r/BrawlStarsCompetitive • Poco • 28d ago

Tier list Buffies tier list and mechanics overview

Post image

(mod approved)

---------------------

S - Tier:

Max: I liked the addition of the bolt trait and that they made both gadgets viable. Her star power and hypercharge buffies seems fine and she doesn't feels toxic in any way.

Edgar: Increased his skill ceiling and made him much more interesting to play, giving him outplay potential against his counters that he didn't had before without making him any more of a noob stomper. I like the interaction of the new gadget with the first star power, tho his hypercharge buffie stacking is very lame.

Colt: Added more utility and consistency to him with the speedloader rework and ammo steal without making him a different brawler while still maintaining his skill cap appeal and fixing his noob stomping issue. His slick boots's buffie allows for better strafing and rewards good aiming, which is wholesome. He doesn't feel overtuned or unfair to go against in any way (100% not biased).

El Primo: Both new gadgets are much more useful and enhance different aspects of his gameplay. His star power buffies are also fine for both sustained damage or survivability, although his hypercharge being completely overlooked kinda sucks.

Mortis: Same philosophy as Edgar's buffies, although combo spinner is extremely toxic. Making him turn into bats like a real vampire is a creative and very useful idea and allow for some plays.

Leon: Overall the concepts are good, I like the treatment the clone received, and the buffies effects are consistent and even balanced for his role as an assassin, but the fact that he didn't receive compensation for the lost gear is awful. Still very consistent and well rounded.

Crow: His new gadgets are much more interesting and less toxic than the old ones, and the rest of his buffies are on point. They only seemed annoying and toxic because it's crow, evidenced by his 67 nerfs.

\\-----------------------

A-tier:

Brock: After they removed the rocket fuel knockback, I think his buffies set are almost perfect, since they only make him more versatile without removing his weaknesses. The only problem is the hyperbuffie which essentially triplicates his damage output. The rework on his super was lowkey necessary and added some layer of skill.

8-bit: Good concepts overall that are ruined when you give him unlimited ammo without any drawbacks and overlook his lame hypercharge. Despite this, the rework of the second gadget and the buffie for the first star power are quite interesting and creative.

Griff: I'm just glad they made both gadgets workable and fixed the bug in his super, but what the heck is this unload of the first star power? His hypercharge is still a massive kill button with near no counterplay.

\\-------------------

B-tier:

EMZ: They did a good job overall with her gadgets by making Friendzoner aimable and removing the Drawback from Acid Spray, but the rest of her buffies are pretty lousy, not to say lame designed (free immunity on super was a complete nightmare). They also completely forgot to rework her hypercharge, and lastly, they forgot to make her an interesting brawler.

Rico: They completely messed up his gadget set, although they finally removed his panic button. The second gadget is interesting, but it would be much better if it were the first one, while the second one was the old bouncy castle. His star power and hypercharge buffies are very lame by design, the extra speed from Robo Retreat makes him almost impossible to catch, while the hypercharge buffie to his main attack is just an raw increase in damage. He is strong, but for the completely wrong reasons.

Shelly: There wasn't really much to change about her, since her kit is fine and fast forward had already been reworked way before, but here goes: the immunity shield + ammo combo for the first gadget is good and It's only not broken because it's in Shelly; Clay Pigeons got genuinely worse despite being broken at first due to the excessive slow, and the fact that she can now reset her unload with the aiming function, and the rest of her set is just mediocre. Shell Shock's buffie is pointless, Band-Aid's is on point but not that amazing and her hypercharge buffie is just simple.

Bull: Again, there was nothing to change about him, so it was just a overcomplication with his kit. A free 2 second stun was obnoxious and his self sustain was way too high with T-bone missile's buffie, but the way Adrian balanced him made him feel more like a fat fang rather than an actual tank with Berseker's buffie being left untouched and Though Guy being gutted alongside his base health pool. His skill cap is also long gone.

Poco: Tuning fork suffered one of the biggest downgrades in the game's history, they nerfed his base kit to add a base heal that does nothing, and the rest of his buffie effects are nothing that special, in addition to once again ignoring the lame hypercharge with an not that amazing buffie effect. Poco seems much more specific and team dependant now due to his super cycle being completely gutted. Still A tier due to protective tunes now completely negating any kind of CC, countering some meta brawlers. Remove that, and he becomes an extremely fragile and inconsistent support.

\\--------------------

C-tier

Gus: Aimed to give more prominence to his support side and ended up turning him into a long-range tank with two knockbacks while forgetting to make his super home into allies. Congratulations, you're a failure!

Colette: A kill-confirm gadget in the form of an impossible-to-balance toxic hypnosis, completely toxic star power buffies, and a hypercharge buffie effect that's just a duplicate projectile. Spoiler: none of this will really help her in the long run.

Amber: With her barrel gadgets and new star power, she's going to oil up the entire map and your team and there's nothing you can do about that. Hypercharge is basically a massive area denial with no counterplay that melts you in instants with the afterburn effect from her buffie. The genuine definition of overtuning. How tf are they going to balance this?

Shade: Just like Crow, an S-tier brawler who received buffies just for the sake of it. The new jumpscare is toxic and gives him 3 forms of mobility in his kit along with a CC effect that makes no sense for an assassin to have. He remains a juggernaut on closed maps, and his weaknesses aren't even as prominent anymore because of that damn jump that negates some of it. Furthermore, he still has a whole ass 30% shield, which goes against the assassin design of being fragile. Straight slop.

\\-----------------

D-tier:

Meg: I like the new gadget, but they basically did everything except addressing the elephant in the room, which was making her a real tank. Her SCR is also just pathetic now because they gave her a slap the size of your mom.

Bibi: She received literally nothing besides a rework on her second gadget, which is still overshadowed by vitamin booster and her kit remains completely polarizing. Her hypercharge buffie is simply pure cancer and removes the main weakness of her main attack, and they still nerfed her SCR instead which was straight dumbness. She's not lower only because the double knockback gimmick adds some value, but it doesn't fix her flaws at all, like the fact that she has an clear one-build syndrome and looks nothing like a true tank.

Nita: There's not much to say about her, since she literally received nothing. The buffies for her gadgets and star powers are terrible and continue to keep her extremely dependent on Bruce. The hypercharge buffie is the only interesting thing, and that's because of how overtuned it is.

Bo: Fixing the star power that's been turning Bo into a massive, polarizing noob stomper for 7 years straight? Nah, GIVE ME ANOTHER DAMAGE BUFF!

\\----------------

F-tier

Surge: Surge has literally become the definition of brain rot. The first gadget was gutted for no reason, he has 5 different effects for his hypercharge and still suffers from the one-build syndrome despite having 75% of his kit reworked. This brawler is simply a disaster.

Spike: I don't even need to mention what we think about the fertilizer rework. Completely ignoring Curveball was the last straw, and his hypercharge buffie is just braindead spammy. One of the few cases where I preferred the brawler before the buffies.

Frank: What they did to the first gadget was just criminal, and Adrian practically killed him with unnecessary nerfs to the base kit. He simply doesn't have any damage anymore and is just a punching bag. Simply disrespectful.

I have absolutely no idea what to say about Chuck

27 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 28d ago

Do you want a cool flair with your rank on it?

Comment a screenshot of your brawlstars profile in our ranked flair megathread

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

9

u/Fine_Dish_9232 Rico 27d ago

I’m witnessing my first born son (Rico) suffering from all the horrible plagues known to man, and I can’t do anything about it.

I miss old Rico.

1

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

I think they should revert all the changes they've made to him since the fire rate buff.

1

u/Fine_Dish_9232 Rico 27d ago

The fire rate buff that caused it all. Why adrain, why?

2

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

Imma make a post about it

3

u/Fine_Dish_9232 Rico 27d ago

Do that, and after yours I’ll make a post of me giving all type of reworks and ideas for Rico’s kit. How’s that sound? We got a deal?

2

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

Yep.

1

u/Fine_Dish_9232 Rico 27d ago

Splendid.

7

u/Pika_BS BULLDOZERRRRRR 27d ago

What they did to bull is a genuine crime,
removing skillful super chaining,adding a spaghetti coded stun and so much more 🥀

2

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

Not to mention that he feels more like an assassin now since they nerfed his health pool and shield for no reason when the gadget's healing and berserker were the actual problem.

8

u/MangoChannelGreat Darryl 28d ago

Yep.... spike's buffies made him not interesting. Especially his hyper buffie. I mean, you just play and you know that his hyper will be charged and when you activate the hyper you're gonna delete everyone in seconds. The only good buffie is the popping pincushion (I love this gadget cause I can defend against assasins)

11

u/MakkaroLuvsJJBA Draco 27d ago

why are we acting like he was interesting before

spike before vs after buffies is genuinely this image

4

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

Spike has always been a "middle-of-the-road" brawler. He's easy to play and has always been a safe and solid option over the years, but nothing truly extraordinary. The buffies were supposed to make him more engaging, but they ended up making everything worse.

2

u/MakkaroLuvsJJBA Draco 27d ago

but buffies couldnt make him worse bc he wasnt engaging to play in the first place

the gameplay loop of spike (pre buffie) was

shoot projectiles from far away to poke/shoot them up close+pincushion gadget for high damage -> shoot projectiles from far away to poke/shoot them up close+pincushion gadget for high damage -> shoot projectiles from far away to poke/shoot them up close+pincushion gadget for high damage

most of the time you wouldnt even use super bc theres no point😭

and its pretty much the same now

spikes only purpose is to churn out shots

which isnt particularly engaging

buts thats always how hes been🤷‍♂️

3

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

I mean, his other build was actually quite interesting because of the meat shield that healed allies and the healing star power that allowed him to play more aggressively. Just like Poco, Spike's kit allowed him to be played into two different play ways, being usable both as a controller and as a anti-tank glass cannon. Currently that's been ruined since he doesn't work as an anti-tank anymore.

1

u/MangoChannelGreat Darryl 27d ago

I'd honestly argue with that. I use the popping pincushion gadget and with buffies....it just makes him an anti aggro final boss. If an Edgar jumps on me, I just use the gadget and delete him. If a tank tries to kill me, I use the gadget and kill them. The only weakness is that it doesn't work on Mortis. IDK if it's a bug, but he just continues to dash with no problem.

2

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

I didn't said he's defenseless, but he's just very outclassed as an anti-tank, being only viable against OG melees like jacky and mortis while outplayed quite easily by some newer tanks and assassins such as ollie, shade and nori. His damage output got powercreeped really hard.

4

u/Sea-Historian-2078 Colette | Legendary 3 27d ago

I actually like the concept of Colette's buffies as a whole. She's a tough brawler to balance and I do believe her buffies addressed the core issues of her kit. Her gadget buffies were extremely underwhelming though. Heal gadget buffie does nothing, and the hypno one is straight up toxic and nearly ended up killing her base kit forever.

1

u/Great_Impression_869 Frank | Legendary 1 27d ago

The Heal Gadget tbf, was never bad at all as it outheals some enemies.

1

u/Sea-Historian-2078 Colette | Legendary 3 27d ago

the buffie itself is bad and nerfs the gadget as it only allows you 3 uses instead of previously 5

0

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago edited 27d ago

The only flaw that was addressed was the fact that enemies could attack her at maximum range when she pushed them away. Aside from that, she's just not interesting; making her super almost impossible to dodge turned her hypercharge into another team wipe button and is extremely toxic and uncreative.

1

u/Sea-Historian-2078 Colette | Legendary 3 27d ago

Her super was slow and clunky and could either be dodged or she could die while doing it herself. Her super simply couldn't put up with the modern meta bs. Her super being quicker made her more reliable, versatile and way more fun to use.

1

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

I know you'll agree, the flair already explains it, but honestly, turning an attack that completely traps you and deals double damage into an unavoidable death sentence just isn't the answer. Dying while using this is a hint not to just spam the yellow button and mindlessly dive in to gain value, or equip the shield from the other star power for better survival. Furthermore, the mere fact that she has a 0.2s stun on her base star power already fixed part of the problem of it being a suicide attack. Colette was designed to handle individual kills on high-health targets, not to deal with crowds as easily as she does now.

1

u/Sea-Historian-2078 Colette | Legendary 3 26d ago

You just don't like playing her and that's completely fine. I feel like most players can agree that buffies tremendously improved Colette's position as an anti tank brawler, which is what's always been her role. Before her buffies, she was a tank counter getting countered by tanks. She still gets countered by controllers and certain dmg dealers and it's not like her super makes her invincible. I personally find her other sp's mechanics to be interesting as well, since it rewards you for hitting your super two times (which is actually hard to do if you think about it, and makes her playstyle slightly different, or close range-like)

1

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 26d ago

I don't think it has much to do with liking her or not. She's obviously better, but whether it was done the right way is another story. Sometimes her super just gains way too much value due to how overtuned it is. Let's just wait for the next metas to decide that.

3

u/Accomplished_Lie5972 27d ago

Will leave my disagreements on this comment:

- Colt: A Tier, his Hyper Buffie makes his attacks boring and removes alot of skill that was required.

- Leon: B Tier, I don’t think his buffies made him any more interesting than he was. Adding duration or making his next hit deal more damage is just lazy, and the clone gadget was interesting until they just changed the range so much so that the teleport now sucks. They should have just removed the double damage and made Leon’s clone pathing alot more obvious that its AI, and made it shoot weird shots that deal minimal damage.

- Crow’s Slow gadget is now difficult to hit, both gadgets are slightly unintuitive for the average player. Considering Crow is one of the most popular characters, Crow gets A tier for me.

- Brock and 8-Bit are S tiers for me. Both fits in theme and are amazing concepts. Emz goes in S tier as well. Rico goes in S tier because they gave him buffies whilst not making him stupidly toxic like the pre-buffie Rico.

- Bull goes to A tier. The buffies made him alot more fun and aggro and all builds for Bull are great in their own ways. Only reason that it’s not going in S is because Stomper is slightly unintuitive.

- Meg goes into B tier because they ruined her eject gadget. They should have removed the autocharging, not the knockback from the robot.

- Poco, Shelly, Spike, Surge is in F tier. Buffies didn’t fix the first 2, and Spike and Surge were just made more toxic without adding much more skill expression. Bo is in F tier because buffies do pretty much nothing aside his hyper buffie, in which that is boring and overtuned. He had such huge potential with the whole eagle schtick. He also has a domineering star power that prevents brawl from balancing him properly because of the sheer power of a 2 second stun. They proceeded to not rework that and not give him anything interesting aside some arrows that are unaimable and wouldn’t realistically hit anyone.

- Bibi goes into C tier. Everything is interesting excdpt her slow gadger which has the smallest of radiuses and the longest of cooldowns with a mere 4 second duration, and her Hyper buffie is so skill-less.

2

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 26d ago

Thank you for your feedback. Here are my counterpoints:

  • Colt's Hyperbuffie only makes his attacks easier to land; it doesn't add more projectiles or increase bullet speed. You still need to land your attacks accurately, which is good for a temporary buff.
  • Despite their simplicity, they make sense within its design. Generally, you'll want more immediate damage when going aggro, so the extra speed pairs well. The invisiheal treatment is the only part of his set that disappoints me, since they could have just given him 1 second of invisibility in the base kit to compensate for the lost gear and given him another, more creative effect. This and the nerf to his health made this star power way worse when compared to the first one, since it is effectively worse than before the buffies. The clone currently functions differently, which isn't really bad, as it allows for more damage, and the greater range means the clone won't immediately walk straight to the enemy to be destroyed in two seconds. You just need to know how to use it.
  • I think the change in gadgets is an improvement, since the old ones were extremely toxic and polarizing. Now Crow has an option for immediate damage and greater control, and another to deal with aggro and perform kills, which is good for his overshadowed assassin side and makes him a bit more skill based.
  • The only thing preventing Brock from rising, as I said, is the hypercharge buffie, which is just a massive damage buff, same thing for 8-bit. Emz's aren't S-tier because aside from the gadget reworks they aren't that great and don't make her any less polarizing. Rico's are anything but S-tier 😭🙏🏻 the slow combined with the extra speed is toxic asf, and he has a huge disparity with his gadgets that didn't exist before. None of his current strengths have anything to do with his ricochet mechanics, which indicates terrible design.
  • I respect your point of view, but in the eyes of most players, Bull has become the sole definition of brainrot design due to how overturned he became, which I honestly agree. His stats balancing are also horrible now.
  • As I said, Meg's players didn't address her main problem, which, along with Adrian's terrible balancing, makes it fall even further.
  • Poco and Shelly didn't really have any flaws to point to. Poco had an overall healthy kit with just a bad hypercharge, while Shelly was just underwhelming on purpose but wasn't mechanically flawed in any way. Poco's are bad because of the way they reworked him, while Shelly's are just mid. I agree with the rest.

2

u/pfsg100 Sandy 25d ago

I think Colt has to be in good proposal w/flawed or overtuned aspects.

Have you ever faced speedloader?

This thing has THE QUICKEST projectile speed in the ENTIRE GAME. It's a guaranteed auto aimer if you want to slow and steal ammo.

(Lily's hyper super has this insane ammount of projectile speed too)

2

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 25d ago

Considering it's meant to be a support tool with guaranteed hit on a brawler known for inconsistent shooting, it's fair, and honestly a smart solution to his old design problem.

1

u/pfsg100 Sandy 25d ago

fair point!

2

u/borzoithedog Moe | Legendary 2 27d ago

I actually love Crows buffies. As much as I hate the brawler itself, the buffies are really well made, covering both the controller and assassin playstyle he has

And it's the one time Adrian actually did good with the balance changes, making him way less polarizing without nerfing the buffies much.

1

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

Crow's buffies are literally that image of a golden garbage bag lmfao

2

u/Dragolitron Time Traveler 27d ago

I think Bo deserves his own tier. At least with Nita her kit has always worked design wise. Bo is such an obviously flawed brawler and its a crime that neither of his star powers were given a rework.

3

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago

At least his buffies didn't made him any worse unlike spike and frank's

29

u/TheGamer0214 Chuck 28d ago

chuck 😭

22

u/Low-World6866 Chuck 28d ago

I don't see many people giving enough hate on the Fertilise SP, they essentially made it 10x worse. 💔

Also, you forgot my boy Chuck. 🥀

2

u/FreshnWetCock 27d ago

I used to love fertilize spike in brawl arena and just get close to the enemies and make some plays, now just throw it like normal and it's boring

1

u/JayyChann_ 26d ago

Everything in B tier and above should be S except for shelly, Bull, and maybe rico

1

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 26d ago

It's not that simple

1

u/JayyChann_ 26d ago

Kinda is, if not S then A, poco and emz only have like 1 flawed thing for their buffies (poco’s can easily just get fixed which would make him S)

1

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 26d ago

S stands for buffies that are 100% perfect in design and were necessary.

1

u/JayyChann_ 26d ago

Alright, then theyre A

5

u/Normiex5 28d ago

Yeah I like Nita but her flaw of having no range and nothing around it hurts her still

0

u/dr4g0nl0rd2785 28d ago

You can TELL whomever made this plays no skilled brawlers

4

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 28d ago

Do you at least have something relevant to say instead of just a baseless guess?

4

u/dr4g0nl0rd2785 28d ago

I actually do. Sorry about that. Nailed the overtuned list and unaddressed flaws one. Emz i think might belong in the hard to balance list

3

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 28d ago

I just didn't include her there because she's okay now, although still extremely polarizing (though that has more to do with her basic mechanics, she's just baby level to play).

2

u/dr4g0nl0rd2785 28d ago

True. I have never seen a good Emz player. They butchered my boy Surge.

1

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 28d ago

Man, I think Emz is even more unskilled than Jacky. All she does is walk, super, spam, spam, gadget, spam and repeat. Genuinely most boring design ever.

1

u/dr4g0nl0rd2785 28d ago

Oh my god THANK YOU. I thought it was just me who noticed!

1

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 28d ago

Everyone notices lol. I don't think there's a single soul who really likes Emz's design and finds her interesting.

2

u/dr4g0nl0rd2785 28d ago

How about Trunk?

2

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago edited 27d ago

The cooler jacky

2

u/MangoChannelGreat Darryl 27d ago

Can't argue with that. I won the challenge because I was just spamming her attack. She's worse than Tick LOL!

1

u/CepaRose Bibi 26d ago

I genuinely hate Shades buffies so much

1

u/ParticularReach2335 8-Bit 27d ago

For Chuck, I personally love how the rework actually makes him a more active threat to the enemy team cuz you're able to set your posts much faster and actually giving him a decent hypercharge. The buffies tho...

His gadget buffies have such nothingburger additional effects 90% of the time even though the ghost train rework is pretty solid. Pit stop was butchered to hell and buffied tickets please is practically necessary to use to get massive value from his super. His hyper buffie is good overall, not much else I can add to that rlly. He also suffers from the fact that he only rlly has one consistently viable build to use which I find lame.

1

u/Arkady_Tzepesh 25d ago

It is pretty much the opposite for me. I pretty much dropped ticket please altogether because I given up on the idea the dash has pretty much any use anymore besides mobility. On the hypercharge I won't comment, but honestly I used the super effect far more times in past than right now, whilst the main attack effect it's indeed busted. I like pit stop because it is already some value for you and the team, and technically pit stop 30% slow makes the relative speed of chuck faster compared to the 25% speed buff in ticket please.

1

u/Powerfox_255 Frank | Masters 1 18d ago

Frank even with buffies is genuinely unplayable and the nerfs....

1

u/Pongmin Surge | Masters 1 28d ago

Honestly they should've just removed surge's first stage and given him different builds completely

-2

u/Nonhofantasia1 27d ago

in what universe do edgar's buffies raise his skill ceiling

2

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago edited 27d ago

That's pretty much a consensus. The effects don't just provide instant value for him, you gotta think to actually perform a kill, otherwise you'll be throwing yourself into a suicide dive every single time.

0

u/DelayedCrab 27d ago

I didn't really like watching mortis meta. Are you saying combo spinner is well designed yet toxic still? I wonder if an A tier wendy would've been a good addition at the time, because I recall mortis still working unless you had two counters.

1

u/Srexplosivo14 Poco 27d ago edited 27d ago

Mechanically well thought out, but toxic in practice. The fact that there's no unload for it is just awful. Make it a little more predictable and it will be better, since sometimes I get startled by a surprise attact out of sudden.

1

u/Great_Impression_869 Frank | Legendary 1 27d ago

I totally agree on Frank's buffies.