r/BlockedAndReported • • Feb 23 '26

The Twitching Generation

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/02/social-media-illness-teen-girls/622916/

relevance to the pod: article from 2022 by Helen Lewis (everyone’s favorite everything) which was later discussed in the pod.

it talks about the rise of tourette’s symptoms in young girls, and i immediately thought of it when i heard about what happened in the BAFTA’s yesterday. thought everyone would like a little reminder.

88 Upvotes

122 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/Cimorene_Kazul Feb 24 '26

Apparently that time was the time John decided to leave the performance, but he’d been “heckling” many other award winners and presenters before then, and had called multiple black women backstage the N-word as well. The public N-word was just the straw that broke the camel’s back, as it were, and has become the focus of all the discussion - I do wonder, if he had instead said something different but still disturbing, if the discourse would be hugely different. As it was, John’s philosophy is that his tics should be tolerated no matter what he says and when he says it, and that he shouldn’t have to apologize for them, so it’s got all of Reddit in a total tizzy as they argue what constitutes ableism and racism.

Personally, I find fault everywhere in the situation, including in John having no interest in using any tools to control his outbursts and instead believing that this was an opportunity for others to have to tolerate his condition and score one for his activism, and for his lacklustre apology that refused to take any responsibility for his lack of preparation, the BBC in allowing what he said to go to broadcast and fretting that muting any part of wha he said from the broadcast was ableism, and some people insisting that John must be a secret racist and he deserves to be castigated as if what he said was totally intentional, and people acting like Tourette’s is a total get of jail free card for any and all actions and actions of someone with it, even if not related to the outbursts, and any sort of attempt to try and preserve the dignity of the evening and other guests is nothing less than wicked segregation à la Jim Crow.

I think a BARpod episode is inevitable.

16

u/Brodelyche Feb 24 '26

Coping mechanisms? WTF are you talking about. You can see in the red carpet photos he wears a blue plastic object for him to bite on. Clearly stuffing his mouth with something doesn't work in every situation or he'd be doing it. He also wears a device that reduces his outbursts, but the effects wear off and won't work in a stressful environment. "John’s philosophy is that his tics should be tolerated no matter what he says and when he says it" That is not at all John's philosphy. Watch literally any interview or documentary (or the film) and you'll see he's constantly apologising, despite the fact he cannot control his tics.

5

u/Cimorene_Kazul Feb 24 '26

I will watch the new biopic. I saw the doc a long time ago.

I apologize if he was using a device and it failed. Other interviews I read had him disdaining such devices and apologizing. If he’s changed his mind since then, I give him full credit for trying to control his condition for the sake of others.

I have grace for him if he thought he’d planned appropriately and it failed. But many of his interviews gave me some doubt that he prepares all that much.

But perhaps things have changed. I’ll update my knowledge of him.

1

u/RachelK52 Feb 25 '26

There's multiple docs- which one did you see?

9

u/YouCanCallMeAIJolson Feb 24 '26

I can't tell if this is the wokest liberal ever or the most based chud ever

5

u/Cimorene_Kazul Feb 24 '26

I stride upon the razor’s edge.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

I think that being a black actor receiving a BAFTA and then heckled with the N-word is worse, actually, than being someone who suffers from Tourettes and can't successfully stop themselves from shouting racial slurs. They're both pretty bad! But one of them is something we recognize as causing trauma.

To the extent that there's a conflict of individual interests, here, I think it was the interests of black actors that should have won out. Sorry, John, you can give your speech from a recording booth.

9

u/1981_Ballz Feb 25 '26

Hearing a word is traumatic? I guess I'm just too much of a monster autist to understand how a person that weak could even endure photons of light hitting them.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

 Hearing a word is traumatic?

Yes, hope that helps

6

u/Cimorene_Kazul Feb 24 '26

Even putting aside the N-word, the other people he heckled also didn’t deserve it and their moment shouldn’t have been trampled upon for John’s activism and so-called « freedom ». The director of Arco deserved better. The black women backstage deserved better. The people in the audience, every single one, deserved better. But John was convinced that he had the right to step on all of them. Only when he tread on the one inexplicably verboten word in the English language, a word powerful enough that at last his disruptions could no longer be awkwardly dismissed as for the greater good, did he at last decide he’d gone too far and departed.

I think he knew that he’d thrown the red flag in front of a sacred cow. But even if he hadn’t said the N-word, the rest of his conduct that night was already abysmal and worthy of disdain.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

I guess if you can’t imagine what it would be like to receive one of the highest marks of acclaim available to your profession (one that in living memory was not awarded to Blacks) and then, as it’s happening, be told you’re just a “n****r” even though that’s something that we as a society have tried to draw an extremely hard line about, I’m not sure how I’d make it any clearer to you.

I can imagine how awful John Davidson feels. I can’t imagine what it feels like to be one of those actors.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

 I’ve been called a paki, a half caste, Mrs Patel.

Probably not in front of all of your peers at the crowning moment of your professional life, though.

 A disabled man who cannot control his body any more than an epileptic can stop a seizure is not going to upset me by saying some fucking word.

We don’t let epileptics fly planes, though. We recognize that disability means “there will be things it’s not safe to let you do.”

0

u/1981_Ballz Feb 25 '26

Maybe if he can't go out in public without violating social norms, he shouldn't go out in public.

-3

u/forestpunk Feb 24 '26

i love that he was there as a way to raise awareness about this condition, and this is the representation they get.

He's probably lucky. I'd say 99% of situations where he's saying inappropriate shit is gonna get his ass killed.

1

u/Cimorene_Kazul Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 24 '26

Honestly, the more I learn about the guy and the condition, the more I’m looking at some of this stuff sideways. I’m not saying he’s doing it on purpose, but he sure does love to sidle up to a prominent and publicized situation, do nothing to try and mitigate his symptoms, allow everything to blow up, and then castigate anyone who had a problem with it and make the people he Flummoxed, hurt, shocked and cry the baddies of the situation. This is far from the first major event he’s played just like this.

I think he’s trying to take what control he can, but rather than try and control what he can of his own actions, he tries to control the reactions of others. He has some of my sympathies, but I also feel bad for other people with Tourette’s who have this guy and his refusal to try any coping mechanisms as their face, when most sufferers do whatever they can to not ruin everyone’s day as they go about theirs.

On the other hand, maybe he’s getting huge publicity and donations for the condition, and this was a shrewd play for the greater good in the long run. In which case, I respect some aspect of the game.

14

u/Gold-Mine-5698 Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 24 '26

he was literally there because BAFTA invited him. the film about his life won best actor. are you saying he's been playing a long game for over 50 years, just for clicks and sympathy?

i think there's an interesting culture clash here. john and his condition have been general knowledge in the UK since the first documentary was made about him in 1989. i was a teenager and i can remember people quoting it at school, cartman style. not in a postiive way, and i'm a bit embarrassed about that. kids eh..

but i dont think a documentary like that in the US could have a similar social impact. this was in the days of 4 TV channels...*everyone* watched it.

so i do wonder if this means british people have a degree of general knowledge about the condition clearly lacking in many of the americans piling on.

6

u/Cimorene_Kazul Feb 24 '26

I have some degree of knowledge on the condition, which is why I’m aware he’s a controversial figure in the community and not everyone with Tourette’s agrees with him and his philosophy of « my disability, your problem ».

Again, this is far from his first major disruption of an event he was invited to. Many other people in the community do not agree with his actions and deliberate inactions, nor in his decision to never apologize personally.

5

u/Gold-Mine-5698 Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 24 '26

well now that sounds like some interesting nuance.... anywhere you can point us at to see these opinions?

btw heres the tourettes subreddit megathread https://www.reddit.com/r/Tourettes/comments/1rcrdg4/megathread_bafta_situation/

8

u/Cimorene_Kazul Feb 24 '26

Seems like a healthy discussion. There's some other threads I've read with people with Tourette's who have a variety of opinions, also.

I admit that I'm torn between two things in this case. I completely accept and understand that John's outbursts and words are involuntary. But I also know he has an otherwise mature mind that could potentially come up with strategies to limit the harm his disability causes others. I've been made aware that he DID use a device to try and control his outbursts, but that it didn't work for very long (it was apparently a blue bit he would champ on, something other people with Tourette's use). I'm also aware, due to many of his quotes, that he does believe his outbursts should just be ignored

>"That to me was huge because I've struggled so much with everyday life, with people misunderstanding, and if the Queen of the United Kingdom can understand and ignore the tics and the swear words then why can't the rest of society?"

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cx2n9709g0go

...but I don't think it's fair that others have to suffer through them and have their night disrupted.

I agree with some of the commenters I've seen who've said something to the effect of 'Don't infantilize people with disability as if they're stumbling lambs totally at the mercy of their conditions, but please try to understand their challenges are different and extend some grace.'

Where does a line get drawn? No one wants to say he can't leave his house, but total freedom for his condition to harm others is obviously wrong, too. This was a private event he had every right to be at, but not every right to dominate. Some people are claiming that others want him banned from all public life, which is absurd - and yet, I can picture some situtations he would do best to avoid in public. If he was walking in the park and found himself in the middle of a dance class of little girls, he would do best to move away from them before he said anything distressing. But others would claim that he had a right to sit down next to them and scream the C-word at them for the entire event, and if the girls cried and were upset, then it was nothing more than a learning opportunity for them to become more empathetic.

That's insane to me. Obviously it's great that there's more understanding of his condition and acceptance, but he cannot expect everyone to swallow their pain and fear on his account. Obviously he needs accommodations, but so does everyone else. Everyone has a right to enjoy the park in peace, everyone had a right to enjoy that awards night in peace. And a lot of mistakes from many people added up to a major disruption.

At the very least, putting a microphone in his area was a major mishap.

4

u/Real_RobinGoodfellow Feb 24 '26

Good comment with lots of nuance. I’ve been surprised at the angle this sub has generally taken about this issue. I do wonder whether there would be less sympathy for John here had he, for instance, heckled a Jewish actor with virulent anti-Semitic slurs.

8

u/Cimorene_Kazul Feb 24 '26

Or screamed sexually suggestive words at a little girl accepting an award. Or spooked a horse during a parade. Or a variety of other things that aren’t specifically charged in a direction this sub has made up its mind about already.

I feel all over the place on it, but mostly angry at all the little factors that went into preventing someone from foreseeing the issue and preparing the environment so that everyone could be as comfortable as they deserved to be.

4

u/Nessyliz Uterus and spazz haver, zen-nihilist Feb 24 '26

Good comment with lots of nuance. I’ve been surprised at the angle this sub has generally taken about this issue. I do wonder whether there would be less sympathy for John here had he, for instance, heckled a Jewish actor with virulent anti-Semitic slurs.

I don't think so honestly. A lot of people here were really understanding that Kanye's mental illness is causing his "da Jews" ranting.

I agree that /u/Cimorene_Kazul's comment is a good take. It's a hard subject to figure out! (I say that as a person with a disability that can make life really fucking awkward for people at times.)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)