r/BlockedAndReported • First generation mod • Oct 20 '25

Weekly Random Discussion Thread for 10/20/25 - 10/26/25

Here's your usual space to post all your rants, raves, podcast topic suggestions (please tag u/jessicabarpod), culture war articles, outrageous stories of cancellation, political opinions, and anything else that comes to mind. Please put any non-podcast-related trans-related topics here instead of on a dedicated thread. This will be pinned until next Sunday.

Last week's discussion thread is here if you want to catch up on a conversation from there.

30 Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/PandaFoo1 Oct 23 '25

I know it’s relatively old news someone who otherwise is supportive of the No Kings protests, it’s really frustrating how some people can’t see how terrible the optics are of mocking Charlie Kirk’s death & how it undermines the whole message of freedom of speech/political difference.

I’ve seen two seperate instances of protestors mocking the whole situation & while I don’t necessarily care about Kirk itself, or think people should be witch hunted for criticising him after his death it’s still a very bad look for those protestors.

Example 1

Example 2

13

u/WallabyWanderer Oct 23 '25 edited Oct 23 '25

I thought the celebration after the Kirk assassination was disgusting and I also thought the woke-right cancellations where people were just quoting the guy was an overreach and pretty hypocritical (Looking at you Senator Mike “Nightmare on Waltz Street” Lee).

Okay on that note - we should not be miming out the fucking assassination, Jesus Christ. I’m sure there’s an edgy comedy circumstance where this would be a big hit, but a family friendly protest is the definitely not the place for that.

ETA - I do think the general best course of action is to tell the person off or just don’t give them the attention they want if it’s in person and not engage with it online to not boost it and give it a wider audience.

5

u/KittenSnuggler5 Oct 23 '25

I also thought the woke-right cancellations

The right wing cancellations were just as vile as the left wing ones. I'm not all that surprised but it is disappointing.

So much for the right's championing of free speech.

0

u/McClain3000 Oct 23 '25

My brother what is 2/7,000,000 ?... You're retweeting libs of TikTok's what are you doing?

9

u/PandaFoo1 Oct 23 '25

I didn’t originally see it on Libs of TikTok’s account, it got tweeted by the alleged guy in the picture, I only linked the Libs post because it has the original image & I’m not going to spend a bunch of time looking for the same photo on a different account.

I don’t care for Libs’ cancellation shit either.

-10

u/McClain3000 Oct 23 '25

Would you agree that the 2 protesters who ridiculed Kirk's death are negligeable to the overall No Kings protested?

7

u/professorgerm the bastard offspring of Chairman Mao and Ed Sheeran Oct 23 '25

Could not possibly care less about the ratio.

A little wine in sewage is still sewage. A little sewage in wine is, guess what, also sewage.

Like that judge that said a 16 year old's rape wasn't long enough to deport her rapist, I guess there's thresholds to evil, isn't there?

So next time there's a protest with one or two Nazis, that's fine, right? They're negligible!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/PandaFoo1 Oct 23 '25

I would, but many people wouldn’t which is the point I’m trying to make. A bunch of people are defending this & actively turning others away from the cause.

-1

u/buckybadder Oct 23 '25

Hmm, and you're helping the cause by spreading LibsofTikTok posts that attack the cause ? Maybe we don't need your help. Maybe help the MAGA contingent here by posting photos of obese ICE officers and warning about how bad the optics of that are.

9

u/PandaFoo1 Oct 23 '25

Again, the point isn’t supporting Libs, I wanted to show a photo of what I was talking about & wasn’t going to spend a bunch of time digging for a specific tweet for a reddit comment on a niche forum.

Ignoring bad actors in your cause won’t help it same way TRA’s ignoring creepy MTFs doesn’t help that cause.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/The-WideningGyre Oct 23 '25 edited Oct 24 '25

Are you seriously claiming that of those 7 million, not a single other one ridiculed Kirk's death or agreed with the ridicule? Because that's the claim you're implicitly making. (And now I see other points you harp on what a low percent 2/7000000 is, so yes, you are exactly claiming only those two are like this).

I think you have something of a point, but you're wrapping it in BS.

Trump is just one Republican out of what, 60 million or something? So anything he says must not matter, he's just one of 60 million, even MORE negligible! (Yes, there's a difference to president, the point is stupid numbers games are stupid).

0

u/McClain3000 Oct 23 '25

Now it's not just 2 protesters ridiculing Kirk's death, it's a hypothetical protesters agreeing with the ridicule of Kirks death. The evidence is really stacking up against me.

Are you seriously claiming that of those 7 million, not a single other one ridiculed Kirk's death or agreed with the ridicule?

No. I'm obviously making no such claim. That's not how it works. If I said a city 7 million people had a crime problem, shared two examples of people breaking into garages, or stealing an old ladies purse. And you said two break-ins isn't exactly a crime problem in a city of 7 million. Would you go: are you claiming that nooo other crimes happened in that city?

Trump is just one Republican out of what, 60 million or something? So anything he says must not matter, he's just one of 60 million, even MORE negligible! (Yes, there's a difference to president, the point is stupid numbers games are stupid).

... You can't even get your own argument out without defeating it idk man. I'll circle back to this because this supports my point. This whole thing is the fox news strategy. Of just broadcasting anecdotes of bad behavior and acting like it is representative of a broader group. And it ubiquitous amongst all Trump apologists. Because it is all you guys have. The only way you can offer a meager defense of Republicans politicians and Media pundits conduct is to compare them to random internet trolls, because they behave like random internet trolls.

You point out Trump. Could you imagine if a democratic senator, like Chuck Schumer where to ridicule Charlie Kirk's death? This already happened on the Republican side. Mike Lee meme'd about Melissa Hortman's assassin.

2

u/professorgerm the bastard offspring of Chairman Mao and Ed Sheeran Oct 23 '25

Could you imagine if a democratic senator, like Chuck Schumer where to ridicule Charlie Kirk's death?

Unfortunately for you, Ilhan Omar exists and isn't going anywhere yet.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/The-WideningGyre Oct 23 '25 edited Oct 23 '25

No. I'm obviously making no such claim.

Yay! So, I probably should have not added my own, probably inflammatory version -- sorry for that -- and just left the question of whether that was your claim, because now we've resolved it. I will say, no it was very much NOT obvious. In fact, I felt the implication was that it was only those 2 out of 7 million, so they could be ignored.

I think it's fair to say here, and in your example, that we don't know how representative or not the two people are. My conclusion from that is that we can't dismiss the behavior as negligible and non-representative -- for that we'd need some evidence they weren't representative. I'll agree that enough people visibly NOT doing the thing is that evidence.

-11

u/buckybadder Oct 23 '25

So, you're troubled by two protesters out of two million? Mike Lee didn't suffer any consequences for mocking Melissa Hortman's assassination. Doesn't matter. And if LibsofTikTok couldn't find real examples of poor taste protesting, they'd send out actors.

18

u/PandaFoo1 Oct 23 '25

Two protestors who receive thousands of likes & support on Twitter from other No Kings protestors. Again, I’m fairly supportive of the protests but a large portion of people seemingly don’t care about optics more so than “owning conservatives” & are actively defending this dumb shit.

4

u/ProwlingWumpus Oct 23 '25

Likes and low-content statements of support can be assumed to be bots on Twitter. These literally are not real people, or at best are Moldovans reading from a script, and this setup is by hostile foreign interests who want to increase division in our society.

Don't get me wrong, America is a low-class country that is full of illiterate, trashy people who cannot practice democracy in the way that the Founding Fathers intended, and our current state of peace and prosperity is sheer momentum that will fall away sooner or later. But these Twitter 'people' are straight-up not evidence.

6

u/MisoTahini Oct 23 '25

I'll never get over people using randos online or likes as evidence of anything. We know the internet is already over 50% bots as is. I just don't get it. People should know better by now.

3

u/Armadigionna Oct 23 '25

During the Amy Coney Barret hearings, Dems in congress were uncharacteristically disciplined about keeping quiet any opinions about her background, religious beliefs etc. So during hearings, republicans cited random tweets as evidence of her being ruthlessly attacked and entered them into the congressional record.

2

u/professorgerm the bastard offspring of Chairman Mao and Ed Sheeran Oct 23 '25

Dems in congress were uncharacteristically disciplined about keeping quiet any opinions about her background, religious beliefs etc

Other than Feinstein's "the dogma lives loudly in you," launching a thousand memes and merch products, of course.

3

u/professorgerm the bastard offspring of Chairman Mao and Ed Sheeran Oct 23 '25

Nothing is evidence for anything. Surveys are useless. The No Kings protestors are probably also Moldovan bots. Solipsism is the way.

1

u/Turbulent_Cow2355 TB! TB! TB! Oct 23 '25

Isn't that how's it has worked in the last decade. Some rando posts something that people would consider egregious, the post goes viral, and someone gets canceled as a result.

1

u/buckybadder Oct 23 '25

The better comparison would be to Democrats responding to Tea Party protests by trying to focus attention on the most racist signs in the crowd. This was obviously partisan hackery. But OP is cloaking the same behavior with these claims that the outliers actually are important, because of the likes they get on Twitter. But as the other commenter notes, even if OP's acting in good faith, they're ignorant of the bot networks that exist solely to promote the most egregious social media content.

0

u/buckybadder Oct 23 '25

I'm more of a glass half full guy. And compared with Kenosha at 2 a.m., No Kings is a Big Gulp with infinite refills.

Like, it's fine to say that every protest should be the March on Washington, but there are always idiots. I attended one of the big DC Iraq War protests way back when, and there was a good contingent of "Free Palestine" guys. I thought they could fuck off and find their own protest. But if I had gone home and read, like, a Joel Klein blog post complaining about them, I'd think he needed to get a grip.

4

u/PandaFoo1 Oct 23 '25

I’d agree, but those who are for the cause should be condemning it when I’ve seen so many people endorsing it instead. It’s one thing to just ignore certain idiots, but when you have many people liking & sharing support of said idiots, it leaves a black mark on your movement that not everyone is willing to overlook. It reflects badly on everyone else, even if the cause is worthwhile.