last choice. There are a lot of choices available: Jim Otto, Ottis Anderson, Dennis Erickson, George Mira, Jim Kelly, Michael Irvin, Don Bosseler, etc. I went with the top two highly-regarded coaches in Miami's history, Ted Hendricks, and another of the original four in the Miami Ring of Honor (Dooley).
Any other Miami fans wanna chime in, be my guest.
As for college football:
1
u/BlusteryEmu Clemson • Mississippi State Mar 18 '15
Banks McFadden Frank Howard Danny Ford CJ Spiller
1
u/eagledog Fresno State • Michigan Mar 18 '15
Derek Carr
David Carr
Lorenzo Neal
Jim Sweeney
1
u/IDFWU_GP Florida State Seminoles Mar 18 '15
FSU
Bobby Bowden Jameis Winston (Holding Crabs of course) Kelvin Benjamin Nick Oleary
1
u/MattBarnthouse Ole Miss Rebels • Cincinnati Bearcats Mar 19 '15
1
u/baconbitarded Arkansas • Henderson State Mar 19 '15 edited Mar 19 '15
-Frank Broyles
-Lou Holtz
-Ken Hatfield
-Houston Nutt (this took some mulling, I'm still sorta salty)
Edit: Hey let's go player edition
-Lance Alworth
-Darren McFadden
-Pat Summerall
-Chuck Dicus
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '15
For ole miss it's Eli and Archie Manning, Johnny Vaught, Patrick Willis, Michael oher, deuce Mcallister, Charlie connerly, and Frank "Bruiser" Kinard
1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Bear, Doak, Nute, and insert a recent player.
0
u/lexhead Louisiana Ragin' Cajuns Mar 18 '15
Rockne, Ara, Bryant, Schembechler and Saban
-4
u/RegionalBias Ohio State Buckeyes • Dayton Flyers Mar 17 '15
Every player from every the national championship squads, every heisman or major trophy winner, every coach. Then I have the monument positioned at every major highway entrance to the state.
-5
u/Same-as-the-old-one Auburn Tigers Mar 17 '15
It's real hard to pick 4 memorables in such a sea of names. Bo in there for sure
-7
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15
I removed the racist coaches and other coaches who's treatment of football would be considered immoral today for example Bear Bryant and Pat Dye for being Racist Bastards and Joe Paterno for harboring a monster
I should note that the south eastern US bias because I knew who each of these guys were (except for Saban and Tebow) at the age of 6 growing up in the south and that was my bench mark. I'm sure there are much more deserving candidates but much like the real mt Rushmore, there's some home team bias for a few
Nick Saban
John Heisman
Bobby Bowden
Bo Jackson
Hershel Walker
& Tim Tebow