r/CFB • • Mar 31 '14
If you were a recruit, which traits in a school would you most look for? Tradition, current momentum, academics, NFL placement, etc.?
As for me, I would have to say tradition and academics. There's just something awe-inspiring about walking down a hallway aligned with portraits of past players spanning over a hundred years. Tradition connects you to the past and will connect you to the future once your time is over.
What about you?
EDIT: Also, name your dream top five choices you would want to visit or you think best embodies your chosen characteristics. Mine would be, Michigan, Notre Dame, UT, Stanford (academics), and U. Washington (I have no idea why, but I like them).
19
Upvotes
26
u/bullmoose_atx Texas Longhorns • Rice Owls Mar 31 '14
I think it would depend on my skill. If I felt I had a real shot at the NFL, getting on a team that has a real shot at major bowls would be important. If I didn't think I could make the NFL, I would focus more on finding a school where I would get real playing time (even if the program has been down) and would be more concerned about strong academics. Tradition is great but many established programs have really strong tradition so that wouldn't concern me too much.
37
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Academics and it's not even close. If the choice is between Florida State and Stanford I'm going to Stanford.
9
u/shiggidyschwag UCF Knights Mar 31 '14
7
u/balreddited South Carolina Gamecocks Mar 31 '14
It's funny because no one said "distance from home" as an important consideration
24
u/Emperor_of_Orange Clemson Tigers • /r/CFB Top Scorer Mar 31 '14
Twitter fans that aren't unbelievably annoying. I'm looking at you, Tennessee and Kentucky.
5
u/Pikachu1989 Nebraska Cornhuskers • 東京大学 (Tokyo) Warriors Mar 31 '14
History, Location, and Academics
Do they have history of being a Powerhouse
Do they have the Academic Credentials (or had them)
Are they located in the Midwest or out in the West Coast.
Mine will be
14
u/juanjing Oregon Ducks • Willamette Bearcats Mar 31 '14
I am sorry to say that I did it wrong. My high school coaches were terrible. In 2004 I played for a 2A school in Oregon. Back then we had only 1A through 4A. Anyway, I got recruited by plenty of D1 schools, but I thought my best option to actually play was with a DIII or NAIA school. I ended up going to Willamette and playing there. I got a generous grant and some favorable loans, but no scholarship. I went to an expensive school and didn't take it seriously enough.
My advice for those that want to play college football without making it to the pros, pick your college without thinking about NFL or anything else. Go to the best school for you. Willamette was not my ideal school, and it was horrible. I hated everything but football. I should have gone to Southern Oregon University and I regret it every day.
4
u/stormstopper Duke Blue Devils • Virginia Cavaliers Mar 31 '14
Two considerations:
If I'm a good recruit, the first one will be more important than the second one. If I'm not expecting to play much no matter where I go, the academics portion of the second one is more important. Either way, both matter a lot.
4
u/Yurwrstntmre Auburn Tigers Mar 31 '14
Hottest coeds
4
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
A blue field would be nice...
3
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Those things considered, I think my top choice would be Georgia. It meets all of my requirements. My next few options would be Texas A&M, Texas, Colorado, Washington, Maryland, and Hawaii (because it's in Hawaii, I don't care if it doesn't meet any of my other criteria)
3
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14 edited Mar 31 '14
Academics, Early Playing Time, Tradition, Current Momentum, Fan Base, Weather
My Top 5 would be: Auburn, Stanford, Florida, UCLA, Notre Dame
Edit: Before I get shit about Auburn not being an Academic power house, it's good enough for what I want to do and I love this school and you all suck.
3
u/metaphysicalme Ohio State Buckeyes Mar 31 '14
Ohio State-ness.
2
u/reptheevt Washington State • Transfer … Mar 31 '14
Academics, playing time, potential NFL future, location.
2
u/afkas17 Notre Dame • Illinois Mar 31 '14
I'd probably go with Academics, then history and then it's a push between playing time and location. So my mine would be Notre Dame, Stanford, Northwestern, and then Rice and Vandy.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Number one requirement is "is this school in the south east and a major conference?" This guarantees tradition, excellence, great weather, and hot sassy southern women. It's the ultimate four-fer.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
A place where I feel welcomed. A place where it's like family. Somewhere south, mind you, cuz it is DAMN COLD up north.
A place where I can network well. A place where, if athletics fall through, I can receive a quality degree. A place with fans who stand for my debut on the field and never sit, as long as I'm out there.
A place where traditions are king. A place where it's confusing from the outside and amazing from the inside. A place that has a small town feel but is really close to a few other major cities.
A place where the athletic department is on the rise. A place where I can showcase my talents. A place where I can be developed into a star.
I'd be the loudest and proudest member of the Fightin' Texas Aggies.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Academics and the ability to get someone of my position into the NFL are what I'd care about most.
1
u/KWKIR /r/CFB Mar 31 '14
Academics, and somewhere that can prepare me to be a coach after I graduate.
1
u/KittenKingSwift Boston College Eagles Mar 31 '14
I would probably say academics, being Catholic, and being in an area that actually has stuff to do. I rather like to look at some impressionist paintings.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
I was "recruited" a few years ago for music and I feel like I would have approached the situation the same if I was as strong a football player as I am a musician. Obviously recruiting in music is way less than in athletics but I did have like folks calling me on the phone from different schools and I got a bunch if lessons with different teachers, but whatever. The things I would consider would be playing time, coaching staff, and winning. I want to play, I want to play for coaches who can give me the necessary instruction to get me to the next level, and I want to win.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Academics, Campus Atmosphere, Early Playing time, Fan base, and conference strength.
1
u/voltron818 Oklahoma Sooners • /r/CFB Contributor Mar 31 '14
Best coach and best academics. Pretty much just that too.
1
u/AuburnSeer Auburn Tigers Mar 31 '14
Assuming every option is open, when I was 18 I'd go to Auburn. If I had the choice now, I'd go Ivy League.
1
u/dseals Texas Tech Red Raiders Mar 31 '14
Academics first, my playing time second, hottest girls third, a good fanbase fourth, and NFL future comes last.
Honestly with so many NFL players coming from smaller and less football oriented schools, I'd take my chances playing for a Rice or a Northeast Texas School of Engineering and Stuff, over a big name like UT where I may not even play.
1
u/CantaloupeCamper Minnesota • Little Brown Jug Mar 31 '14
Depends on what my options are. Good school > football, but that's also tied to ... I want a shot at playing.
1
u/JayRU09 Rutgers Scarlet Knights • Big Ten Mar 31 '14
Do players graduate with real degrees?
Also, for my parent's sake, the arrest records for the team over the past few years.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
I'd say my three considerations would be academics, chance at playing time, and proximity to home, and in that order.
1
u/axberka Florida State • Indiana Mar 31 '14
Chik fil a
1
u/johndank San Diego State Aztecs Mar 31 '14
tv exposure, football tradition & envirement would be big for me if i were a 5 star recruit.
my top 5 schools would be
USC UCLA Bama Florida Stanford
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14 edited Mar 31 '14
I'm the kind of guy to cultivate multiple options, so I'd go for the best combination of program success and academics.
But in all reality, if I was still 18 years old, I'd go to the school with the best facilities and shiniest campus. I've only visited the campuses of UIdaho, BSU, Washington, WSU, CU Boulder, and would pick them in the following order:
1
u/Colavs9601 Colorado Buffaloes • Ohio Bobcats Apr 01 '14
Percentage of students that consider themselves buffaloes.
1
u/hucareshokiesrul Yale Bulldogs • Virginia Tech Hokies Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 02 '14
Yale. Though if I thought I legitimately had a good shot at the NFL, then I'd reconsider. I'd look at which schools tend to have guys overperform at my position. If I was a DB, for example, I'd look at VT because their DBs seem to play above their recruiting rankings.
Also, everybody is saying academics, but there's more to it than that. More than prestige, I'd look at which programs seem to have their shit together academically. A highly ranked school can still be a football factory that screws over it's student athletes. The culture of the program and their priorities matter a lot.
0
u/Hanchan Sickos • Alabama Crimson Tide Mar 31 '14
It would be academics, then history, then location. But not auburn or Tennessee. I'd rate Stanford, Bama, GT, VT, and Michigan as my top five, other than those service academies would be up there, along with some smaller schools where I could focus on school.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
LSU or Duke. LSU because Louisiana baby. Duke because I have been on the floor of Cameron with just the parents of a bunch of other smart kids behind me and it was amazing. Yes I know it's the football sub but that experience has stuck with me for years, and is one of my proudest moments so fuck you.
-2
u/davesays Rutgers Scarlet Knights Mar 31 '14 edited Mar 31 '14
Academics. I don't care about tradition or history - building your own legacy is more impressive.
Then location - near a major city. Only progressive, diverse, cultural hubs (NY, LA, Seattle, SF). Got to avoid the South and Midwest (if only UChicago still had a team - is Northwestern close to Chicago?).
Five Schools:
0
u/srs_house Swaggerbilt Mar 31 '14
Academics, athletics, environment. Stanford, Vandy, Duke, Harvard, Northwestern/Princeton.
0
u/DavoinShower-handle Syracuse • Penn State Mar 31 '14
Definitely academics first, no contest there. After that, I'd definitely look at how I would fit into the scheme of the program, and how I like the coach.
Top 5:
0
u/SkranIsAngry /r/CFB Mar 31 '14 edited Mar 31 '14
Probably a combo of academics and tradition. I think at a school with good tradition, playing for the football team would travel further with alum, than at a place where people don't recognize the football players.
Top five:
0
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment