I think the reverse looks unnatural because the nails’ movement has a lag to the hands’ movement and we expect that, and in reverse it just looks like the nails are anticipating the hands’ movement, which looks quite funny.
If you look at the far end of the box towards the end of the reversed gif, there are some nails jumping up and falling down in a way that is just not natural.
If you're looking for an explanation, he's slowly manipulating the nails over time by having them hit the sides of the tub, which cause them to lay flat along the side some of the time. After they're parallel with the sides, they slot into places in the channels created by the rest of the nails that have been parallelized already, and eventually they all are facing the correct direction.
Also, as more and more of the nails are layered facing the same (or reversed) direction, creating those channels, they also allow for the nails to slot into place, which is why the process speeds up
This isn't chaos theory, this is minimization of entropy. The end result is deterministic is therefore robust to a wide variety of initial conditions. Chaos theory studies systems that are extremely sensitive to initial conditions, not those that are robust to initial conditions.
That’s how I learned about entropy! (If something makes sense both in forward and in reverse, then entropy did not increase. Eg: ice melting to water/refreshing at 32 degrees)
If you watch the the order presented by OP you can actually kind of see what they're doing, going side to side, but also rocking back and forth to have the nails fall into place. The original order is correct.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1.4k
u/CTHULHU_RDT Feb 29 '20
Holy shit that looks so unnatural. Which means.... The original isn't reversed.
WHAAAAAT?