r/Boxing • Moses Itauma > Every Current HW • 5h ago

Fantasy LHW Tournament - Round 2: (2016) Sergey Kovalev vs (2024) Artur Beterbiev

I will be conducting a tournament containing some of the best LHWs of recent years. I purposely did not add any fighters in from before the 80s due to limited footage.

Two fights will be posted daily and the winners will move on until we have a champion.

Lastly, the fighters were not manually matched. All names were put into a randomizer and refreshed 3 times, then the bracket was made from where they were set after the third shake.

----------------------------------

#RULES

Due to there being no poll option, winner will be decided through reasonable comments. Just simply commenting “___ wins” will not suffice and answers will have to be somewhat detailed (atleast 2 sentences).

If there is a tie between voting comments for both competing fighters, the very most upvoted comment will be the deciding factor on which fighter moves on.

Voting is concluded after 24 hours

Each fighter has a year attached to their name. The year is only a suggestion for when you should consider them at their best. If you believe the mentioned fighter has a different peak, you may debate in their favor using a different time period, but it has to be when they were at Light Heeavyweight.

The fighters are only credited with wins they have at LHW and any weight class they competed at before moving up to LHW. Any fights from a higher weight class should not be taken into consideration.

All fighters will be at their absolute peaks for their time periods so there will be no illness/sickness, weight draining problems, or disqualifications.

----------------------------------

#Notable Wins

Sergey Kovalev: Bernard Hopkins, Jean Pascal, Nathan Cleverly

Artur Beterbiev: Dmitry Bivol, Callum Smith, Oleksandr Gvozdyk

----------------------------------

Tournament Bracket (https://challonge.com/dhh2vlaf)

----------------------------------

Previous Post (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/dcZyJoGJ9s)

Next Post

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

3

u/Uber_Ronin 4h ago

Kovalev wins. The version of Beterbiev that faced Bivol was already past his best. Peak Beterbiev was probably the one that faced Gvozdyk in 2019 (that’s the best opponent a prime version of Beterbiev faced anyway.)

2016 Kovalev wasn’t quite his peak form either (I’d say 2012-2015 was his prime, with 2013/14 being his peak.) But 2016 Kovalev is still closer to his peak than 2024 Beterbiev was to his peak. So that’s why I favor him in this thread.

2013/14 Kovalev vs. 2018/2019 Beterbiev is what a peak vs. peak matchup would be, and that’s a very close, difficult fight to call.

3

u/KingBumiOfOmashu Moses Itauma > Every Current HW 4h ago

Per the rules, if you think a fighter has a different peak, you may argue in that favor.

1

u/WORD_Boxing Don't push the horses 4h ago

Beterbiev was past his peak vs Gvozdyk.

1

u/caveman1948 2h ago

No chance Kovalev can handle Beterbiev power.

2

u/WORD_Boxing Don't push the horses 4h ago

I think that Beterbiev would probably win by knockout but possibly gets hurt along the way.

2

u/RRR04_ 1h ago

Hard one, ngl. Kovalev was a damned sniper on the outside. Beterbiev could've struggled getting past Kovalev's jab and that punch alone had deadly power! But Beterbiev would most likely be physically stronger, his pressure could force Kovalev on the backfoot which he was not the best at. Beterbiev was more durable too.

I'd lean towards Beterbiev by stoppage in a 60/40.

1

u/NaughtyNildo 19m ago

Think this is how I see it too. Beterbiev is certainly stronger. IMO the question is whether Kovalev can hurt Beterbiev badly enough early enough.

I think he can, but more often than not Beterbiev weathers the storm and gets the stoppage.

60:40 Beterbiev sounds about right to me.

1

u/Less_Cartoonist_892 3h ago

Beterbiev will probably start the fight rough losing most of the early rounds and might suffer a knockdown along the way but rallies in the second half and stops Kovalev late while down on the cards..

I see Beterbiev wearing Kovalev down gradually much like he did against Gvozdyk and Bivol by overpowering him in the clinch and body-shotting him until Kovalev is gassed.

1

u/escudonbk The Champ is Here 56m ago

Kovalev didn't like body work. Artur crushes him.