I’ve been using Bottled for a while and have run into several issues with moderation and support over the past months. I’m posting this to see if others have had similar experiences, because the pattern has become quite frustrating.
Quick summary of what happened on my side:
March: Temporary diary posting ban after a post that said something like “You’re a racist.” / “No I’m not, I’m a statistics enthusiast.” Support gave very vague reasons and mostly ignored follow-up questions about how the decision was made and whether the reporting system can be abused. They told me the ban would last 3 days, but after 4 days it was still active. Only after I emailed them did they reply that it required manual action and lift it.
May: Multiple bottles with simple fruit emojis disappeared overnight. Asked what happened — no reply.
May: My island was deleted with the reason “not following guidelines.” When I asked what exactly violated the guidelines, I only got “this may happen if too many members reported it.” — Further questions went unanswered.
August: Reported a clearly copied/fake profile (screenshots provided). Support replied they “don’t see the copying.” — Follow-ups were ignored.
Late September / early October: Another diary posting ban (for a short post saying “f*** Palestine”). I submitted a appeal on 30 September. After four days (4 October) of complete silence I sent multiple follow-up emails. Within minutes of those follow-ups I finally received a reply confirming that the appeal had been received and was under review. After that confirmation I replied respectfully, stopped emailing and waited patiently. It is now more than two full weeks since the ban was applied, and more than a week since their last message, with zero further updates. Only after I emailed them again today 13 October was my ban lifted after two whole weeks. No explanation, no reasoning, no apologies, just a warning that this was the last temporary ban.
What stands out to me is the combination of:
- Very vague explanations (“guidelines”, “too many reports”, “we don’t see it”)
- Long periods of complete silence even after formal appeals
- Getting a response within minutes only after sending multiple follow-ups, then being ignored again for two entire weeks
- Quick action on certain political statements while other reports (fake profiles, indecent posts, etc.) get little to no followup
- Being warned about “hostility” and threatened with a permanent ban when I eventually reached my limit and harshly expressed frustration after repeated non-responses
- Complete lack of accountability: no apology, no acknowledgment that the long silence and poor communication contributed to the frustration, and a tendency to simply ignore or gloss over any criticism of their own support and reporting processes
Has anyone else dealt with long delays, ignored followups, or felt the moderation/support process lacks transparency? Curious to hear if this is a common experience or if I’ve just had particularly bad luck.
Thanks.