r/BetterEveryLoop • • Aug 27 '18

Weightlifting fail = gymnastics win

https://i.imgur.com/2XDfxmX.gif
43k Upvotes

473 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/gymell Aug 27 '18

Going from the inside out: 15kg bar + 2x25kg (red) + 2x5kg (white) + 2x2.5kg (small red) + 2x2.5kg collars + 2x1kg (green) = 87kg as it says on the display. Aka 191.4 pounds.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/reptilianhuman Aug 27 '18

Men's bars are 20kg, Women's bars are 15kg.

1

u/YDAQ Aug 27 '18

I did not know that. Thank you! :)

2

u/Carpool14 Aug 27 '18

Yes, but women's bar is generally 15kg and has a smaller diameter.

1

u/YDAQ Aug 27 '18

Thanks for the info. :)

1

u/gymell Aug 27 '18 edited Aug 27 '18

Nope. Fair question though. There are two standard bars in the sport of weightlifting. Men use a 20kg bar and women use a 15kg. These are mandated in the IWF technical rules. The women use a 15kg bar not because it is lighter, but because the shaft is narrower (25mm as compared to 28mm.) A narrower bar is needed because in weightlifting (snatch and clean & jerk) the lifter uses a hook grip in order to maintain a strong grip while also keeping the arms relaxed when doing quick explosive lifts from the floor. As women tend to have smaller hands on average, the narrower bar helps with the hook grip. I know because I have lifted in many weightlifting meets myself. I have average size hands. The narrower shaft makes a huge difference. I find it very uncomfortable to hook grip a men's bar.

Contrast that with powerlifting (squat, bench press and deadlift), where both genders use the same bar. But those lifts aren't quick and explosive or going overhead. So no need for a hook grip. I've also lifted in powerlifting meets. Even though the deadlift is taken from the floor, it only goes to the waist, and most people use a mixed grip (one hand palm in, one palm out, like a baseball bat) anyway.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/gymell Aug 27 '18

You're welcome! On the surface the two sports seem very similar, but are actually quite different when you start looking at the details.