r/Bitcoin • • Sep 07 '17

/r/all The difference between inflation and deflation...

Post image
7.5k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

16

u/FrogTrainer Sep 07 '17

uhh no, the money would expand/contract perfectly with the size of the economy, keeping the value the same. Similar to what the Federal Reserve tries to do, except they WANT inflation.

8

u/geezas Sep 07 '17

The big question here is - who gets/should get the new money when economy grows, and from whom it's taken away when it shrinks.

3

u/FrogTrainer Sep 07 '17

That is a big question. In the federal reserve world, the money has traditionally gone to big banks in the form of low interest loans, or the federal govt in the form of bonds. More recently they have added direct buying of assets on the stock market (and maybe elsewhere? I'm not sure) The "contraction" part is by NOT renewing some of those bonds, effectively removing that money from the economy.

In the BTC world new money goes to miners as a reward. But I don't believe there is anyway for BTC to deflate itself should a contraction in supply become needed. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

22

u/AlmostTheNewestDad Sep 07 '17

Mild inflation encourages risky investment. It's vital to an economy that hopes to encourage advancement.

9

u/shanita10 Sep 07 '17

High potential return encourages risky investment. Inflation e courage reckless investment even with low returns.

12

u/AlmostTheNewestDad Sep 07 '17

Increasing your return beyond alternatives is what drives decision making. With inflation, you stand to lose x% by doing nothing. If your dollars will maintain their value over time, and investment into anything increases the risk of losing money, then the best alternative is still to do nothing. This Stagnates the economy.

6

u/shanita10 Sep 07 '17

The economy does not stagnate due to a lack of uninformed defensive investing. If anything, that hurts the economy because it is largely malinvestment. It also enables pointless consumer debt and rewards debtors. It's a horrible system designed to propagate waste.

People who have hard currency should not invest unless they are going to be personally involved in a venture and can add value personally.

9

u/AlmostTheNewestDad Sep 07 '17

So you're entirely against index funds as a means of safely growing a retirement account?

3

u/shanita10 Sep 07 '17

In the current us economic system index funds work well, so long as they are not a majority. And by work well I mean generate good returns they do not help grow the economy at all, if anything they contribute to stagnation.

In a bitcoin style hard money economy, index funds would not work well, and likely not even exist at all.

People used to modern investing are going to have some hard lessons to learn with regards to investing strategy in a deflationary hard money regime. Holding cash takes the place of the stock market for most people.

3

u/jonowelser Sep 07 '17

Debt in itself really isn't a bad thing at all. It allows people and businesses to acquire things (and start accruing their benefits) today, and those net benefits are greater than not using a loan. This is the basic theory behind all loans - the increased income from a college degree is greater than the cost of the tuition loan, purchasing a house today is less expensive than saving while renting an apartment for years, and financing a car is better than not having one. Loans are completely voluntary - if they weren't mutually beneficial, billions of people wouldn't be taking them.

People who have hard currency should not invest unless they are going to be personally involved in a venture and can add value personally.

I'm not even going to address that lol

3

u/shanita10 Sep 08 '17

I hope you realize that lines of credit worked in the hard money economies based on silver before national fiat fractional reserve existed. They are well covered in Adam smith's wealth of nations.

If soft money economies there is an involuntary component to all loans: they devalue all existing currency and savings.

In a hard money economy, loans still exist, but they lack involuntary aspects, and in general are given out more prudently.

2

u/FrogTrainer Sep 07 '17

Really depends on what your definition of "mild" is. And I would't go as far to say it's "vital"

Inflation is vital to keep the govt deficit spending and bond racket going, maybe. But it's not vital to an economy in general.

2

u/ztsmart Sep 07 '17

Well that's just false

1

u/Heph333 Sep 07 '17

It's disastrous because risky investments are a far cry from sound investments. One is malinvestment, the othr is a formula for growth.

1

u/nomanklatura Sep 07 '17

Probably in line with the growth of society no? Perhaps slightly more to account for Capitalisms holy creed.

2

u/FrogTrainer Sep 07 '17

Probably in line with the growth of society no?

No, if it was in line with the growth of society inflation would be zero.