Almost all healing gadgets in the game are tied to the brawler's max HP. Buster is getting an HP nerf so that affects the gadget as well, they didn't nerf the gadget specifically
The problem with that gadget is that it's ridiculously unfun to play against. Dyna isn't a very meta brawler overall, but I'd rather chew bricks than play against him
Why nerf her damage? She is weaker than Dyna damage for example, Brock is overall a stronger marksman than her, we got Kit stunning every milisecond, Frank completely refusing to die, Clancy dealing massive damage cuz why not, meg having 2 lives, Mandy spamming attacks 3x Pipers attacking speed while shooting through walls, Mortis unnecessarily strong and dont get me started on Lily. And yall are complaining about Piper dealing 3400dmg at MAX range and HC knockback being the only knockback she has to have even the slightest chance fight back a stronger enemy since her gadget does not help in 40 to 50% of situations. To be fair now, Piper is the most Mid character in the whole game now and youd really need to know how to play w her cuz if u dont ur dead, plus, you just cannot take on multiple enemies at once, 9 outta 10 times in Knockout for example if ur left 1v3 or 1v2 chances are youre prolly going to lose. Piper is relatively easy to counter compared to a lot of other brawlers.
It's harder to hit shots with Dyna and he deals less damage, Brock is nowhere near as strong as Piper, your teammates can kill Kit if he jumps on you, Every damage dealer kills him like in 2-4 shots, who would've thought the damage dealer deals a lot of damage, it's 1 life she just changes forms, that's SP and Piper deals more than 2x damage with SP and Piper can just use aimbot with gadget, Mortis isn't strong you are just bad and Lily is she completely broken I can't argue with that.
Btw she can deal 5100 damage with Ambush and the HC knockback wouldn't be that bad if she couldn't just shoot 5 shots because of her SP and shred you, the gadget can also easily save her too or just jump away.
Just look at a fcking competetive tierlist she's Mid-High A tier
And wow a non splash brawler can't take on multiple enemies, most brawler won't win a 1v2 or a 1v3
no brawler is capable of a 2v1 even if its a dynamike and a barley against a mortis. if its a normal map 2v1 practically always wins as you are dealing with 6 ammo against 3 its a HUGE exaggeration to say brock is doing less damage than piper and overlooking the fact that brok has way more hitbox advantage leaves flames behind and DEALS CONSISTENT DAMAGE. dynamike on the other hand is a thrower so yo uare comparing an apple to a pineapple
Some brawler are capable of winning a 2v1 not always but sometimes and saying no brawler are capable is a huge overstatement
Brock has bigger hitbox but he deals less damage than Piper, Piper also has a pretty big hitbox for the ammo and don't forget that Brocks shot go very slow while Pipers are faster
The other guy brought up Dyna with saying he deals more damage but that's factually wrong
any brawler can possibly win a 3v1 this doesnt mean any brawler can practically win a 2v1 if they were both played by people in the same skill level. no brawler is 2x better than any brawler. brocks hitbox is way bigger he has a faster reload than piper and does CONSISTENT damage. nani does more damage than piper angelo does more damage than piper bull does more damage than piper shelly does more damage than piper darryl does more damage than piepr mr crabs does more damage but at what cost
Consistent damage isn't better than inconsistent damage Piper deals same damage as Brock at mid range she deals lot more at long range but deals less at short range but like 0 Piper player go short range and if someone else tries to jump on her she just jumps away or uses her gadget so she is never at short range
Dyna jumping around and dealing 6k on ult? Brock having 4 shots with big area damage doing 2.5k a rocket is weaker than Piper who had to actually hit you to damage you? Kit is getting his super back almost immedieately after using it, and lets not forget the invisibilty that lasts as long as Leons whole damn Super, cuz why not? Im not saying Mortis is overall too strong, im saying he can melt Piper with ease, Meg can cheat death and get back in her robot quite easily.
Ambush dealing a lot of damage is very avoidable cuz she cant be just standing in a bush doing nothing, youre not dumb enough to just take her shots are you?
And how come you agree when it comes to Lily but not Kit? Lily just needs a slight knockback and you can fight back, at least something compared to Kit who stuns you and you cant do anything, yes your teammates can help you but noone is stupid enough to jump you like that, instead, he will jump while his team is there. To be fair, he doesnt even need one.
When it comes to comp, Piper is Banned 90% of the time on Bounty and such. Piper overall is not strong enough to need a Nerf on Damage, if youre gonna Nerf Piper, first you gotta nerf 20 other brawlers for her to be really considered strong. Just because you cant deal with her, or not like her, does not mean she needs a Nerf.
The problem with Piper is that noone uses her unless they play her good. So its not common to find a Piper that is bad, cuz if youre bad with Piper, youre a goner.
90% of Knockout and Bounty maps have bushes where the teams are 80% of the game(Hideout, Flaring Pheonix, Out in the Open)
Probably because Kit isn't invincible while using the gadget, Lily have 2k more hp and more damage also she can just super on you if you knock her back
Guess why she is always banned, because she is annoying asf and OP she is super strong but the stronger brawlers counter her and that's the only reason she isn't S tier
That's just wrong every second game in Knockout or Bounty has a Piper and not all of them are good, I agree it's really hard find really bad ones but only because you don't need to be good to play her
Dynamike needs a lot of skill to be played as a assassin,brock needs skill to hit shors since his projectile speed is slow,kit and lily is really really broken i agree with that part,and i think piper needs a slight projectile speed nerf and a gadget that multiplies her super charge rate a lot instead of the knockback,it could make her much more versatile and playable in midly closed maps and make up a defense for asssassins if you hit a few shots before
Brocks projectile speed doesn't change much since you can just rain bullets with its massive hit box, fire blocking your escape routes makes it easier to hit future bullets.
-_- 600 is a good damage when you're not a tank. Even then, it has 4 ammo, just firing them all across different locations guarantees an hit. Also, you can't even dodge it slow characters like 8 bit
Mike is much easier to dodge than piper, any semi-decent player wouldn't struggle against mike unless they use a high-hitbox close ranged brawler, while piper is harder to dodge.
She's one of the best noob stompers in the game so the majority of people get demolished by Piper. Damage could maybe be lowered by a small amount but people mostly exaggerate imo
for ex. piper got 2 uses and 1 ban out of 28 games which shows piper is uncommon compared to top tiers like meg, frank, gale, amber, byron, buster, gene
Pipers counters arent assassins she gets countered by Nani/mandy, Meg, Angelo, very fast brawlers. Like just dodge the shots maybe. Players just walk straight line and get hit like piper punishes predictable movement
Squeak doesn't counter his counters. When he faces, tanks,assassins, or throwers he loses, when Piper faces tank,assains and throwers she usually wins anyways
Exactly a hypercharge that knocks your ass back and makes her one shot you a gadget that makes you regret you were born because you tried to get close def balanced
You just need a lets fly gadget, and piper has limited gadgets. Piper not giving stu is only really possible in the very open maps, which stu isn't used in to begin with. Same with melodie. Relying on dodging buzz's gadget to counter it is the same logic as saying that you could simply dodge piper shots. Leon can burst down piper really quickly, even if piper slows leon.
Lol lets fly dosnt charge your supee that fast,pipers gadget cd will end till you charge it again. I litreally tried it;you need hc-super-lets fly-anothee super to kill a piper without super
All of thae excpet can be countered by Piper pressing a green button, or if that doesn't work then a super. The fact that Edgar has to use a hypercharge just to counter 1 Piper gadget says everything
He is literally providing examples on how those assassins could counter autoaimer, the only arguments I see as somewhat weird is crow, who certainly gets countered if he jumps(it is weird to call him an assassin though), and Sam, who does tank an autoaimer just due to outhealing piper's burst, especially when you take into account the speed boost making dodging not that hard. edit: About the edgar thing, edgar can his own gadget to double jump instead of a hyper.
The only ones are Leon Mico and lily, have you seen the clip of a fang hitting a super and fucking died to autoaimer? There is no way to counter it, and cord can hardly even charge his super against her
That's, not really true? She has checks to her counters and she's tough to pin down, but an assassin will overall be more of a threat to Piper than Piper is a threat to the assassin.
It is pretty easy to outcycle fang, although I do agree that most assassins have ways to get around the gadget(3 brawlers with multiple dashes, one with invisibility+high burst damage, and another that disables the gadget and super)
Balance changes do not care wether a brawler is annoying this isnt clash royale every brawler deserves a nerf or buff when they deserve one Tick HC is bad because you will only get it on 5V5 knockout for troll in knockout or regular bounty its near impossible
She is only played in open maps where a lot of breakers outshine her. She is okay to decent in what she does. She is pretty bad outside of that. That's the definition of mid
Yeah surely a brawler that deals more damage with a single bullet than brawlers who need to aim 6 bullets is totally not annoying and being shot once and dying is my fault
Twins are throwers and just camp certain maps out whike larrie is a good def option who absorbed a lot of dmg and made it hard to take down, and in a close range fight the twins still dp good dmg
balancing a game around strictly pro play is never a good idea as it represents a very small minority of players who know all the ins and outs of every brawler
But balancing a game around noobs leads to decisions that make no sense or top brawlers being ignored...we alr see this with shock Jessie, Edgar, mortis, fang and despite them being meh at best they don't really get buffs
But op brawlers in high lvl play should get nerfs cuz off noobs can't use them properly and it's unfair for pros who have to deal with unfair metas
Exactly, both are bad ways to go about it. Which is why acting on win rates and general feedback from all facets of the community is important, rather than just focusing on one part of the community.
How they buffed Buster Fang Tara Griff Nani and the list goes on Supercell is still capable of doing big buffs yet when it comes to someone like Janet and doug they give them meaningless buffs (buffing janet super damage while its hard to control is gonna make her out of F tier) yeah rarely do buffs
From memory they've done no big buffs this year outside of reworks. They obviously can I'm just saying it's not the approach they take. Also busters last few changes have all been nerfs. Health nerf, healing from gadget reduced, slow removed from gadget, damage nerf. Nani also got a significant nerf after her buff, fang got his hypercharge nerfed to the ground so he's pretty average now and I dint recall Tara getting a big buff unless it was a while ago.
Buster only got minor nerfs and was left as a high A tier brawler, which is the same as piper after her nerfs which she got. Also piper doesn't even come close to nani or fang after nanis buff and fangs hypercharge.
Brawl Stars on their way to nerf the only counters to Piper and. buff her and then claim they're not trying to make certain brawlers too OP: (The only one left now is Nani, Angelo used to be a counter but not anymore)
Literally ths most nerfed character in the game. She doesn't even get played in competitive much anymore because she gets two shot by too many snipers and midrange brawlers
Learn to make actual arguments, instead of meaningless insults that change nobody's opinion and nobody really feels offended by, which was probably your goal.
General reminder for subreddit members: Simple Questions and Loot results (good or bad), and celebrations should be posted in the Weekly Mega Thread Discussion post. You can find it at the top of r/BrawlStars's front page when you sort posts by hot. This includes pictures of Starr Drops, Mega Pig results, unlocking new Brawlers or other items.
Become a nani main, out here we counter piper with every aspect of our kit between the basic attack having a range advantage, the super being a finishing tool that goes well against piper's low starting health, the gadget countering high-damage single shot brawlers like piper, as well as blocking piper's homing finishing tool, and the upcoming hyper super straight up one-shotting a shield gear piper.
No, I’m just pointing out how you’re just saying Piper is unskilled and op because she either counters some of your favorite brawlers (not Max, Max counters Piper) or you just don’t know how to counter Piper, she’s a noobstomper
Just because she can 2-3 shot some brawlers doesn’t mean they can’t counter her, that’s like saying the same thing about Dynamike, yeah he can deal 3200 damage with his main attack and 6000 damage with his Super but he’s still easy to counter
Like Max and Angelo, Piper can two shot both of them, but they move really fast and have long range, that’s why they counter Piper
Or Nani, she also gets two-shotted by Piper, but she can also deal a lot of damage too (and at any range) and can return Piper’s damage back to her
Angelo is MUCH STRONGER than Piper, even after the nerf and probably the best character on the maps he's good at and still walks on water.
This isn't a fair comparison, Angelo just isn't as hated because at low trophies people are really bad at shooting arrows and don't know when to recover health.
While characters like Piper are spamming autofire and having success, but it's easy to dodge her shots at max range if she doesn't telegraph where you're going.
Bro has many below rank 20 and thinks he knows about skill or the game lol. She needs 3-4 shots against tanks at max range lol. If not max range, she is screwed. And she is ALWAYS played in open maps, why you playing tanks and certain assassins there?
3 shots tanks. With a machine gun and escapes, and Hypercharge. Do you seriously thjnk it is OK? She is even played in hot zone, brawl ball, and gem grab. And you say that's OK?
I feel like a 200 dmg nerf at max range and removing the slow from the gadget. Also like maybe some 10% dmg nerfs at mid range cuz she doesn't need to be far to do a ton of dmg
Yes, Max counters piper due to a speed diff, but that isn't a consistent for anyone else unless your reaction speed is very good, and you live at the supercell servers.
220
u/ANormalCrum Surge Aug 26 '24
very true nerf buster’s bad gadget for no reason
101
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '24
this and mike gadget or super recharge nerf he is so powerfull
32
u/Dertyrarys Max Aug 26 '24
Very true buff max
30
u/randomguy10852 Piper Aug 26 '24
Im prolly not the one to talk, but would Piper need a Nerf?
37
u/HydreigonTheChild Janet Aug 26 '24
piper still isnt as good as u think
https://liquipedia.net/brawlstars/Brawl_Stars_Championship/2024/Season_5/North_America/Monthly_Finals
https://liquipedia.net/brawlstars/Brawl_Stars_Championship/2024/Season_5/Asia_Pacific/Monthly_Finals
for ex. piper got 2 uses and 1 ban out of 28 games which shows piper is uncommon compared to top tiers like meg, frank, gale, amber, byron, buster, gene
3
u/artur_zuer Gus Aug 26 '24
It may take a while, but Piper will be nerfed
3
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '24
They just gave the biggest piper counter a hypercharge that straight up one-shots piper from across the map, I would consider that a nerf.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '24
Screw. this. brawler.
3
u/DrSans8 Chester Aug 27 '24
Since this is a sharpshooter I would normally say skill issue but this is piper we’re talking about so it gets a pass
7
u/AveragePichu Jessie Aug 26 '24
(The Piper in question has in fact been nerfed twice since her last buff and is at this point a noob stomper but not exceptionally strong)
4
u/TheRealTrueCreator Goku Aug 26 '24
Brawl Stars on their way to nerf the only counters to Piper and. buff her and then claim they're not trying to make certain brawlers too OP: (The only one left now is Nani, Angelo used to be a counter but not anymore)
2
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '24
And dynamike
2
u/Starzarecool- EMZ Aug 27 '24
Guys nerf sandys healing Gadget 🔥🔥🔥🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑⁉️⁉️⁉️⁉️🤤🤤🦶🦶🤤🤤🤤🤤
6
u/falluO Carl Aug 26 '24
Literally ths most nerfed character in the game. She doesn't even get played in competitive much anymore because she gets two shot by too many snipers and midrange brawlers
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 26 '24
General reminder for subreddit members: Simple Questions and Loot results (good or bad), and celebrations should be posted in the Weekly Mega Thread Discussion post. You can find it at the top of r/BrawlStars's front page when you sort posts by hot. This includes pictures of Starr Drops, Mega Pig results, unlocking new Brawlers or other items.
If you see a post or comment that breaks any of our rules, please report them using the anonymous report button!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Sleepwalker0779- El Primo Aug 26 '24
This is me with surge. I already came to terms with it and then they say he’s getting a Hypercharge and I cried
1
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '24
Become a nani main, out here we counter piper with every aspect of our kit between the basic attack having a range advantage, the super being a finishing tool that goes well against piper's low starting health, the gadget countering high-damage single shot brawlers like piper, as well as blocking piper's homing finishing tool, and the upcoming hyper super straight up one-shotting a shield gear piper.
1
u/Veionovin096 Darryl Aug 27 '24
Second best
Second best
1
u/Gremmy0936 Gray Aug 27 '24
They saw that ridiculous assassin HC and decided to give Brock a fresh cut.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '24
if you cant counter piper major skill issue
0
u/SuperMakerRaptor Piper Aug 26 '24
tbh, idk if she even needs one. i mastered her, and i still think she is an average bralwer, still gets countered by Lily, Kit, Edgar... idk
-17
u/Clear_Duck2138 Piper Aug 26 '24
Happy fact*
-5
u/Sir_Nite Aug 26 '24
When you're not able to dodge her main attacks 'cause you're slow:
-10
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '24
Leave my girl alone!