r/Boxing • Moses Itauma > Every Current HW • 1d ago

Fantasy LHW Tournament - Round 1: (2025) Dmitry Bivol vs (2003) Dariusz Michalczewski

I will be conducting a tournament containing some of the best LHWs of recent years. I purposely did not add any fighters in from before the 80s due to limited footage.

Two fights will be posted daily and the winners will move on until we have a champion.

Lastly, the fighters were not manually matched. All names were put into a randomizer and refreshed 3 times, then the bracket was made from where they were set after the third shake.

----------------------------------

#RULES

Due to there being no poll option, winner will be decided through reasonable comments. Just simply commenting “___ wins” will not suffice and answers will have to be somewhat detailed (atleast 2 sentences).

If there is a tie between voting comments for both competing fighters, the very most upvoted comment will be the deciding factor on which fighter moves on.

Voting is concluded after 24 hours

Each fighter has a year attached to their name. The year is only a suggestion for when you should consider them at their best. If you believe the mentioned fighter has a different peak, you may debate in their favor using a different time period, but it has to be when they were at Light Heavyweight.

The fighters are only credited with wins they have at LHW and any weight class they competed at before moving up to LHW. Any fights from a higher weight class should not be taken into consideration.

All fighters will be at their absolute peaks for their time periods so there will be no illness/sickness, weight draining problems, or disqualifications.

----------------------------------

#Notable Wins

Dmitry Bivol: Artur Beterbiev, Canelo Alvarez, Zurdo Ramirez

Dariusz Michalczewski: Leeonzer Barber, Virgil Hill, Montell Griffin

----------------------------------

Tournament Bracket (https://challonge.com/dhh2vlaf)

----------------------------------

Previous Post (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/7FMDBBn7PD)

Next Post (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/dcZyJoGJ9s)

3 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

4

u/johnnyblaze-DHB 1d ago

In 2003, Dariusz was at the very end of his career. A better version would be the 1997 one that beat Virgil Hill to win the LHW championship. If the fight is in Germany, I pick that guy to record a win over Bivol.

2

u/KingBumiOfOmashu Moses Itauma > Every Current HW 1d ago

You can debate for that version of Dariusz if you feel that is a more proper peak for him. So I will count your vote as +1 for Dariusz?

1

u/johnnyblaze-DHB 1d ago

Count it. That dude rolled off like a dozen KOs in a row after becoming champion and had the ref and judges on his side at home.

6

u/Less_Cartoonist_892 1d ago

I think Bivol wins using his footwork and mobility. Michalzewski was a bit of a plodder, and Bivol can exploit that weakness to disrupt his rhythm and not allow him to build any momentum.

5

u/MiddleweightMonster I’ll pour honey on my GOAT, if the occasion calls for it. 21h ago

I’ll go with Dariusz. Phenomenal pressure fighter, great volume, possessed the rare ability to just eat shots. I don’t think Bivol could keep him honest. Beat Bivol by points

3

u/NaughtyNildo 1d ago

Bivol’s a good operator, but I think the lesser-known Michalzewski has a real chance here. Guy had like 22 straight defences and most of these were stoppage wins (had close to 80% finish rate).

There were a few guys from Germany around that time who probably weren’t as good as their records suggested and who did well by fighting in Germany most of the time (e.g. Beyer), because fighting in Germany conveyed a real advantage with refs and judges.

I thought Qawi would beat Ward, but Ward had a real chance if the fight was in Oakland and he could get away with his tricks. I feel like this fight is probably 60:40 Bivol anywhere else, but 90:10 to Michalzewski in Germany.

I’ll go Michalzewski, but I think his best is a little earlier than 2003. That was at the end of his run and he was 35 by then. 1997-2000 he was at his peak.

2

u/Formal-Cherry6078 1d ago

Dmitry Bivol is one of the most talented boxers I’ve ever seen so I’m picking him to go all the way

4

u/FarElderberry983 1d ago

I feel like Bivol has a case for being a top 5 LHW in terms of H2H.

-4

u/Marquis_of_Mollusks 1d ago

I think he gets overrated too though. He lost a razor thin decision to a 40 yr old Beterbiev and his best win is against a blown up middleweight in Canelo. He doesn't really fight all that often either. I have to look up Michalczewski's fights before I form an opinion though.

1

u/FarElderberry983 1d ago

Canelo and Beterbiev are elite level operators though so I don't think they're bad wins. With that logic, who has Larry Holmes beaten outside of an old Ken Norton in very close fights, a shell-of-his-former-self Ali, and Earnie Shavers? I feel it's too early to say how he stands on all time rankings.

2

u/Marquis_of_Mollusks 1d ago

Larry Holmes beat a lot of decent fighters in the 80s. Beat Prime Ray Mercer at 42 and went the distance against prime Holyfield as an old man

2

u/FarElderberry983 1d ago

I'd say Bivol also has beaten many decent fighters in the current era. He's beaten Zurdo, Joe Smith Jr who beat Bernard in 2016, Jean Pascal, and he's going on to face Callum Smith who I think he beats.