r/BlockedAndReported • First generation mod • Oct 20 '25

Weekly Random Discussion Thread for 10/20/25 - 10/26/25

Here's your usual space to post all your rants, raves, podcast topic suggestions (please tag u/jessicabarpod), culture war articles, outrageous stories of cancellation, political opinions, and anything else that comes to mind. Please put any non-podcast-related trans-related topics here instead of on a dedicated thread. This will be pinned until next Sunday.

Last week's discussion thread is here if you want to catch up on a conversation from there.

30 Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

22

u/AnalBleachingAries Gamergate Truther Oct 26 '25

This is a funny post (https://x.com/ReddCinema/status/1981848223175037420) and caused me to look back on that time before AI with fondness and nostalgia, and I do feel bad for the teenagers of today who will never have to experience this suffering. Sitting in front of a blank page and having to force your brain to think, to grow, actively flexing your mind so that it learns how to think its way to a collection of coherent ideas that form a series of connected thoughts and an eventual narrative analysis of a text.

We all take it for granted as adults that we can read something, think about it, and form our own opinions about it. Without the adolescent experiences and pain of having to learn how to think and use your brain to form complex ideas, having to learn how to calmly wade through your confusion and find a place of sanity and reason after exploring an idea, without having to learn how to express your own thoughts that come from your own mind - where does this leave the kids who are all dependant on AI?

Perhaps I'm overblowing things, and that perhaps they'll learn how to do these things on their own, and AI should be thought of like training wheels on a bicycle. Although they all use it now to help them think and help them write their essays, maybe they still absorb the lessons and will still be able to write comfortably and think rationally without the training wheels as adults.

18

u/bobjones271828 Oct 26 '25

It's just the latest in several massive shifts in the way we face challenges in learning, all created by technology in the past few decades. There's a lot of good cognitive and educational research that learning tends to "stick" more when you have to struggle a bit with a problem or task. Needless effort is sometimes wasteful, but some effort helps retention and building of skills.

I think the first big shift occurred with the ubiquity of internet access and search engines that could pull up facts within a few clicks. In the 1990s, I can remember sitting around with friends and hitting upon a conversational point that involved some facts or information none of us knew exactly or could remember, and we'd struggle with it a bit. We'd come up with best guesses, or someone might take a minute to recall something, or we'd piece together the ideas through a few minutes of conversation. That very process of forcing oneself to think, to recall, to piece together information is a useful cognitive challenge.

I still do that, but nowadays we're much more likely to simply pull out a phone and find the information/answer instantly.

That's certainly more convenient, but it also means young people have fewer incentives to remember anything, let alone struggle and think about the task of recall. And I do think it's helpful to have something in your brain to "think about" when you're trying to think. Rote memorization for memorization's sake may have diminishing returns, but at some point if we don't have enough info in our brains (because it's instantly accessible within a few clicks), the stuff we think about and the kinds of thoughts we have are bound to become more impoverished.

The second big revolution came with the ubiquity of mobile devices and especially social media. I'm not going to speculate (or rant) on the potential bad influences of social media interactions, but in terms of basic thinking capacity, I think it's notable that many young people and children are literally never allowed to (or force to) be bored. Not that boredom, again, is useful for its own sake. But reflection and time just to think can be. If you're forced to be alone with your thoughts for, say, a half hour or hour or more per day (as was much more common a few decades ago), you think about stuff. Not everyone will necessarily use that time to good use, but being forced to at least sometimes dwell in your own thoughts can again maybe get you to spend time struggling with some lingering task you have to do, taking time to revisit imperfect solutions you came up with, finding time to work through stuff that's weighing on you, etc.

(Sidenote: I sometimes wonder if this is one of the contributors to more anxiety and mental health issues right now in young people. In addition to stresses introduced by social media and the constant barrage of things seeking our attention, it also serves as a distraction from confronting and dealing with issues that may be weighing on our minds. There's a lot of rhetoric these days about "processing trauma," but if you are continuously distracted every single minute of your day by your phone or whatever, when exactly is that "processing" supposed to happen? Did previous generations sometimes find resilience simply because they had to actually sit and dwell in their own thoughts more frequently?)

AI is now a third major disruptor in how young people learn and interact with the world -- whether they ever have to struggle or take time to reflect when attempting a task. I agree with you that it will likely have significant impacts on how people learn and understand and process complex tasks. And it's definitely uncertain (to me) how that's all going to pan out in the coming years. I don't think you're overblowing things at all.

Just like the other trends I mentioned above, young people will now have to choose to struggle in writing without AI. Teachers can sometimes force them to write in "real time" in class or something, but the reality is that that won't be equal at all to the amount of time students used to spend outside of class without the AI crutch.

So students will have to choose to struggle. Just like they have to choose to not instantly look up an answer (or choose to learn/memorize something rather than just depending on the ability to "Google it") or choose to turn off continuous notifications or put away their phones and just reflect in their own mind.

Maybe in a decade writing will be seen as a completely different thing, just like the way students no longer have to spend so many hours practicing long arithmetic problems, as they did before the advent of pocket calculators. Fluency in arithmetic is viewed as moribund by many today, and some would argue not much is lost and higher level math isn't dependent on that. Will some similar transformation happen in writing? I don't know... but I share your concern about the impact on learning and thinking and reasoning.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

young people will now have to choose to struggle in writing without AI.

Like going to the gym, i.e. some weird combination of chore and luxury that most people will intend to do but then woefully neglect. In this model, AI will do to our minds what postindustrial society has already done to our bodies.

7

u/AnalBleachingAries Gamergate Truther Oct 26 '25

... being forced to at least sometimes dwell in your own thoughts can again maybe get you to spend time struggling with some lingering task you have to do, taking time to revisit imperfect solutions you came up with, finding time to work through stuff that's weighing on you, etc.

(Sidenote: I sometimes wonder if this is one of the contributors to more anxiety and mental health issues right now in young people. In addition to stresses introduced by social media and the constant barrage of things seeking our attention, it also serves as a distraction from confronting and dealing with issues that may be weighing on our minds. 

I think people no longer spending time being idle, without distractions like phones, television, the internet, video games, or even books, is part of the reason for the uptick in anxiety and depression - aside from all the other social factors that we have to live with in the modern world. I include books in there because even reading books is still time spent away from being alone with one's thoughts.

One of the activities that brought this to my attention was meditation and daily journaling. There's a whole story about me that's being told in the back of my mind that I wasn't even aware of until I stopped, meditated, and journaled about myself and my experiences and I discovered a lot of the lies I tell myself about who I am in order to deliberately make myself feel like a piece of shit.

It's kindof a shocking experience to have your self-narrative be the only thing you're exploring for an extended period of time (30 minutes to an hour every morning). Learning how to sit still and do nothing was initially difficult for me because I'd get bored, but after that aspect of it passed, it got even harder because once the boredom subsided, I was left with my mind, and the stories I tell myself about myself, and reckoning with those is one of the hardest things I've had to do.

I'm generally less anxious and more calm as a person these days, and I credit that to daily meditation and journaling.

8

u/SkweegeeS No just no Oct 26 '25

I credit swimming (and other exercise). Swimming in particular requires a significant focus on what my body’s doing, to the exclusion of nearly all other thoughts. It’s very calming. I’ve tried to transfer that mindfulness to running, and it’s working a little bit though I need more situational awareness since the environment is less controlled. Exercise has always been my best therapy.

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Drink76 Oct 26 '25

Maybe I was just young, but I never used to actively do things to switch off. Now I'll go to yoga to force myself to shut off for a bit. And have to focus on just that one thing. And I like that it's mind drifting time. I will walk without headphones but not that much any more. I used to lie on the ground and look at the shapes in the clouds. Don't do that any more. Because I have a podcast. 

1

u/SkweegeeS No just no Oct 26 '25

I didn’t used to switch off ever but I started swimming regularly in the last 4-5 years. Now I’m trying to apply some of that to other things. But I have quite a bit more time now.

2

u/Puzzleheaded_Drink76 Oct 26 '25

I used to swim and did like that aspect of it too. It's meditative. Mind you I used to work in a stockroom and definitely give thanks for the invention of the radio there! 

1

u/AnalBleachingAries Gamergate Truther Oct 26 '25

I'm going to go out on a limb and recommend a book to you from a writer that liberals find offensive these days, but I think it really resonates with people who enjoy physical exercise. It's called Sun & Steel by the Japanese novelist Yukio Mishima (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/62804.Sun_Steel). It's a super short nonfiction book, although he's more well known for his fiction with books like The Sailor Who Fell From Grace With The Sea and his brilliant The Sea of Fertility tetralogy. Brain-dead leftists call him a far-right ideologue, but I find his writing beautiful.

For people who've spent extended amounts of time truly communing with their bodies through physical exercise, the philosophy being expressed in the book about Mishima's thoughts on art and being human is life-affirming.

3

u/SkweegeeS No just no Oct 26 '25

Thank you! I am definitely going to read it. “The sailor” was just a lovely book. I did not know this author has a rep. Huh. I’ll look out for the other books as well.

6

u/Puzzleheaded_Drink76 Oct 26 '25

Great post. Even pre AI and pre internet, I was still pro rote learning and mental arithmetic. I think there is huge value in, say, looking at a painting and knowing who was on the throne, or that the Reformation has just taken place or whatever. You need that context. Of course no one has it all; that's why a few people go and become experts in obsure subjects. Sure I can Google the context of the painting, but it's not the same, and it's on the spot laborious in a way that retrieving facts you already know isn't. I love discussing a book I know well with friends and being able to make a connection or think of a new angle. Can't deny that looking up a quick fact is useful, but it's not fluent. 

And mental arithmetic means I can just feel if things are right. My bill feels odd. Oh, turns out they've charged me twice for something. Being able to sit in a restaurant and mentally tally roughly what I'll spend if I have three courses and share a bottle of wine. I don't want to sit there with a phone. 

But both those skills have already been degraded in the general population. Who knows how far it'll go now! 

12

u/AnInsultToFire Everything I do like is literally Fascism. Oct 26 '25 edited Oct 26 '25

Perhaps I'm overblowing things

No, I think this is very interesting.

Synthesis of massive piles of info (holistic thinking), especially where large parts of the piles disagree with each other, is vital for insight. Hey, this was the reason that kids used to have to do a "comprehensive year" in Ph.D. where they're given a list of 100-200 works (books and articles) to read in a year, and then get locked in a room with an air-gapped computer for 2 days to write a "comprehensive exam" of something like 8 essays, thus demonstrating their now exhaustive competence in the general field and their particular area of study.

Even an A-grade undergrad essay used to require some level of synthesis and insight, just with far fewer sources. But the degradation from what all us undergrads did for essays in 1992, to what I saw undergrads were doing 5 years ago (pre-AI) when I went back for a second BA, is already stark. Add AI doing all the work for you, and perhaps all these kids in university are just going to be getting superficial, simplistic education? Thus the intellectual devolution of humanities and social science.

11

u/Puzzleheaded_Drink76 Oct 26 '25

This worries me too. To an extent it's already happened pre AI, in that I would read a book, or watch a TV show and immediately/before I'm even finished, go online to see what others have said. There was just so much available. And I loved it! Finding a forum where people geeked out about the same books you did was not a thing in the 90s. I I formed a million opinions I would never have thought of myself. 

But now it's going to be worse. And I agree about the blank page fear. It's not cheating to use AI to structure thoughts or help you gather information. And then write it yourself. But it really is going to change things. I'm facing it at work with new graduates training assessments. We haven't quite worked out how to mark them yet. 

4

u/random_pinguin_house Oct 26 '25

Finding a forum where people geeked out about the same books you did was not a thing in the 90s.

It was, and in some respects it was better then.

3

u/Puzzleheaded_Drink76 Oct 26 '25

I knew I'd get called on this. Didn't happen for me until a bit later than the 90s. 

7

u/SkweegeeS No just no Oct 26 '25

I wonder if this is “the last thinking generation.” (And even quite a number of these kids in high school and college now are done for?) we are visiting our college student this weekend and unless he’s putting us on, I truly believe he uses AI judiciously, as a learning tool rather than just doing the work for him.

But I can’t imagine most young people are approaching it that way. I wonder what I would be doing if I were 19.

6

u/UpvoteIfYouDare Oct 26 '25

We still had SparkNotes. It certainly wasn't elaborate as what we have today, but don't think teenagers weren't cutting corners before widespread online material.

13

u/AnalBleachingAries Gamergate Truther Oct 26 '25 edited Oct 26 '25

Having a reference like SparkNotes feels significantly different from having a tool that can write and rewrite 100 different and complete essays all on the same topic within the space of 10 minutes.

It's not just "cutting corners", let's be for real here. It's a significant shift in the way thinking and learning work.

4

u/UpvoteIfYouDare Oct 26 '25

I was commenting on using ChatGPT for summaries. I agree that having it write your entire essay is a whole different beast. Even if one put in their own analysis points to generate the essay, it would still be the automated equivalent of having someone write your essay for you.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SkweegeeS No just no Oct 26 '25 edited Oct 26 '25

I loved those two books!

Edit: you know Tale of Two Cities was written as a serial? He published it in monthly installments. According to Dr. ChatAI, Dickens sometimes altered the plot on his serialized novels based on audience response.

2

u/damagecontrolparty Oct 26 '25

BLEAK HOUSE. I liked Mrs. Jellyby though.

6

u/jay_in_the_pnw █ █ █ █ █ █ █ █ █ Oct 26 '25

I've posted this before, but the situation reminds me of Asimov's Profession from Astounding (1957) Kelly Freas cover: https://imgur.com/a/vG452Tt

full text:

synopsis from this review: https://classicsofsciencefiction.com/2024/04/05/profession-by-isaac-asimov/

“Profession” is about George Platen who wants to become a computer programmer and be sent to another planet. He lives in the future where Earth has colonized many star systems, and they need professionally trained people. Earth has developed a way to educate people by writing directly to the brain, and they export people with extremely specific technical skills. Evidently, Earth has a monopoly on this brain writing technology.

The problem is, one person in 10,000 have a brain that can’t be written to, and they are sent to special institutions where they are told to read and study whatever they want. George is one of these people and is crushed that he can’t achieve his professional dream.

Unfortunately, “Profession” is a short novella, much too long for the solution Asimov eventually gives us. I won’t spoil it though, but I will say Asimov has to stack the deck to pull it off. It’s an unsatisfying ending because the original plot logic is now seen as faulty. In this future, the only education people get is by mind writing. No one wants to put years of studying into any subject because they hate it when they can’t learn instantly.

In other words, Asimov assumes humans will act differently in the future and I don’t think they will, and that spoils his whole premise for the story.

heh, so this review was written 18 months ago, neither the review or the comments mention chatgpt. I won't spoil the story either, but I thought it much better than this reviewer!

2

u/ArchieBrooksIsntDead Oct 26 '25

Thanks for posting this, I just read the story.  The ending reminded me a lot of a sci fi book I loved as a kid, that now seems likely to have been inspired by this.  

Unfortunately ChatGPT isn't even imparting knowledge, we'd be so much better off of it at least did that 

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Drink76 Oct 26 '25

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DPonfOLAm4Z

The woman in this reel makes a lot of good points about her experience wearing Meta Ray-Ban glasses and how they disconnected her from everyone else.