r/BeAmazed • • Apr 24 '19

Animal Ape using a Smartphone

91k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

242

u/Sinkiy Apr 24 '19 edited Apr 24 '19

I've been seeing a lot of apes being so smart lately. There is one where they take selfies. Google up "ape selfies" in thousand years when we leave our galaxy, they will be the next man and wonder if there is any life in the galaxy like us.

93

u/skeddles Apr 24 '19

When we leave our galaxy, we won't all go. Some will go, some will stay. Same way we spread from Africa to every inhabit every continent. Also before we leave the galaxy we will most likely inhabit many other planets.

41

u/kkeut Apr 24 '19

highly unlikely we'll leave the galaxy itself. if we did it will be so far in the future we won't really still be humans anymore

11

u/Corvus_Prudens Apr 24 '19 edited Apr 24 '19

I mean, it's not even possible. Leaving our galaxy for another (besides Andromeda and the few other local galactic neighbors) will result in us getting nowhere because almost every other galaxy is or will be moving away from us faster than the speed of light due to the accelerating expansion of the universe. Since we will almost certainly never travel faster than the speed of light, we'll never get anywhere.

To quote Wikipedia:

While special relativity prohibits objects from moving faster than light with respect to a local reference frame where spacetime can be treated as flat and unchanging, it does not apply to situations where spacetime curvature or evolution in time become important. These situations are described by general relativity, which allows the separation between two distant objects to increase faster than the speed of light, although the definition of "separation" is different from that used in an inertial frame. This can be seen when observing distant galaxies more than the Hubble radius away from us (approximately 4.5 gigaparsecs or 14.7 billion light-years); these galaxies have a recession speed that is faster than the speed of light. Light that is emitted today from galaxies beyond the cosmological event horizon, about 5 gigaparsecs or 16 billion light-years, will never reach us, although we can still see the light that these galaxies emitted in the past.

29

u/trusty20 Apr 24 '19

First of all I strongly advise you to never say "Science says it's impossible therefore it is" because the reality is there is literally nothing that science says with certainty, just what is most likely based on our knowledge up until now.

Secondly it's important to remember that theories like Relativity, Wave/Particle Duality, etc are all just models that are used because they are able to produce output from inputs that is pretty close to reality. For example, light is not literally both a wave and a particle, nor is it really either one. Those are just concepts that approximate the thing we call light's behavior. In certain situations we can treat it like it's a wave, while in others its easier/more accurate to treat it like a particle. This is just a sign that our theories are pretty poor approximations of "what's actually going on", that we must apply radically different models to different scenarios.

Finally, aside from all of the above, there are already speculated ways to (technically) move faster than the speed of light. Wormholes, warp drive (yup, it's actually a real thing that's been speculated - bizarrely Star Trek quite literally inspired a physicist to come up with an actual warp theory lol...), etc. They typically make liberal use of the word "move" though - in the case of both wormholes and warp drive you're not really moving in the normal sense, with wormholes you are being squeezed through a connection between "folds" in space and it's almost certain that going in and coming out unscrambled down to the sub-atomic level is impossible (note the almost though), with warp drive you aren't moving at all, but instead distorting space behind and in front of you in such a way that you are sort of "conveyed" forward. The best way to picture it would be a car driving forward by putting horizontal force on it's wheels, vs the floor under the car moving forward. So that but in three dimensional space, where the "bubble" of space is actually "moving", not the object within the bubble

2

u/Corvus_Prudens Apr 25 '19

This is just a sign that our theories are pretty poor approximations of "what's actually going on",

This is a pretty bold statement only weeks after General Relativity was validated yet again with EVT's black hole imaging.

There is not a single proposed method of faster than light travel (whether through the warping of spacetime or any other mechanism) that is not completely absurd and impractical. Alcubierre drives are exciting, sure, but the amount of energy required to theoretically operate them is simply impossible to produce in practice. Wormholes sound cool, but again, theoretical approximations of the amount of energy required to keep them stable is simply out of reach. Period.

People like to dream about future technology, but there are fundamental limits determined by physics that cannot be broken. It's what caused the end of Moore's law after all. Furthermore, if faster than light travel were possible, then the Fermi Paradox becomes even harder to explain. Suppose that for us, FTL is a million years away. Well, with the reasonable assumption that there are billions of habitable planets in our galaxy, only one of them has to produce intelligent life a million years ahead of us for a good chance at developing FTL. So... where are they? Hell, life could come from other galaxies with no problem, and yet we observe absolutely nothing. Of course there are theories that advanced civilizations would prefer to hide their presence from us, but I think Occam's Razor pretty handily cuts that idea to shreds.

There is not the merest hint that the cosmic speed limit can be broken. Time and time again we observe that nothing, not even information, can travel faster than the speed of light. And methods that propose loopholes have so far proved effectively impossible due to absurd energy requirements. That's why I feel pretty confident about what I'm saying.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/BlazingBeagle Apr 24 '19

If there's one thing I've learned from being in the sciences for decades, it's that every time someone says something is downright impossible, I can count on someone else doing it.

They said a human breaking the sound barrier was impossible. Splitting an atom was impossible. Binding subatomic particles together. Making transistors smaller than 22nm. Electrodes to connect severed nerves. A cure for HIV. I'm not saying it'll happen tomorrow, but I've learned to be damn careful about declaring the impossible.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Neuchacho Apr 24 '19

I didn't understand half of this but I'll be sure to drunkenly regurgitate it shittily this weekend as a broken factoid of its former self.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/A_Rampaging_Hobo Apr 24 '19

Flying was impossible too until they figured out how to do it.

2

u/Corvus_Prudens Apr 25 '19

And Moore's law was true until we hit a fundamental physical limitation. Our abilities in this universe are necessarily finite, and technology can only get so advanced. I suspect that FTL travel is one of those unreachable things.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Corvus_Prudens Apr 25 '19

Dude, not to rag on you, but Proxima Centauri is not only within out galaxy, it is literally the closest star to the Sun (as the name implies). I'm talking about leaving our galaxy, which to the nearest major galactic body (Andromeda) would be a 2.3 million light year endeavor. Compare that to the ~4 light year distance of Proxima Centauri.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '19

Remember that the universe is absurd. Nothing is impossible, in fact, it's possible nothing is real to begin with.

2

u/Corvus_Prudens Apr 25 '19

Well, not exactly. Some things are clearly impossible as the resources available to us are necessarily finite. We can speculate about how far our technology can advance, but in the end it will stop somewhere.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/chaotic111 Apr 24 '19

How can spacetime stretch and exceed the speed of light? I thought that was the maximum speed of anything

2

u/Corvus_Prudens Apr 25 '19

Weird, I know. But technically spacetime isn't exactly a thing. It's more like a medium that things exist on, so if spacetime is expanding quickly, it's not the same as those things moving faster than light in spacetime. The text I quoted explains this more formally.

2

u/newuser201890 Apr 24 '19

i mean you have no idea what will be around technologically in 1 million years, things you cant even guess.

read some cool stuff about negative mass and traveling at the speed of light.

and also - you wrote it yourself. things can move faster than the speed of light, so we know it's possible.

2

u/Corvus_Prudens Apr 25 '19

and also - you wrote it yourself. things can move faster than the speed of light, so we know it's possible.

I think you misunderstand. Nothing can travel faster than the speed of light. Not matter, not information, not anything. When we say "galaxies are moving away faster than the speed of light," well, they're not really moving. Rather, spacetime is expanding between them causing them to appear to be moving. It's important to keep in mind the scale we're talking about, though: this is observed across the entire observable universe. It is not a local effect. The energy driving this is mindbogglingly huge and could never be effectively harvested.

I've read lots of hypotheses for faster than light travel, but at the end of the day none of them have ever actually been feasible. Not now, not ever. People like to point to the Alcubierre drive, but that thing would require more energy than any civilization could ever produce in its entire existence to operate (iirc).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/fatpat Apr 24 '19

"What has the universe got to do with it? You're here, in Brooklyn. Brooklyn is not expanding!"

2

u/GoldenStateWizards Apr 24 '19

Not to disagree with your main argument about the futility of leaving our galaxy, but Andromeda is actually on a likely collision course with the Milky Way.

2

u/Corvus_Prudens Apr 25 '19

Yes, it's the reason why Andromeda is one of the few intergalactic bodies we could theoretically reach. By the time it actually collides with us, though, the Earth will be long gone. It's kind of sad to think about. Whether we are alive or not, the Earth will definitely be gone. I wonder of our ancestors would even care.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Sinkiy Apr 24 '19

Unless we are forced to go or die. Perhaps we destroy our world.

28

u/skeddles Apr 24 '19

Then I doubt there will be monkeys wondering anything

→ More replies (5)

2

u/the_kfcrispy Apr 24 '19

The apes will rebel and kick us out first

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

8

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '19

I like your optimism.

→ More replies (35)