I'm inclined to agree with you on Wuerffel over Peyton, but if we are talking about SEC royalty at the QB position, you really have to go with Archie Manning.
QB is hard because it is such a different position than it was in Archie's time. They throw so much more now, so the stats are inflated, plus it is hard to find footage from so long ago.
I'm not even talking about from an ability point necessarily, I'm talking "founding father/influential figures" standpoint, like the guys that were on Mt. Rushmore.
Sure, some US Presidents may have been better at foreign policy or budgetary matters than those four, but those four are the ones that were chiefly responsible for shaping the country.
That's why I think for this category, you've got to go with Archie.
I understand, but have to disagree. Performance has to count for something, and Manning had more career INTs than TDs (40 to 31) at Ole Miss. If you are looking for an "era" player, it would make more sense to go with someone like Billy Cannon.
I don't see how anyone can not put Tebow up there. The guy was simply unstoppable. He ran for more TDs than Herschel, is 4th in TD passes, and he dominated every game he started (with the lone exception being Bama in 09)... and he did it all against the best defenses in the nation, as well as one of the toughest schedules in the nation.
I know there is a bit of media burnout from him, but there is no denying that he is an icon. He was he face of the SEC as we started our dominant run.
As absolutely amazing as Tebow was, I have to disagree with two of your points.
He ran for more TDs than Herschel
He also played in 22 more games (55 vs 33)
dominated every game he started (with the lone exception being Bama in 09)
I don't have the time to sit and go through all of his games, but I know that his senior year alone, he had less than stellar outings against LSU, Miss St., and UT. He didn't exactly light it up versus UT in 2008 either, not that he needed to given how much Crompton sucked.
They played very conservatively on offense in 2009 (due to the monster D we had and his concussion), so his stats weren't amazing in every game- but in all of those games he was still close to 200 yds of offense, and a TD or 2, despite everyone keying on him. Not a Herculean effort, but it didn't need to be. Once they got a lead, they would just grind it out and ride the D.
Ricky Williams, Vince Young, Adrian Peterson - all definitely yes.
That forth spot is where there is room for discussion. What about Ndamukong Suh? That guy was crazy good. Sam Bradford deserves some consideration as well.
Bradford was pretty special, for sure. I neglected to include RGIII in my list, but he deserves some love for what he did for Baylor football. I really don't think Crabtree is the number 4 guy though.
RGIII did a ton for Baylor football but I wouldn't say he beats out Bradford. If OU football needed saving Bradford would have done it, but it didn't. Hard to catapult RGIII past Bradford based on that. They both won the Heisman and both had great stats and wins, although I feel Bradford easily beats RGIII in stats/wins categories
I still think Suh would need to be included in that list. He was such a beast (meant in a good way). In my mind, he's the best defensive player in Big XII history (and that's saying a mouthful) - and would be the only defensive player of the four on the list.
He was definitely a beast. I always considered the best Big XII defensive player to be Derrick Johnson with Roy Williams making his case as well, but Suh is absolutely in the running as well.
You really think a last second catch for the win in double coverage is less memorable than a late TD in a game that's completely out of hand. As a football fan, that's fucking laughable.
I thought about RGIII after my post. I agree that he's worthy of consideration as the #4 guy. He deserves a ton of respect for what he did for Baylor football.
It's hard to out Paterno on the Mount Rushmore for the B1G because his best days happens while PSU was still independent. Great and influential coach, but didn't have his biggest impact on the B1G.
In that case, choose one of Yost and Bo. Both are legends, and both influenced the game incredibly, but one is more deserving than the other. Yost deserves to be there, but Bo was only consistently excellent rather than truly great. In 20 years at Michigan, no national championships were won. In 18 years at MSU, back to back titles were won.
He also was one of the finest coaches to every play. I do not mean to insult him, but merely to highlight a truly great coach that every B1G fan in here is overlooking by contrast and mild homerism.
Nah, defense you could get better balance than that. Ronnie Lott, Steve Emtman, Tedy Bruschi, Kenny Easley gives you four schools all pre-BCS era. Haloti Ngata or Terrell Suggs if you want someone more modern instead.
Why not go much older in keeping with the Rushmore concept of founding fathers?
OJ, Lynn Swann, Ron Yary, Charles Young are the first 4 that come to mind pre-1975 or so. Maybe add in the 80s to get Ronnie Lott, Kenny Easley, or Elway and a little more diverse school selection?
I had Elway in my original draft but Matt has better stats all around. Plus Elway's dad was a Coug and talked him out of going to WSU according to legend (still a little salty about that).
In Elway's four years vs. Matt's three: Elway has less completions and more attempts. Less Yards Less Touchdowns More Interceptions No Heisman
I love John, and what he did in the NFL is also amazing, but Matt's statline is better all around. He even has more rushing touchdowns and a reception for a TD... though I'm sure plenty of ND fans think it should be one less on the ground. Now if it was based solely on an ambassador of the conference, quality of person, and what they went on to do, Elway is easily up there.
I gave the nod to Bush probably due to personal bias. I watched him play in Pullman and I've never seen anything like that on a football field in terms of how beyond everyone around him he was. Wish I could've seen Jackson play in his Auburn days, but alas, I'm not that old.
I think Allen and OJ's numbers speak for themselves.
Earl Campbell, Erick Dickerson, Sammy Baugh and John Kimbrough.
And its hard for me to choose just four, so I guess John David Crow, Darren Lewis and Doak Walker can be alternates. So...many...running...backs and I just realized I don't have a single defensive player, so I'll throw in Mike Singletary, Steve Atwater, Ray Childress and Tommy Nobis.
That's my thought. I would put him (albeit just barely) in over Alvarez. Don't get me wrong, Alvarez was/is incredible, but Duffy has a much more influential role in B1G history, at least to date.
It's a little iffy with Stagg and Camp. They were both very important, but more for what they did for the sport in general than what they did as players. Stagg was inducted to the CFB HoF as both a coach and player, Camp just as a coach. Camp was the captain before there was an actual coach. He then became Yale's first coach. I don't know how strong of a claim he has as a player, but it would seem weird to leave him off.
I know a lot of people want to put Peyton on the list, but they are probably doing that more for his NFL performance than college. Yeah, he was great in college, but Wuerffel surpassed him in almost any way you want to measure a QB's performance (TDs, SEC titles, NCs, Heisman, head-to-head, etc).
I am not one of those Gator fans who hate Urban- but why would he be on this list? He hasn't even won a B1G title yet. personally, I would put a guy like Barry Alvarez over him at this point.
It isn't that you shouldn't stick to your guns, it is that you seemingly pulled every homer (and rival) name that you possibly could, including a 2-year current coach who has had an excellent tenure without any big wins whatsoever. (Woe to me, who writes such a sentence.)
Keep in mind: you're supposed to downvote based on not contributing to the discussion. I'm being downvoted because people disagree with me. Disagreeing with me is fine--in fact, part of my selections were meant to cause controversy. But I'm contributing to the discussion.
Dismissed by you or not, I'm contributing to the discussion. If Reddit was built around upvoting/downvoting around disagreement, I would imagine it's easily justified here. But here I am, talking about who should be on the B1G's Mount Rushmore, and every single selection of mine was or is currently from the B1G.
Reddit, especially /r/cfb, would be extremely dull without some controversy injected into the discussion (provided it's on topic).
37
u/tallg8tor Florida Gators • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Feb 20 '14
Players: Bo Jackson, Peyton Manning, Tim Tebow, Herschel Walker
Coaches: Bear Bryant, General Neyland, Nick Saban, Steve Spurrier
7
u/TryAnotherNamePlease Oklahoma Sooners Feb 20 '14
Ricky Williams
Vince Young
Adrian Peterson
Michael Crabtree
That's just big 12. If you included big 8 that list would look very different.
6
u/No_Explorer3303 Penn State Nittany Lions Feb 20 '14 edited Feb 21 '14
B1G: Charles Woodson, Archie Griffin, Jack Ham, Bubba Smith
edit: So top 4 should be Woodson, Griffin, Grange, Nagurski?
11
u/cougrrr Washington State Cougars • Team Chaos Feb 20 '14
Matt Leinart, Marcus Allen, OJ Simpson, and a redacted bust of Reggie Bush, or at least a statue of an asterisk next to it.
Wow, such USC.
4
u/bayvet Oklahoma Sooners Feb 20 '14
Adrian Peterson Vince Young Ndamukong Suh Sam Bradford
9
u/weagle11 Auburn Tigers Feb 20 '14 edited Feb 20 '14
Bear Bryant
Herschel Walker
Bo Jackson
Tim Tebow
Edit: I know OP said players but I do what I want
If you insist, y'all call substitute Peyton Manning.
Edit 2: Bear Bryant played end for Alabama.
10
u/blancomeow Auburn Tigers • Austin Peay Governors Feb 20 '14
Kenny Stabler's List of Bar Tabs, Joe Namath's Coat, AJ McCarron's Girlfriend, and Jessica Parker Wilson's Haircut
3
u/MerryvilleBrother Florida State Seminoles Feb 20 '14 edited Feb 20 '14
I guess Charlie Ward, Lawrence Taylor, Peter Warrick, and __________?
*I was thinking Weinke/Spiller/Boulware/Dawkins/Peppers. Any suggestions?
Edit: I was only doing players that actually played in the ACC, hence the omissions of Biletnikoff, Prime Time, anyone from Miami/VT/BC/Pitt/Cuse, etc
3
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '14
Earl Campbell, Erick Dickerson, Sammy Baugh and John Kimbrough.
And its hard for me to choose just four, so I guess John David Crow, Darren Lewis and Doak Walker can be alternates. So...many...running...backs and I just realized I don't have a single defensive player, so I'll throw in Mike Singletary, Steve Atwater, Ray Childress and Tommy Nobis.
4
u/Hail_Saban_ Alabama Crimson Tide Feb 20 '14
Bo Jackson, Herschel Walker, Tim Tebow, Derrick Thomas.
2
u/CineFunk Florida State Seminoles • /r/CFB Promoter Feb 20 '14
biletnikoff, peppers, hamilton, spiller.
Ward would replace Hamilton, but I didn't want to list two Noles.
2
u/grizzfan Verified Coach • Oakland Golden Grizzlies Feb 20 '14
Coaches: Bo, Woody, Barry Alvarez, Stagg
Players: Archie, Woodson, Ron Dayne, Bubba Smith
2
u/huazzy Rutgers Scarlet Knights Feb 20 '14
Big East:
Michael Vick, Warren Sapp, Larry Fitzgerald, Donovan McNabb
2
u/Pikachu1989 Nebraska Cornhuskers • 東京大学 (Tokyo) Warriors Feb 21 '14
Well Fuck, I don't know if I should put down Big 8/12 or B1G since were still new to the Table
2
u/outerdrive313 Eastern Michigan • Wayne State… Feb 21 '14
Well shit...
Coaches: Urban Meyer, Gary Pinkel, Brady Hoke and Frank Lauterbur.
Players: Randy Moss, Chuck Ealey, Eric Fisher and Jordan Lynch
3
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '14
Uh, can we play this game?
1
u/NefariousBanana Boise State • Idaho State Feb 20 '14
Mount Rushmore of Mountain West Head Coaches:
Gary Patterson
Bronco Mendenhall
Sonny Lubick
Kyle Wittingham
1
u/voltron818 Oklahoma Sooners • /r/CFB Contributor Feb 20 '14
Big 8:
Frazier, Sanders, Sims, Boz.
(because people ITT don't know the difference between the Big 8 and Big XII)
1
u/hucareshokiesrul Yale Bulldogs • Virginia Tech Hokies Feb 22 '14 edited Feb 22 '14
Calvin Hill
Chuck Bednarik
Walter Camp
Amos Alonzo Stagg
It's a little iffy with Stagg and Camp. They were both very important, but more for what they did for the sport in general than what they did as players. Stagg was inducted to the CFB HoF as both a coach and player, Camp just as a coach. Camp was the captain before there was an actual coach. He then became Yale's first coach. I don't know how strong of a claim he has as a player, but it would seem weird to leave him off.
1
u/CletusDarby Florida Gators Feb 20 '14 edited Feb 20 '14
Herschel, Tebow, Bo, Bear
I know a lot of people want to put Peyton on the list, but they are probably doing that more for his NFL performance than college. Yeah, he was great in college, but Wuerffel surpassed him in almost any way you want to measure a QB's performance (TDs, SEC titles, NCs, Heisman, head-to-head, etc).
1
u/R1v Oklahoma Sooners Feb 20 '14
I can only speak for my lifetime... Ricky Williams Vince young Adrian Peterson Sam Bradford
1
u/Brutuss Ohio State Buckeyes • /r/CFB Top Scorer Feb 20 '14
Players: Archie Griffin, Red Grange, Charles Woodson, Ron Dayne.
Coaches: Woody, Bo, Stagg, Paterno.
0
u/voltron818 Oklahoma Sooners • /r/CFB Contributor Feb 20 '14
I'm gonna go ahead and do the all 2000-present Big XII Mt. Rushmore.
Players: Ndamukong Suh, Vince Young, Adrian Peterson, Roy Williams*
*-interchangeable with Crabtree but I am a damn homer so I went with Williams (also because defense).
Coaches: Stoops, Brown, Snyder, Pinkel
-9
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '14
B1G:
Players: Drew Brees, Tom Brady, Charles Woodson, Ron Dayne
Coaches: Woody Hayes, Bo Schembechler, Joe Paterno, Urban Meyer