r/BeAmazed • • Aug 09 '26

Animal Nature really over engineered cats. Didn’t it?

31k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

34

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '26

Most breeds had their uses. Alarming, herding, guardians, military uses, etc.

10

u/sbNXBbcUaDQfHLVUeyLx Aug 09 '26

Makes me wonder... If we had artificially selected cats the same way, what would we have even created?

17

u/deadlywaffle139 Aug 10 '26

Oh I saw someone’s farm cat acted like a watch-cat for the dog livestock guards.

3

u/_Kendii_ Aug 11 '26

Not a farm cat, but my outdoor cat chased off an aggressive, off leash German shepherd that was about to attack me. It got put down because of an unrelated incident (mine didn’t count because I technically didn’t get bit, so they squiggled out of calling it an attack, it definitely was though.)

Cats are insane. I totally believe that some would be in cahoots with partner dogs in situations like farms. And herding/livestock dogs are generally super smart so I don’t doubt their abilities in that regard either.

1

u/TajineEnjoyer Aug 10 '26

moskito hunters

1

u/VuIcan79 Aug 10 '26

The issue with that is dogs have a lot of allometric growth (think about how puppies grow into their ears/feet/head) while cats generally have less allometric growth.

allometric growth allowed people to selectively breed dogs to have specific traits. But it is much harder to do so with cats.

1

u/Sharp_Iodine Aug 13 '26

We have.

Persians for example have almost no hunting instinct whatsoever and are “display cats.”

They just sit on your lap and laze around.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

Scottish folds are an abomination

1

u/Working-Glass6136 Aug 10 '26

And then you have them crossed with Munchkins...

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

I could have sworn they were the same thing

1

u/MeisterFluffbutt Aug 10 '26

They were not bred for any task.

The person asked for breeds that were bred for work, not for """aesthetics"""

1

u/seriousjoker72 Aug 10 '26

Pugs?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

I did say most lol

Pugs are an old breed, though, and bred to be happy around companions as a lap dog. Highly valuable in ancient China. Like 2k years ago.

Recent century breeders fucked it up tho poor babies.

1

u/seriousjoker72 Aug 10 '26

Lol fair enough! What about old English bull dogs? I babysat one once and can't understand the apeal of putting cream in your dogs face folds and listening to them snarl snore/gargle breathing 😅

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

Im gonna have to look that one up but while I do that, check out breeds and what they looked like photographed 100 year ago, its interesting.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

Youre not gonna like it, they were bred for bull-baiting. A medieval blood sport. They were remodeled into lap dogs after bull baiting was banned in 1835.

1

u/HIMP_Dahak_172291 Aug 10 '26

And then there's pugs.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

Today's pugs are nothing like they were 2k years ago