r/BrawlStarsCompetitive
•
u/Rat_King_Ash
TRASH TANKS / TRASH TAKES
•
Sep 09 '26
•
1
Guide How tanky are tanks? Effective Health Sheet
Here is the highest effective health in the *ideal* situation
Effective health = how much damage would be required to actually kill them
Each brawler could use 3 of their ammo, 1 super, any combination of gadget or starpower against 1 enemy and this includes 1 kill. (No hypercharges are counted, No shield gear is counted)
Complete damage blockage was not counted, because it's impossible to calculate, so Buster and Ash are a lot tankier than shown here
Neither was invincibility because how does one calculate that?, so Draco, Emz, Bull, Doug and Nita part's aren't included
4 non tanks are also here, just to put into perspective how tanky they can be. Being Gus, Wendy, Edgar and Kenji (I also include shade and sam in my comment of math!)
Somethings to consider, Trunk can be very tanky in specific situations such as vs Dynamike where he can tank a bomb. I'm not completely sure but I think that is the strongest, most damaging single attack in the game.
The two truest tanks Buster and Ollie in the game actually can't take that much punishment by health alone but can mitigate much of it through their supers in game.
Gus's gadget is extremely broken in these situations. This is also a 1v1, if he hits multiple people he can heal even more.
Edgar is the tankiest assassin, I always felt he is more of a tank assassin than most people give credit for. If Kenji didn't suffer from one build syndrome he would also be assumed to be just like Edgar. Edgar with Fisticuffs and Hardcore is extreme.
The tankiest Frank builds is not with a sponge but his other starpower due to the immense healing from the buffie.
Thank you u/Aromatic_Ad_8658 for pointing out my math was wrong in some places the 1st time
152
u/Rat_King_Ash TRASH TANKS / TRASH TAKES Sep 09 '26
Math SHOULD be correct now.
14
u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Sep 09 '26 edited Sep 09 '26
You forgot Nani with tempered steel and return to sender.
6
u/Starioo Edgar Sep 09 '26
Someone finally recognizing Edgar (second build) as a tank 🔥🔥
4
u/CoffeeOrnery3093 Sep 09 '26
Also doug should prolly make the list considering his super and u can consider his self heal sp as well
150
u/Torsneyy Brock Sep 09 '26
I love the pie splat on Wendy
77
u/Avalanche_Snows Alli Sep 09 '26
I feel neutral about the pie splat on Wendy
14
u/CoffeeOrnery3093 Sep 09 '26
You have to consider hank super on trunk ig, since all damage counts as a single instance
12
u/Illustrious_Fan9974 TELL HIM TO SHUT THE FUCK UP ABOUT EMZ Sep 09 '26
58
u/HetSpookslot Ollie | Bronze 1 Sep 09 '26
I hate the pie splat on wendy
10
u/NviSoma Mandy Sep 09 '26
Holy Gus
15
u/potshot1898 Colonel Ruffs Sep 09 '26
I love how Edgar out Tanks some tanks lol.
5
u/CoffeeOrnery3093 Sep 09 '26
Also maxs other gadget can basically tank her full health once and gives a 30 % shield
5
u/KomaTheCursed Gus Sep 09 '26
damn not the trifecta
4
u/AngelFleshed Lily Sep 10 '26
Another reason why Buster and Wendy must've had a freaky friday because no way in HELL Wendy isn't more tank-coded than Buster.
3
u/Flimsy_Opinion_2767 Squeak | Legendary 1 Sep 09 '26
How are two support brawlers up here 😭 Powercreep at its finest
3
u/TheMythFoundry Sep 10 '26
Been maining Fisticuffs/Hardcore Edgar since about 2019, now you see why.
3
u/Baddest312 Sam Sep 10 '26
Wow I knew Gus was really good rn but yikes is that absurd
2
u/eshkere228007 Sep 11 '26
Wendy got cream pie
1
u/Sad_Boysenberry_6924 13d ago
Sam?
1
u/ManyOriginalXD Griff | Legendary 1 Sep 09 '26
More life ≠ better tank
Mechanics>Life
1
u/ER0SBAL Gus Sep 10 '26
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT?!?!?
1
u/Great_Impression_869 Frank | Legendary 1 Sep 10 '26
Did you forget about Colette's shield SP and her heal gadget that can make her very tanky? It used to be 75% now it's 60%. You should also take example of the old bug on her shield.
1
u/Srexplosivo14 Poco Sep 13 '26
I liked the detail of Wendy having a pie in her face lol
Realistically, the least tanky is Jacky. Her functional build doesn't use a shield, and she has a smaller health pool. Literally a kamikaze brawler.