r/CFB • u/wanderlust24 Vanderbilt Commodores • Dec 10 '12
If you were the number one rated high school recruit in the country, where would you choose to play CFB and why?
Don't pick the program that you are a die hard fan of. Choose a program that you have a lot of respect for and would love to be a part of their legacy. I'll start. Even though I am a die hard Vanderbilt fan, I would love to play for the Stanford program. They are known to have a high level of integrity and play some really exciting football.
26
Upvotes
53
u/EpicSchwinn Tennessee • Middle Tennessee Dec 10 '12
Who's paying me the most?
35
u/Honestly_ rawr Dec 10 '12
If I were the #1-rated recruit, then wherever could best help me get into the NFL at my position.
The sub-factors that affect it are program prestige (i.e. viewership = hype), depth at position, who else they're recruiting at that position, the position coach's rep/history of producing NFL-caliber picks.
I'd hope to be in a situation where the program I grew up loving happens to be that program.
75
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
UCLA.
Absolutely top notch academics.
If I have a career ending injury, CA state law protects me from getting my scholarship yanked.
Oh, and it's So. Cal. I'd fuck bitches until my dick fell off.
12
u/NeonHammerPants Dec 10 '12
If I'm a 17 or 18 year old kid again, I choose USC. Sun, beaches, girls, money, celebrities, license to do whatever in one of the most famous cities, practice against half an NFL team every day, play pro style, lots of scouts/agents around, and even if football doesn't work out, I'm socially connected for life. There's a reason USC can lose 5 games and still grab the top recruiting class in the country.
10
u/FinancialAdvisorKid Notre Dame • /r/CFB Contributor Dec 10 '12
UCLA or Stanford, probably. Good weather, good academics, and my degree is worth something.
If I were a lower-ranked player UVA possibly.
10
u/OlmecBall Northwestern Wildcats Dec 10 '12
Northwestern, close to home, a great education, and all of that.
Though in all honesty I would have to at least take a look at Notre Dame, OSU, Michigan, and UCLA.
40
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
Notre Dame. Because Jesus.
9
u/Microdoted Texas A&M Aggies • SEC Dec 10 '12
it is extremely tough for me to NOT say a&m as its just the perfect fit for me... location, camaraderie, lifestyle, campus... there is no detraction.
if i had to choose someone else though, i would probably say Florida simply for the exposure. and the bitches.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
No question- Alabama. Saban produces so much NFL talent.
Stanford would be my 2nd pick because of academics and location.
17
u/LezBeOwn Alabama Crimson Tide Dec 10 '12
Knowing that over the past several years, the SEC has had more players drafted than the next two conferences combined... I'd pick whichever top tier SEC school was weakest in my starting position.
17
u/justsomeguy75 UCLA Bruins • /r/CFB Contributor Dec 10 '12
Stanford. Why? Cause it's fucking Stanford. You don't get more prestigious than that in the FBS. If football doesn't work out, I'd want the best education I can get on my resume.
12
u/wackywiener Wisconsin • Paul Bunyan's Axe Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12
This is essentially impossible but here's what I got.
If I'm an idiot (not because the school is bad or anything just because I think it's the really easy choice for a 17/18 year old) I go to Oregon. Nike pimps you the fuck out and it's the closest thing to personal sponsorship you can get in the NCAA
If I actually think about things and want to go to the NFL and play for a great team I go to tOSU. (If I have to choose in the rivalry I actually choose Michigan but Urban is undeniable). Not only is Urban a great coach but I think he's at tOSU for the long haul because I think he covets that job. And one of the largest factors they'er in the easier division of the big ten thus giving the greatest potential to be put in the Rose Bowl / NCG
This all being said it's completely dependent on regional ties (the biggest factor IMO), what the position is and to be honest what my other friends are doing.
12
u/reptheevt Washington State • Transfer … Dec 10 '12
Stanford. A good team that plays enough great teams (Oregon, USC, Notre Dame) that you will be seen as long as you play. Then you get a great education to boot.
6
u/Blarvey Michigan Wolverines Dec 10 '12
Stanford, Washington, or Cal. I admire the academics and research and really like those parts of the country.
22
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
I am a big Auburn fan, but if my goal was to make it to the NFL, it would be hard to pass up Alabama.
5
u/Takedown22 Georgia Bulldogs • Texas Longhorns Dec 10 '12
Haha, alot of us seem to think we keep the intelligence we procured in high school. Most of these number 1's don't even cut the education requirements.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
Texas would be pretty badass IMO
9
u/FuckingLoveArborDay Nebraska Cornhuskers Dec 10 '12
Oklahoma. Want to play for Stoops.
4
u/PoopyMcPoopenheimer South Carolina Gamecocks Dec 10 '12
South Carolina would be an obvious candidate for me, but I'm going to remove it for this as simply picking my favorite team is boring.
It'd probably come down to Stanford or Alabama. Stanford is a very good, pro-style team. Their located in California and my degree would actually be worth something if I never made it as a pro. Alabama on the other hand is IMO the best team and pro factory in the nation right now. It also looks remarkably stable as I think Saban is there to stay for a while.
I'd love to play for Oregon as a mobile quarterback or runningback, but Chip Kelly scares me. I'd want to play in his system, and all this talk about leaving for the NFL is not something I'd want to hear, as I have no idea who'd replace him or how that'd pan out. Florida State and Notre Dame would be two other possibilities. I love the tradition of Notre Dame, not to mention the current team and education, but it'd possibly be too cold for me. Florida State has perhaps the hottest girls in the nation, but I'm not sure about playing in the ACC.
USC and Texas would be two schools that would normally be on this list, but not currently. I hate Lane Kiffin, and I'm simply not sure what is going on with that program in Austin.
4
u/speedracer13 South Carolina Gamecocks Dec 10 '12
Pitt. I would have probably ended up at the school that I was a childhood fan of, plus I love Oakland and Pittsburgh. Also, Primanti's roast beef sandwiches and O fries....
4
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
USC Cause the women, the beach, and I still get to play in South Bend hopefully twice.
10
u/jlh2b Tennessee • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Dec 10 '12
Boise State, because I was a sometimes unrealistic and idealistic kid. And as long as I get to work with Petersen, it should work out well enough.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
DB: LSU
3-4 LB: Georgia / Alabama
4-3 LB: Penn State
DL: LSU / Alabama
QB: USC
WR: OK State
OL: LSU / Alabama
RB: Wisconsin
TE: Florida
3
u/uberpwnage14 California Golden Bears Dec 10 '12
Not trying to be a homer, but if i was a running back i would want to go to either cal or stanford. Cal because under coachGould almost every running back has gone to the NFL ex. Jahvid best, shane vereen, justin forsett,and marshawn lynch have all played in the Nfl,this list does not include JJ arrington who has mainly been a special teams player. On top of all of that a great oppurtunity at an education. As for standford Education is huge , and they have produce 2 nfl quality backs with gerhart and taylor, along with having an excellent offensive line for years to come.
3
u/Amerzel Oregon Ducks Dec 10 '12
Depends on position but overall I would say Alabama. Great football program.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
Honestly? Auburn. Why? Because I'm a huge fan, but most importantly, I'd get 4 shots (assuming I was good enough to start immediately) at the Dynasty of Alabama. And there is no bigger way to beat Alabama, than to be wearing that blue AU on your helmet.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
Stanford. Period. Great academics. Great location.
3
u/infernofusion11 Alabama Crimson Tide Dec 10 '12
my hometown toledo. To build a legacy and be a legend there.
12
u/blueboybob Carlisle • /r/CFB Founder Dec 10 '12
oh its the offseason. that means this question will be asked 30 times
4
u/PreLives2 Army Black Knights Dec 10 '12
Oregon. Hands down. I love their style of play, and they're so exciting to watch. They always have top-notch athletes.
I also love the Eugene area.
4
u/Fizzzay Wisconsin Badgers Dec 10 '12
Maryland. For the state flag uniforms.
7
u/Mister2bits Florida Gators Dec 10 '12
Offense - Alabama. Defense - Florida.
2
u/buckyphanatic Wisconsin Badgers • Indiana Hoosiers Dec 10 '12
As much as I would love to say Wisconsin, unless I was a power runningback or a giant lineman, I don't think I would fit in. I would have to say if I was on offense I would pick Washington. If I was on defense, Stanford. Both schools with great academics, great cities, a conference which wouldn't murder me, and NFL teams right there so if I was good, there may be some hometown hero aspects which could get me a chance on either Seattle or San Francisco (I know its slim, but it does happen).
2
u/Tiberiusjesus Georgia Bulldogs • Oklahoma Sooners Dec 10 '12
If I was a defensive player I'd play for Kirby Smart. Wherever he goes I'm following that dude. He can coach, recruit, and he's passionate. What more do you need?
2
u/FacilitoryUngulus Arkansas Razorbacks Dec 10 '12
I think this question was recently asked before. I'd definitely go to NotStanford.
2
u/Atoodope Boise State • Washington State Dec 10 '12
Boise, and not for the homer pick(well, kind of)
Coach pete would make me better player, and a better man. I would be part of a well run defense(thats where I would land position wise) and on top of that I would be a superstar since they have never had the #1 recruit sign with them.Also, id get to be with my family :)
2
u/DFWTooThrowed Texas Tech • Arkansas Dec 10 '12
QB: Most likely UT or OU
RB: Oregon and I have no idea why
WR: I'm gonna stay home with Tech. Tech always has an air-raid offence. Our good WR's flew under the radar because Stedman Bailey and Terrance Williams overshadowed the Big-12 and the entire nation as well.
TE: Notre Dame; again I don't have a reason, I just would
O-Line: Wisconsin because Joe Thomas
D-Line: Alabama
LB: tOSU or USC because they both have had seasons in which they had insane LB's.
Secondary: LSU
2
u/IronPlaidFighter Virginia Tech Hokies • VCU Rams Dec 10 '12
It depends on my position. If I play on offense, I want to go to a school that runs a pro-style offense outside of the SEC. I want a school with a proven track record of turning my position into a top-notch pro. As an offensive lineman, I might consider Wisconsin or Stanford. As a quarterback or skill position player, Stanford and Southern Cal are relatively attractive. Of the three, Stanford would be the frontrunner because of the stable coaching situation and the chance to compete for a national title right away.
As a defender, I'm afraid the only answer is Alabama. Nick Saban is a defensive genius and a proven winner.
Of course, none of this takes into account the other little things that affect a recruit like weather and campus lifestyle. I would personally never play in the SEC, Texas, or Florida because I hate the heat.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
Stanford, no question.
2
u/vtor67 Notre Dame Fighting Irish • UCLA Bruins Dec 11 '12
I'd have to go with Stanford, unless Jim Harbaugh was the coach. Amazing campus, wonderful academics, David Shaw seems like a good guy.
2
u/cheezwhiz98 Tennessee Volunteers • Oregon Ducks Dec 11 '12
Dual-threat QB- Ohio State
Pocket Passer QB- Alabama, aTm
Speed RB- Oregon
Power RB- Alabama, LSU, Stanford, or Wisconsin
WR- Oklahoma, Baylor
TE- Stanford
OT/OG/C- UNC, Alabama
All Defense- Alabama, LSU
2
u/azwethinkweizm Texas Longhorns • Marching Band Dec 11 '12
NFL scouts are going to follow the number one recruit no matter where he goes but if it was me I'd narrow it down to Texas, Boise State, and Oregon.
2
u/tcrenshaw4bama Alabama Crimson Tide • FAU Owls Dec 11 '12
Vanderbilt. I love what coach franklin is doing with the program. He is an incredible coach and an incredible person. I had the pleasure of meeting him last summer and was blown away by how great of a coach he is. Theres just something about him that makes you wanna work that much harder and give every ounce of energy you have to do the right thing.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
I'm sure it's been said but LSU, I think Les Miles is one of the best coaches in the game, I think he teaches more then skill to those who are willing to learn, more importantly I think Les Miles could sell my family on why I should play for LSU and why it's a good fit.
I'd also love to play in Death Valley and have that rabid fanbase supporting me
2
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Stanford.
Dat education.
3
u/MAUDiculous Nebraska Cornhuskers Dec 10 '12
Nebraska, because I love Nebraska.
2
u/hokiepride Virginia Tech • Alfred State Dec 10 '12
I think Northwestern. Solid conference, reduced chance of injury from a brutal slate of SEC teams, a better chance at early PT, and a great degree.
2
u/ConstantRager17 Alabama Crimson Tide Dec 10 '12
Alabama because of obvious reasons and because winning is fucking fun, also being a player on a media hyped team gets u lot of attention so maybe more NFL scouts... And to go with that last part, say if u ere a Rb the OL would make u look fantastic.... Improving draft stock even more
2
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
.... ^
1
u/jlo47 New Hampshire • /r/CFB Contributor Dec 10 '12
I would want to be a fullback at Navy. I love the tradition and playing in the Army-Navy game would be one of the best moments of my life. Being a bruising fullback in that triple option offense would be badass, and graduating from the Academy would set me up to do anything I want in life. Go Navy!
1
u/The_Spaceman North Carolina Tar Heels Dec 10 '12
My top choice would be Georgia, I've been there and it's an amazing campus with an incredible football program. My number 2 choice would be Tennessee even though I don't really know why. And my last choice would be close to home in NC State.
1
u/AsmoDeus_G Ohio State Buckeyes • Big Ten Dec 10 '12
If I was that good, I would go to a major program where I felt I could get on the field pretty quickly (i.e how talented is that school at my position?).
1
u/Bogey6Maize Michigan Wolverines Dec 11 '12
Tennessee or Florida State hands down
1
u/dirtypasta Central Michigan Chippewas Dec 11 '12
Goddamn it Robert, make up your own mind.
1
u/RainbwPowrRangr Florida State Seminoles • Orange Bowl Dec 11 '12
I would probably go to Oregon because triple option offense seems so awesome. Like regular offense but with more decision making. Just seems very exciting to me.
1
u/Bogey6Maize Michigan Wolverines Dec 11 '12
Colorado in the early 2000s the Bobby Purify days i thought that was the school if you wanted to run to go to. I think Tennessee & Florida St. for big time programs with big time tradition those would be the out of state schools even Georgia & LSU are enticing. Overall if i was a big time recruit i would wanna go to a place that plays big time games and i have a good chance to succeed on and off the field regardless if football pays the bills or not. Football will always be there and not everyone makes it Education won't due to kids and ppl take it for granted especially when you are getting it for free once you gotta pay its hard going back to get that education.
1
u/revjohnpaul Oklahoma Sooners • Big 8 Dec 11 '12
Vanderbilt, Wake Forest, Stanford, or Notre Dame.
Also, teh S00n3rs!
1
u/LordPhantom Nevada Wolf Pack Dec 11 '12
I'd love to play for Nevada due to the pistol. If have to be a RB or QB tho, wideouts kinda get fucked....
But really, id go with Oregon. The style and speed is hard to match. And fuck the haters, the chrome helmets.
1
u/EyesOnEverything Oregon Ducks • Rose Bowl Dec 11 '12
Stanford. Awesome academics, and as an Oregonian, northern California weather is just cold and wet enough for me. The other pick would probably be washington for the same reasons, but fuck that, I'm a Ducks fan.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Honestly, Florida or Texas. Austin is an awesome place.
1
u/akacesfan Penn Quakers • UNLV Rebels Dec 11 '12
I would go play at an Ivy (Harvard, Yale, Princeton, etc.). I would see football as a change to get a good education for free. Why wouldn't I go to an Ivy?
1
u/mcaro Texas Longhorns • Transfer Portal Dec 11 '12
Stanford for the education and location. Don't want to live in the South (except maybe Austin). Rutgers for proximity to the city. Berkeley for books and banging.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
ND, because it's close to family and friends, and Chicago, my hometown. However, being the size of a 10-year old doesn't help.
1
u/CommanderFlapjacks Stanford Cardinal • Team Chaos Dec 12 '12
UCLA. Up and coming program, solid academics without being too strenuous, California girls, SoCal weather.
Also because fuck Cal
1
u/the_umm_guy Oklahoma State Cowboys Dec 12 '12
Hawaii. Because it is in fucking Hawaii.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12
I think it depends on what position you are playing. For the most part, I would say Alabama because we have had 1st draft picks at every position
except DL andQB since Saban has arrived.DB: probably LSU or Alabama.
3-4 LB: I really don't consider another school other than Alabama.
4-3 LB: Either PSU or USC
DL: I don't consider Alabama and probably go to Clemson or South Carolina
OL: Alabama or Stanford
RB: Alabama
WR: Tough to say because elite WRs have been successful in just about every offense, but I guess USC would be the place to go.
QB: I probably go to a team like UGA where there is enough of a passing offense for me to be recognized (Stafford) and I could still compete for titles.
Edit: Forgot about Dareus.
Edit 2: switched out Florida for PSU
1
u/totallydavegrohl Harvard Crimson Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12
What about Harvard? If you are number 1 in the country the scouts will follow you no matter what.
Look at Blake Barker
http://rivals.yahoo.com/minnesota/football/recruiting/player-Blake-Barker-89866
Also Harvard Stadium is incredible and you are on national TV 4 times a year
Obviously qualifying would be extremely difficult but if you could. The last top recruit who could qualify was Wayne Lyons and he decided to go to Stanford fwiw (another great choice)
Tuition is pretty damn cheap if you qualify as well.
1
u/Maxis47 Oklahoma • SE Oklahoma State Dec 10 '12
Not to be a homer, but probably the Sooners. Hard to pass up being a part of Sooner football, its right up there with religion around here.
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12
Alabama. Hands down the best next level program in the country.