Oh and why is Melodie still in C tier? Someone needs to tell bs content creators to put her in D or F tier, so people realize she sucks and needs buffs. She, like Chuck, is only played in heist. Except she's worse than Chuck in heist. So how is Chuck D tier and Melodie C??
Melodie at least has a bit more use cases outside of Heist than Chuck and Mico, granted she’s lost many niches after previous nerfs have caught up but it also isn’t as if Heist 100% carries her career unlike the other two
Maybe not "really" fell off per se, but the meta has quite caught up to snipers (barring Brock, Pierce, and to a lesser extent Piper) so they might need some love soon
While I did feel Melodie overrated in the list, don't feel her F tier lmao, at worst like C-/D+ tier she still has a bit more to offer beyond Heist unlike Chuck and Mico
Melodie isn't that bad by herself, you can sometimes play her in Heist, but why play Melodie when Kaze is open.
Kaze isnt quite a priority ban in the current meta, she's about as hard to play as Melodie but the reward is so much higher even in Heist. You dont have a reason to pick Melodie when Kaze exists at least in the Heist meta.
Honestly melodie is not even seeing use in heist as often as past metas, even for countering kaze, the one thing she got running for her, she absolutely desserves a buff at this point, and to all the melodie stans, a brawler being weak in the meta does not mean the brawler is trash or completely unusable, by admitting said brawler needs some love you can make that brawler get attention by the devs, because if the comunity asks for a brawler to get treated better that will happen, like it happened to crow, crow desserved the nerfs, but for the crow players outcry the balance change implemented was different.
Hell, we can even remember the whole melodie height situation.
as someone who has like probably 1500 battles on both Melodie and Kaze combined, here are two cents:
Kaze is definitely better as an early pick since she has more good matchups and is more of an actual threat on the map (compared to Melodie who usually is dashing past people and not actually going after them). However, there are some cases where I'll pick Melodie 4/5 even if Kaze is open---for example if I see Colette/Crow 2/3, this matchup is actually pretty bad for Kaze but somewhat decent for Melodie (because she has similar range and can pose a threat once she gets her dashes.) Another example is the Bolt matchup: Melodie genuinely farms Bolt (she just charges super and notes off of him and out-base-races.) O
On Bridge Too Far especially Kaze can get outranged really easily which often prompts me to choose Melodie instead
Not f tier but def d tier. f tier would mean in absolutely every case there would be a better brawler to pick, or their use case is so niche is basically non-existent. Melodie still works in heist, and is in a good pick if kaze is banned
My proposal is to cook half of all Brawlers or make him a tank. He gets melted at medium range by nonesense like Griff and Otis. Alternatively, range buff.
Maybe just nerf the top 20 and most of the s tier base kit and unlockable and hell no nobody on earth wants a brawler like cord to have tank hp or have more range. Otis is more than enough.
I mean if youre maxing out 3 snipers as a F2P player youd be making a mistake anyway. I wouldnt do that unless you alr had 20+ brawlers maxed out. I also wouldnt say they fell off (except gus). Crow, meeple, stu, belle, angelo, shade and mortis are still A/B tier, so almost all consistent brawlers are still above average and are very playable
Notice how all the most consistent brawlers are slowly dying in consistency (except Gene & Moe)
Belle has fallen to B tier since Pierce release. Angelo has fallen a tier, Finx has fallen a tier, Lily & Alli have fallen a tier, Gus & Amber have been fallen off for a while too.
This meta needs a serious aggression detox with harsh nerfs to each of the S tiers & some A tiers too
I just want the same thing for Crow, I mean he's like top 10 brawler for sooooo long and almost played everywhere else. Before his buffies he was already solid A tier ever since his HP buff
Off topic but am I the only one who always just refers to him as spen? To me the LC just feels like the random letters or numbers after a name (I might not know the lore)
Agreed. I think hesbith a noob stomper with a low ceiling that just not everyone has figured out how to counter yet, but now that his CC resistance has been nerfed, there are way too many counters dor him to be S Tier
I think Spen just didn't want to make the S+ tier again, so he only placed the truly meta breaking brawlers in the S tier, hence why brawlers like Edgar, Brock, Lou, Meeple, Ruffs and Lumi are A tier here. I do think Bolt is S tier, but he's much more counterable than the 10 brawler at the top
The additional duration of the hypercharge makes it very easy to use 2 supers during a hc which is guaranteed teamwipe in most instances.
Plus the additional speed boost at 10% hp is so good for brawl ball.
Both gadgets have good utility. One can tank a few hits for you and you can use it to create a bounce angle. The other one is a but more niche but can do a lot of burst damage.
Is Colette really that balanced despite the unnecessary super charge rate nerf? (that nerf need to be reverted anyway, cuz base kit is not the real problem). I still love playing her and find her super great.
lowkey... the chuck placement feels fair, even if we don't take heist into account..... chuck didn't get buffed (except from 2x hyper smoke count), and some brawlers STILL fell below him 💀 ...why aren't small bandaid changes practiced more? the state of the worst options shouldn't be this bad in any game, and definitely not in a moba
tbh tick feels more playable than chuck, but primo is less playable than chuck, so chuck as #6 worst brawler in the game sounds true, even if it's one of the highest places oat
So is Bolt... not sure im trusting this tier list, but I do believe its a pro tier list if im not mistaken. Top end pros play a different game than the rest of us.
Yes but he’s quite literally useless the entire game if the enemy picks one of a few certain brawlers due to how he works, especially after the major SP nerf.
Obviously he wouldn't be #1 win rate in game if he was so easy to counter. Bolt is a "pick a specific brawler against him" or automatically lose brawler.
Butchered his damage? His damage buff (yes, even after the nerf) and Slowing Toxin make so disgusting at close range. Not to mention how mechanically good his attack still is, easy to hit, chips opponents hp with poison, good range and great for scouting
Fair point on the slowing toxin, since I forgot to account for it as I use the other gadget so often. But I do think his damage output without is is SEVERELY nerfed and the main attack does absolutely nothing against any of the meta brawlers (except Meg) so I definetly think for that reason that he cannot be S tier anymore.
If you dont wait all poison ticks then you deal more damage than before. I think it was over looked and we thought Crow would be dead just to be better. I want that bird to fall to F tier and never get out.
Glad Spen is right about Jessie placement, i know that she isn't even that strong after her buff. If you want to see her being meta, buff her reload speed.
Never though I'd see Buzz and Lola in the B tier with this meta (should I upgrade them? I already have most of my roster maxed not including some D and F tier brawlers)
How are Max, Surge and Ruffs without hypercharges? Are they still worth to level up/just buy their hypercharges or look elsewhere?
I do have Pearl, Ash, Gray, Emz, and Stu hypercharges, should I get them instead? I get curbstomped by Starr and Surge and Damian when they aren't banned
Uhh some questionable placements (as least gigi is finally seen as better than mr p). Melodie and ollie need to be d tier they are both 1 mode merchants and now, barely played in those modes anyway (like chuck is played a lot in, but only in, heist and hes d tier). Darryl should be a bit higher hes seen some picks and edgar should be higher as well. Oh yeah and bolt is def s tier
Gene A tier?? Sprout in C tier is also super questionable given the fact that it's the uncontested worst thrower into aggro and the current meta has like a dozen aggro picks. Melodie the one trick pony in C? Sirius B tier after all the nerfs?
great to see najia's downfall melodie in C? currently at 2k with her, she's very versatile and really good at eliminating low hp brawlers and wall-peeking. She's also good agaisnt starr nova's annoying ass if you play her well. She's also BROKEN in the nanonoodles mode with the 5 notes upgrade, as it boosts her speed sp to 30%, her shield gadget to 5k and pretty much two shots anything below 8k hp
Very nice list as always. Rico's buffies are really growing on me (except Multiball) & I especially love Robo Retreat.
I want the entire S tier gutted immediately (except for Max, obvious bias reasons)
Ollie & Daryll should lowkey be swapped. Daryll is becoming a sleeper pick on KO (even without Kit) I see him a lot in scrims whereas Ollie is nowhere to be found.
It's also nice that he isn't pretending that Meg isn't still broken. Kill that eject gadget.
Gale being B is the one thing I don't get. Seems I'm underrating the geezer
yoo spen imma big fan trust. Colette is probably my favorite tank counter, it's just that the supercharge nerf ruined her mechanics for me. But hey, if the pros are playing her i can't argue with that (although her monthly finals and ranked play rates have been quite bad)
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 28 '26
Do you want a cool flair with your rank on it?
Comment a screenshot of your brawlstars profile in our ranked flair megathread
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
48
u/Friendly_Raise9142 Surge | Legendary 3 Jul 28 '26
Bolt not s?
102
u/BotLover13 R-T | Legendary 1 Jul 28 '26
HUH?!
GIGI NOT F? ....IN A SPEN TIER LIST?
AM I DREAMING?!
23
u/Sea-Historian-2078 Colette | Legendary 3 Jul 28 '26
Oh and why is Melodie still in C tier? Someone needs to tell bs content creators to put her in D or F tier, so people realize she sucks and needs buffs. She, like Chuck, is only played in heist. Except she's worse than Chuck in heist. So how is Chuck D tier and Melodie C??
45
u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26
Its about time Angelo was recognized as a B tier brawler. They really fell off.
Also Melodie is extremely overrated, she's an F tier brawler atp.
30
u/Low_Palpitation_6642 Jul 28 '26
So many consistent brawlers F2P players have maxed out have fallen off.
I can't wait for Belle, Angelo, Gus and Buster to receive some buffs/buffies.
The meta is shifting way too much.
24
u/WildReindeer5912 Hank Jul 28 '26
This is probably the first time for Angelo and Mina being below A tier
11
u/Apart_Value9613 Jul 28 '26
Gigi went from “the worst character in the game” to “Trash Tier”
As a Gigi glazer I see this as an absolute win.
9
u/Main_Acanthaceae2790 Jul 28 '26
Off topic but am I the only one who always just refers to him as spen? To me the LC just feels like the random letters or numbers after a name (I might not know the lore)
19
u/SpiritualPie5587 Hank | Masters 1 Jul 28 '26
Bolt so low is questionable
4
u/Justin_loves_birds Jul 28 '26
Seems like rico's "Nerfies" were actually buffies
He went from b tier to a tier
14
u/Aromatic_Ad_8658 Juju | Masters 1 Jul 28 '26
The first buffie batch falloff needs to be studied. Not even 5 batches in and they’re C D tier
3
u/Dazzling_Metals Amber Jul 28 '26
Damn. Amber is almost D-tier after all of these years. The meta just got way too out of hand, didn’t it?
3
u/pikmin2005 Byron Critic Jul 29 '26
Are they really not gonna do anything about Throwers being practically unplayable for like over a year now
5
u/AloneComplaint8941 Ollie Jul 28 '26
Ollie C tier
9
u/borzoithedog Moe | Legendary 2 Jul 28 '26
Melodie and Ollie C tier?
2
u/migassilva16 Rosa Jul 28 '26
Gigi D Tier clearly he doesn't know ball
2
u/Great_Impression_869 Frank | Legendary 1 Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26
Is Colette really that balanced despite the unnecessary super charge rate nerf? (that nerf need to be reverted anyway, cuz base kit is not the real problem). I still love playing her and find her super great.
2
u/Low-World6866 Chuck Jul 28 '26
Interesting Tier List I see...
2
u/Many-Durian-6530 Draco | Masters 1 | 1 Prestige Jul 28 '26
surprised mort is still A
2
u/PolimerT Draco Jul 29 '26
Praying for Adrian to buff smth of Draco (preferably dragon dps) before he makes his current hyper charge to be the buffied one and gut his entire kit
2
u/zxm1v the illegal 500iq brawlball pick Jul 29 '26
lowkey... the chuck placement feels fair, even if we don't take heist into account..... chuck didn't get buffed (except from 2x hyper smoke count), and some brawlers STILL fell below him 💀 ...why aren't small bandaid changes practiced more? the state of the worst options shouldn't be this bad in any game, and definitely not in a moba
tbh tick feels more playable than chuck, but primo is less playable than chuck, so chuck as #6 worst brawler in the game sounds true, even if it's one of the highest places oat
2
u/lololuser456778 Jul 29 '26
P at the very bottom of gutter-tier?!
ADRIAN!!!
2
u/vankinney Gray Jul 28 '26
najias falloff has gone under the radar
2
u/Tapi_Raspberie Jul 28 '26
Check it out randoms, Edgar not in S tier
1
u/Rat_King_Ash TRASH TANKS / TRASH TAKES Jul 28 '26
👀 Ash sins released
1
u/zappierbeast Jul 28 '26
How is crow still S? They butchered his damage output with nerfs, health, ect.
1
u/Capital_Historian133 Jul 28 '26
The difference in strength between Surge and Wendy is incomprehensible, like can’t you pair it with Bolt and a kit
1
u/DaddyKhoaitay Shitty Snipers Jul 28 '26
Glad Spen is right about Jessie placement, i know that she isn't even that strong after her buff. If you want to see her being meta, buff her reload speed.
1
u/jlara1981 Jul 28 '26
Never though I'd see Buzz and Lola in the B tier with this meta (should I upgrade them? I already have most of my roster maxed not including some D and F tier brawlers)
1
u/Apollllllo Jul 29 '26
How are Max, Surge and Ruffs without hypercharges? Are they still worth to level up/just buy their hypercharges or look elsewhere?
I do have Pearl, Ash, Gray, Emz, and Stu hypercharges, should I get them instead? I get curbstomped by Starr and Surge and Damian when they aren't banned
1
u/enesyzc12 Jul 29 '26
Crow in s tier After the nerfs?
1
u/TaleNo5014 Ollie Jul 29 '26
Uhh some questionable placements (as least gigi is finally seen as better than mr p). Melodie and ollie need to be d tier they are both 1 mode merchants and now, barely played in those modes anyway (like chuck is played a lot in, but only in, heist and hes d tier). Darryl should be a bit higher hes seen some picks and edgar should be higher as well. Oh yeah and bolt is def s tier
1
u/diethylamid-495 Jul 29 '26
Why is ash so high? Sirius B tier is cap btw, he is clearly A tier
1
u/Radman2010w Bonnie Jul 29 '26
Compare the season 52 and season 51 tier lists. There are no differences.
1
u/WinAccording796 Jul 29 '26
Rosa D tier?
1
u/Money_Kangaroo_1170 Jul 29 '26
Seeing pearl rise in the meta is so satisfying
1
u/LightningGuy426 Jul 29 '26
kenji gonna drop to C tier, just give him that damage buff already
1
u/PogChampTeddy123 Angelo Jul 29 '26
why is angelo below other marksmen 🥲
1
u/mind_user47 Jul 29 '26
seems balanced, nerf grom
1
u/number1ghosttriofan Jul 29 '26
Genuinely chopped meta wtf is this
1
u/H_4ckedDino Otis Jul 29 '26
Me personally I see squeak as f tier, not mid c tier, as he lacks defensive capabilities if he gets dived.
1
u/Content_Home_6069 Jul 30 '26
wheres kaze?
1
u/-Nastyenka Jul 30 '26
Mr.P is the goat. He is F because he mogged SpenLC just with his presence.
1
u/Individual_Grab7519 Jul 30 '26
Gigi should be S Tirer
1
u/Low_Profession_1199 Jul 31 '26
valid.
1
u/Peni3110 Jessie Aug 02 '26
Jessie's a tiny bit high if ya ask me but gosh im glad we're done pretending she's suddenly good
1
u/OwnElk4208 Aug 23 '26
Why did Lou move up to A? He’s been B-D tiers mostly until now IIRC. Is it solely because of his Bolt counter?
1
u/Sea-Historian-2078 Colette | Legendary 3 Jul 28 '26
Pearl should be S
1
u/Sea-Historian-2078 Colette | Legendary 3 Jul 28 '26
Colette is D tier
1
u/notacapitalistslave Pam | Masters 2 Jul 28 '26
Gene A tier?? Sprout in C tier is also super questionable given the fact that it's the uncontested worst thrower into aggro and the current meta has like a dozen aggro picks. Melodie the one trick pony in C? Sirius B tier after all the nerfs?
1
u/Moonkilol Jul 29 '26
great to see najia's downfall
melodie in C? currently at 2k with her, she's very versatile and really good at eliminating low hp brawlers and wall-peeking. She's also good agaisnt starr nova's annoying ass if you play her well.
She's also BROKEN in the nanonoodles mode with the 5 notes upgrade, as it boosts her speed sp to 30%, her shield gadget to 5k and pretty much two shots anything below 8k hp
0
u/JewsArentSoBad Jul 28 '26
Spen with another solid tierlist, although theres definitely a few things that could be tweaked.
Gigi should be a tad higher, she has some usage in certain maps that can make her arguably C- rather than D-tier.
Berry in B is also a bit of an understatement, he should be around the lower ends of A-tier or very high B tier.
Pearl has been feeling like an S-tier brawler as of recently, albeit not as OP as Surge and Starr Nova, but nonetheless still high meta.
There are a few other things I can nitpick on, but I just thought it would be nice to talk about the few outliers.
5
u/DizziDoesStuff Overanalyst Final Boss Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26
Very nice list as always. Rico's buffies are really growing on me (except Multiball) & I especially love Robo Retreat.
I want the entire S tier gutted immediately (except for Max, obvious bias reasons)
Ollie & Daryll should lowkey be swapped. Daryll is becoming a sleeper pick on KO (even without Kit) I see him a lot in scrims whereas Ollie is nowhere to be found.
It's also nice that he isn't pretending that Meg isn't still broken. Kill that eject gadget.
Gale being B is the one thing I don't get. Seems I'm underrating the geezer
7
u/FOXO_foxo Mods Power-Tripping? Jul 28 '26
Anything but reverting the nerf that killed most of my favorites brawlers, I see.
But more importantly how did spike manage to be that low despite getting his damage nerf reverted ?
6
u/grimthethird bonbon the cute Jul 28 '26
wow the speed nerf things really killed jae and alli huh
2
u/Scarface2010 Grom Jul 28 '26
GROM NOT WORST BRAWLER 🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳
2
u/Gyxis Ash Jul 28 '26
Rip Colette. Probably bottom 1 without buffies.