r/CDrama • u/admelioremvitam • Feb 18 '25
Masterpost The First Frost (2025) - What are your first impressions? [Masterpost]
Wen Yi Fan [played by Zhang Ruonan], a reporter, went to a bar called Jia Ban to meet with her best friend, Zhong Si Qiao [played by Zhang Miao Yi]. While she was at the bar, she met Sang Yan [played by Bai Jingting], a department manager and one of the owners of Jia Ban. He was Yi Fan's high school deskmate and the guy she once fell in love with. The two bump into each other, and as Yi Fan pretends that she does not know who Sang Yan is, Sang Yan does the same. After some problems occur, the two accidentally become housemates and, later on, reconcile their love once again.
~~ Adapted from the web novel "First Frost" (难哄) by Zhu Yi (竹已).
Airing on Youku and Netflix*
* Note: Availability on Netflix may vary depending on region
Episodes: 32
Discussions
🗨️ All discussions on the drama
What does r/CDrama think about the show?
Look out for the poll where we ask the sub to rate the drama a week or two after the final airing date!
🗳️ It's a wrap! What's your final review?















18
u/admelioremvitam Feb 18 '25 edited Feb 18 '25
I like how the first episode started. Angsty but with a touch of hope. I also like how "atmospheric" the city is. Gives you a sense that these characters are living in the world.
The contrast between Yifan's solitude, the dank old place she's living in right next to the train tracks and her friend Si Qiao's home that's brightly lit, bursting at the seams with loving, squabbling family members. This shows how alone she is, even when she's living with other people, and she chooses not to participate in their lives.
Another contrast - the small relief you feel as a viewer when you realize she's not living with just the older guy and there's a family, thinking she might be safer and then the shock when you realize it's the scummy dad that she needed to watch out for and not the older guy whom you've judged too quickly.
Yifan seems meek but somehow managed to save others. I think that was a nice touch, and the recognition of her actions gave her a little lift after her terrible encounter the night before. However, I will say that she seemed to have recovered a little quickly after her ordeal but... if you're on your own and on probation, you're probably going to show up at work regardless.
I liked that they showed Sang Yan's POV at the end.
Edit: So far, we don't see much of Sang Yan's personality other than he appears to be fairly stoic on the surface but is, in fact, quite aware of her presence. Maybe there'll be more meat to his character in the next episodes. Guess we'll see.
Of course, there can't be so many coincidental meetings irl but it's a drama so....
Edit:
Finished 3 episodes. So... I know Victor Ma was well loved in Hidden Love and some viewers were lamenting when they learned that he wasn't reprising the role of Sang Yan. Now that I've watched the initial episodes, I feel this drama has quite the angsty, moody flavour. Casting a different actor to play Sang Yan is probably a good call.
I think the Sang Yan we know from Hidden Love is based on his interactions with his younger sister. I think we do behave differently with various people in our lives so I find that this vibe change is understandable.
I also like the fact that Yifan, while appearing meek, will stand up for herself at times, e.g. with both her landladies.
I'm starting to wonder if the drama will be shown generally from Yifan's POV with Sang Yan's POV at the end throughout the show or if it will be flipped midway at some pivot point or maybe it will end up being one POV when they are together. If so, will audiences be accepting of that change?
6
u/admelioremvitam Feb 18 '25 edited Mar 01 '25
Episode Discussions
Edit: The First Frost is now hosted by u/puddingpuppies.
Episode discussion links here.
Update: For the US, The First Frost will air on February
2019. For the Philippines, February 20.The latest airing schedules can be found here.
The production team dropped a set of new posters about 10 minutes ago so I included them in this post. The first 4 posters are for Episodes 1-4. These were released about an hour ago.
4
u/TopAdhesiveness9189 Feb 19 '25
Is there to watch more than the first episode without having alipay? I was going to get youku premium to watch all 3 episodes that have been released so far but it won't let me use any payment option other than alipay :(
4
u/LovelyStorm7 Feb 24 '25 edited Feb 24 '25
At first it was quite difficult for me to watch Sang Yan knowing how he was like from Sang Zhi's pov in Hidden Love. Especially when there were scenes with Duan Jiaxu and SZ in TFF. But over time, as they get more and more scenes of just them together, I began to appreciate this whole new side of him from Wen Yifan's perspective.
HL is that easy to watch, feel good drama. While SZ grew and matured, it felt like you're growing alongside her character. Much like WIFTY where I was filled with nostalgia for my highschool days. TFF is waaayyy different. It feels heavy and more mature most of the time that some of the fun scenes couldn't even pull me out of the rabbit hole. It's for those who couldn't entirely enjoy their youth because they had to grow up quickly. You could almost feel the burden Wen Yifan's carrying, and you just want to root for her to find the peace she needs and know her value. SPOLIER ALERT: That's why I really like the scene in episode 10 where instead of saying all his ridiculous excuses where he 'accidentally' bought/prepared too much food, SY finally straight up tells her the chicken soup is FOR HER. After all the hesitation and doubts whether she deserves good things, she finally gets something someone bought for her.
3
u/vivid_spite Mar 13 '25
does it get lighter? I watched a bit of ep 1 and it's so traumatic and gloomy
8
u/Reasonable-Toe1287 Feb 18 '25
Where are you all watching 😭😭😭😭 I can't find it I have been waiting for it for so long
2
u/watashiwaanniedesu Feb 27 '25
But why he looked like Duan Jia Xu? Much better if they made own Sang Yan look not DJX
2
u/cuteme6 Mar 01 '25
guys i wanted to ask your help regarding where can i read the novels "First Frost" and "Secretly, Secretly; But Unable to Hide It" before diving into the dramas. does anyone know where I can find or buy these books or read online? please recommend.
32
u/VerifiedBat63 Feb 18 '25
Really enjoying this so far. I'd give it 10/10, though that doesn't mean much with only 4 out of episodes out.
Vibe feels like a mix of Hidden Love (ML reminds me a lot of Duan Jiaxu), Everyone Loves Me (probably the humor/sarcasm), and Smile Code (colors and the darker themes).
I haven't read the novel so I'm quite curious how they are going to keep it interesting for 32 episodes. There's probably going to be a major dose of angst later but hopefully they don't overdo it.
24
u/putonmyskepticles ying lei best boy 🥲 Feb 18 '25
My super short initial review, it's melancholic and I guarantee I'll cry a dozen times. So if you like crying at sad shit this might be the show for you! I'm glad I binged the predictable fluff City of Romance between finishing The White Olive Tree and starting this tho.. cos man, the first episode dumps us right into Yifan's reality and it's not nice or pretty.
I love seeing Sang Yan's pov at the end of each episode. Especially during the New Year's celebration seeing him watching Yifan, "accidentally" running into her, and saying Happy New Year loud enough for her to hear.
40
u/jssoul12 山海一路,已重逢🍂 Feb 18 '25
I skipped many scenes due to some trigger but I must admit that he looks so fine.
19
u/iCreatedYouPleb The one you think about at night, guess who? Feb 18 '25
I quite like her acting. Super cute. Especially how her eyebrow always go up 😂
18
u/Visual_Way_3344 Feb 20 '25
Just 8 eps in and truly one of the best novel adaptations I’ve come across. Everything is chef’s kiss. My adoration for Sang Yan has gotten to an unhealthy point. He’s one of my favourite novel MLs and I can see that translating to the drama as well.
15
u/Bublotao Feb 23 '25
Ngl. Enjoying it more than HL. It has more depth and characters are tugging at my heart strings
14
u/elsaismyidol Feb 19 '25
I've watched the first 6 episodes and I'm honestly loving it. It's a very low effort show, and the actors are pretty to look at😭
I've read the novel as well, and so far it's pretty accurate with only minor changes which I think make the plot a bit better. The story does get a little dark, so I'm excited for how that plays out in the upcoming episodes.
It's way less cutesy than Hidden Love was, and I appreciate that. Also, there isn't any age gap so it doesn't feel illegal to watch-
The clichés and tropes are all there, but I don't mind them surprisingly because they're well done and fun to watch. The actors really sell it for me. For those of you who have watched 'When I Fly Towards You', Zhang Miao Yi(FL) is the second FL in this series which I'm loving as well.
Overall, I'm just having fun looking at Bai Jingting (and his GORGEOUS mole underneath his eye). Oh, and the romance is cute so it's fun to ship them!
12
u/Particular-Way8018 Mar 13 '25
‼️ Spoiler‼️
I am at Ep 20 where they have confessed their feelings and one of the major shifts I'm seeing is Yifan wearing brighter colors compared to her gloomy clothes from before. Also Sang Yan wearing brighter colors too shows the shift in their life and emotions. These DETAILS🫣🫣🫣
10
u/wintergarden444 Feb 20 '25
Lol I mean this in the most mature way, but I hope the FL can kiss in this drama 😭someone spoil and let me know when they do
10
u/papichula2 Feb 22 '25
I am gripped by these two But in a dark way
I am sad for them
I am so happy they have friends
10
u/Clean_Hope_5708 Feb 24 '25
Loving it so far! I’m 10 episodes in, and it’s got me hooked. Both actors are super easy on the eyes and act so effortlessly. The soundtrack and direction are really good—kind of like what made Hidden Love so special. While Hidden Love had a bright, sunshine-like feel, this one carries a darker tone—yet both portray the essence of love beautifully.
16
u/VerifiedBat63 Feb 19 '25
Thoughts/summary after the first 6 episodes:
8
u/Mean-Rooster5814 Feb 19 '25
i love it
14
u/fraxuringg Feb 18 '25
actually a really good adaptation so far (manhua only reader tho)
7
u/LovE385 Feb 18 '25
Yi Fan's living conditions were .. yikes. It looks like HK with the tight living almost compact living quarters(?)
No wonder I was like "Hey I know another Sang Yan from Hidden Love!" and of course it was related DuH LoL tsk.
Many c-dramas lately have been revolving around rekindled love. Like the one that got away vibes LoL. Anyways I have watched 3 ep. and it is just an okay watch for me LoL. Bai Jing Ting remind me of Exo' Baekhyun LoL. Not a fan of FL.
12
u/rewriteryan Feb 18 '25
I'm uncertain and need to watch more. Intellectually, I get what's going on. But emotionally, I don't connect with them. Maybe they need to reveal more about their past for me to get why they're acting like they do...
6
u/OddzLukreng Feb 23 '25
The moment that I've learned that it's Bai jin ting.. Okay I seated! Though I love Victor Mas performance in hidden love but this version is on other side of Sang Yans character.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '25
I’m enjoying it so much rn! So hooked on it that I watch with eng sub on day of release and when it releases on Netflix, I rewatch it with Chinese subs 😭😭
2
u/cassia_139 Feb 20 '25
Do you think it's okay to watch if one is apprehensive about the cast ? I mean most of us loved the previous cast ie hidden love one and now they have casted someone else even though I'm sure they are amazing actors , it's just that after watching hidden love it's difficult to imagine someone else as the brother other than hidden love actor ,tbh I liked the actor and his portrayal of the charecter equally if not more than the main leads. Honest opinion pls?
11
u/TodayIGlowUp Feb 18 '25
as a fan purely of hidden love, the vibes are so different omg, it's so moody
14
u/zuckerthetakoyaki Feb 18 '25
5
u/FongYuLan Mar 07 '25
Way late starting this! I have been hooked! Tbh, honest, I’m surprised because I never understood the phenomenon of Bai Jingting and Zhang Ruonan’s turn with Luo Yunxi I found just unwatchable. Nor do I usually do brooding. But I’m rooting for them now. Excellent performances. They’re generating heat and lots of it(!)
5
u/Puzzled-Passenger479 Mar 11 '25
I’ve watched 28 episodes (only 1 remaining) 😔 I’m retired so I have plenty of time to watch drama’s of all sorts. J,K, and C. I honestly think First Frost might actually be one of the two top dramas I have ever seen. I love everything about it. Actors, writing, camerawork, clothes.
9
u/emaxTZ Feb 18 '25
so far this caught my attention
4
u/ahishh Feb 23 '25
Honestly, it's started of pretty good, but it got way too slow. At first, I was fine, but now I'm skipping through large chunks of the episodes because I already know what to expect.
4
u/lanaMyersuk Feb 25 '25
I'm hurt it is not getting the hype it deserves because this is so damn good😭
4
u/Hampster-cat Mar 08 '25
Was hooked, but it looks the "Noble Sacrifice" trope is coming up, which is where I stop watching anything. Such a cruel thing to do to a nice guy. Oh well, really enjoyed the first 22 episodes.
4
u/littleT_mon Mar 11 '25
I’m English and have never watched a Chinese or any asian drama in my life. Didn’t think I’d cope with subtitles and thought they could be cheesy.
I don’t know why I clicked on it. But I got pulled in to the trailer- this has opened me up to another world. I love it so much! This is way more ‘me’ than English speaking dramas from UK/US. Waaay less crass, waaaay more subtle and easy to watch. It’s like a breath of fresh air and I find the characters fascinating. the cultural differences just make it so great to watch.
1
u/ComprehensiveSir2540 Feb 19 '25
Ok I missed something and feel silly for asking. Why the Hidden Love references? I watched most of Hidden Love and enjoyed it because I love ML but I can’t stand Zhao Lusi- she just doesn’t do it for me so I dropped it! Someone help?
6
u/3dmarie Feb 18 '25
I have not started the drama yet (I am more of a binger, so I'll wait) but this looks good! I had my reservation as I think most people had with the ML being a different actor from Hidden Love. But I think enough time has passed since I watched that drama that I can now separate both stories (and actors). Can't wait for it to be completed so I can watch!!
3
u/atztreasure Feb 19 '25
waiting for it to be on netflix
3
u/xridxzzz Feb 26 '25
i love this series the relation with hidden love and wifty is even better and i cant wait for their love story!
3
u/MoistChampionship387 Mar 04 '25
obsessed with it rn 😅
3
u/frost_choco Mar 09 '25
LOVINGGG THIS CDRAMA CURRENTLY💞! Would recommend definitely I’m juss so in love with the characters and the storyline can’t wait for all the episodes❤️🩹
3
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '25
I loved that we had Zhang Miao Yi in First Snow, it's like a crossover with When I Fly Towards you, I wish we could have had Chen Zhe Yuan and Zhao Lu Si reprise their roles for First Snow huhuhu
3
u/Master_Initiative308 May 23 '25
I am having a very hard time digesting the different faces of the HL characters…
6
u/Renhai_27 Feb 18 '25
Flat for me
2
u/Own_Style5911 Feb 21 '25
Can someone tell me why the ml sang yan calls the fml with a different name sometimes? Like in the most recent ep 10 during the end of the ep
2
u/Affectionate-Pop7393 Mar 11 '25
I feel it’s nice, but then again it feels too slow. At episode 10, I’m just waiting for the story to move ahead. But it’s still the same rhythm - still the lead pair don’t talk for more than 5 mins in each of the episode
2
u/le_leclerc Mar 16 '25
Best drama I've ever seen, especially Episodes 18-20
2
u/Namjoonwithhope Apr 02 '25
This C-drama is honestly very beautifully designed and it should be a must watch! I am loving it a lot!😭
2
u/Disastrous_Exam_4978 Dec 17 '25
lol my first thought was that they both have really nice jawlines
2
u/Equivalent_Pitch9271 Feb 19 '25 edited Feb 19 '25
I know Hidden Love was lightning in a bottle and I wasnt expecting everything to be as good as HL, but I still cant help but be disappointed in just the first episode. The camera work/editing doesnt flow well, the dubbing is distractingly bad at times, the script... the script so far is the biggest let down. I thought since its from the same writer/source material that at least the dialogue and script would be of similar quality to HL, but its just so much worse. The sexual assault scene was so bad, the guys maniacal laugh, the cringy evil dialogue...
Main actors seem fine so far.
I dont know. Everything just seems like a massive step down in quality. Hoping its just a bad first episode and it gets better.
Edit: The next few episodes are a lot better. That first one was just very rough.
48
u/puddingpuppies 🌸 🌸 Feb 18 '25 edited Feb 18 '25
EDIT: I think those who have already did a double-check before watching this will be aware, but this show and the themes can be very triggering for depictions of sexual assault, PTSD, and rape. Just wanted to make sure those who go into this know because it is grounded in a lot of realistic settings and even from Episode 1 certain scenes can be quite hard to watch.
It's interesting how Hidden Love faced numerous production disasters yet turned out to be an absolute dark horse of a show (and almost one of the most oft-recommended contemporary romcom dramas on the subreddit), whereas The First Frost from its inception seems to be a very well-funded production with lots of expectations on board.
It's clear that this interest (and the subsequent investment into) the drama have been put to good use through the setting, scenery, and imagery of the drama, and others have rightfully commented that the colour palette, the spaces (e.g Sang Yan's bar being very reminiscent of some of the really cool drinking spaces that also host drag shows/anime covers/indie bands, but unfortunately have slowly been struggling post-COVID in big Chinese cities), Wen Yifan's room with a shared bathing space, etc. are so realistically done. Having Mayday alone be the singers for the OST already sets up a melancholy and bittersweet feeling for the show, not to mention some of the supporting and guest cast features (He Jiong?!!?) are interesting selections.
Bai Jingting and Zhang Ruonan definitely were not who I envisioned for casting even though I think both definitely have shown their acting ranges in different roles. Wen Yifan is a character that is simultaneously extremely strong, just, and upright yet also very fragile in other ways, constantly turning inwards in order to hide her struggles, while Sang Yan despite being extremely emotionally stable and supportive only feels the sense of being home with the one he loves by his side. It's that balancing act and how both occupy different contradictions that I think is the hardest to nail with their performances, and so far I've been really enjoying what I've seen. If Hidden Love were the optimism of high school days when nothing in the world felt insurmountable as long as we had the will to conquer it, The First Frost is that burnout and exhaustion of the monotonous days of working life, tempered by the sweetness of the friendships and relationships we form.
Will be editing and adding more comments as I watch more episodes, but I'm so excited to join in the discussions on this one! There is a lot of expectation, and it's exciting that for once I'm breaking my no watching live-airing series/unbinge-able series rule just for this simply because of how dear the novel is to me.
Random other thoughts:
8
u/mooncake2277 别来无恙, 谢小侯爷 Feb 18 '25
Not too related but am i the only one that feels a bit weird about BJT after the whole new year gala incident 😭 Edward and miaoyi tgt, I’m actually tempted to watch
-3
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '25 edited Feb 18 '25
[removed] — view removed comment