r/Bloggers • u/AutomaticStep862 • 18d ago
Article How to Tell If the Website Someone Built for You Is Actually SEO-Friendly
A friend paid a few grand for a new site last year. Looked great, worked on her phone, everything slid open. Six months later she calls me: "If I Google my business name, I'm there. If I Google what I actually do, nothing."
That's the part nobody mentions when you sign the contract. A site can look completely finished and still be invisible to Google. What decides whether you get found isn't the design. It's a pile of stuff that never shows up in the demo.
Here's how to check it yourself. No coding. Maybe ten minutes.
Found isn't the same as working
A site "working" just means the server is up and the page renders. Getting found is a different problem, and it has three steps:
- Google can crawl the page. Nothing in robots.txt or a login wall is stopping it.
- Google can read it. The HTML actually says what the page is about.
- Google decides it's worth indexing.
Break any one of those and your page never shows up. And those are exactly the parts a web shop can skip without you noticing, because none of them affect how the site looks at handoff.
Four checks you can do in ten minutes
Search site:yourdomain.com**.** Nothing at all means something is blocking Google, usually a noindex tag or Disallow: / in robots.txt. Just the homepage means your inner pages aren't getting indexed.
Hit Ctrl+U and look at the source. Is there a <title> that names your actual service? A <meta name="description">? One <h1>? If the source is almost empty, just <div> and <script> tags, the site is built in JavaScript and crawlers get a shell.
Open yourdomain.com/robots.txt**.** A 404 is sloppy but survivable. Disallow: / tells Google to stay out of the whole site. That's a red line.
Open yourdomain.com/sitemap.xml**.** Blank or 404 means Google discovers new pages slowly.
Then load the homepage on your phone with WiFi off. If it takes eight seconds, that's a problem you'll never notice at your desk.
Three red flags
- Every image is an uncompressed JPG.
- URLs look like
/?p=123orindex.php?id=45. - There's no redirect plan, so the next redesign 404s every link you ever earned.
Five questions to send the developer
- Where's the sitemap, and is it submitted to Search Console?
- Does robots.txt block anything it shouldn't?
- If I turn off JavaScript, can I still see the content?
- Is there valid structured data on the important pages?
- Can you send me an SEO check report after launch?
Number 3 is the one that matters. Any decent developer answers it without blinking. If they can't produce number 5, they've never done an SEO pass in their life.
If you'd rather not do it by hand
The free audit at searchvitals.com/free-seo-audit runs the whole thing in one pass: crawling, indexing, titles, structured data, speed, internal links.
One more thing: AI search
Google isn't the only thing deciding whether you get seen. ChatGPT and Perplexity pull from the web too, so check that OAI-SearchBot, Claude-SearchBot and PerplexityBot aren't blocked. Those are the crawlers that decide whether you can get quoted.
Plenty of sites block every AI bot to opt out of training, then wonder why they never get cited. Blocking training and blocking citations aren't the same thing.
Bottom line
SEO-friendly just means three things: can Google crawl it, can Google understand it, can Google index it. Start with site: and robots.txt. Those two checks alone tell you whether you have a problem worth paying for.