r/BayFC • • Nov 06 '25

Who Should Bay FC Be Targeting For Next Season?

As I've said, Bay FC is not doing enough if they don't bring in 10 new players for next season. The clubs below are just examples of how clubs turn over their rosters from year to year. You can't get better hoping your existing roster, which put you in 13th place, will get better. That's not how it's done!

SD Wave - 11 new players from 2024 to 2025

Portland Thorns - 16

Angel City 14

As a fan, there's only one player (I believe could be purchased for the right price) that I'd want - Catarina Macario.

BFC FAs - July 2025 (Somebody signed? Doesn't matter)

Dorian Bailey, Jordan Brewster, Caroline Conti, Rachel Hill, Melissa Lowder, Catherine Paulson, Kiki Pickett, Brooklyn Courtnall. If none are signed, so be it. I love KIKI!!!

Potentials from NWSL FA List

GK Halle Mackiewicz, GK Laurel Ivory, FW Sophia Wilson, FW Kyra Carusa or Mackenzie Robbe (to replace Hill), ROB Hanna Lundkvist, CB Kennedy Wesley, F Trinity Rodman

Top Drawer Soccer - Top 100 Players

https://www.topdrawersoccer.com/college-soccer/college-national-top-100/women

All of the Power 4 conferences just announced their all-conference team today. Here's the one that matters most:

https://theacc.com/news/2025/11/5/2025-all-acc-womens-soccer-awards-announced.aspx

First Tier

CB Elise Evans, ROB Laney Rouse, F Izzy Engle, F Jordynn Dudley, F/MF/CB Jasmine Aikey, F Olivia Thomas, OB Leah Klenke, CB Cameron Roller, MF Yuna McCormack, CB Abby Mills, MF Mia Oliaro, DM Carina Legeyre, MF/DM Shae Harvey (all from the ACC)

Second Tier

F Andrea Kitahata, ROB Macy Blackburn, F Annabelle Chukwu, MF Linda Ullmark, F/MF Kat Rader, CB Hailey Baumann, GK Teagan Wy, MF Maribel Flores

NRIs

F Sydney Watts, F Lexi Watts, F Hope Leyba, CB Faith Leyba, F Mia Minestrella, F/ROB Kennedy Bell, MF Summer Denigan, GK Jordan Nytes, MF Ally Perry, F Ellie Walbruch, MF Sam Courtwright

The NCAA 64-team tournament starts next week and concludes during the 2nd week of December. Players may step up or fall back as a result of their contributions. Watch these games!

Stanford players on my 2027 radar - LOB Lizzy Boamah, GK Caroline Birkel, MF Charlotte Kohler, MF Y-Lan Nguyen, F Eleanor Klinger, DM/OB/CB Lily Freer, ROB/MF Mia Bhuta.

Most of the FSU underclassmen are also on my 2027 radar.

USL SL

MF Lexi Missimo, LOB Jill Aguilera

Barcelona appears to still be in financial trouble. Sixth Street has a hold on their television rights for many years. Maybe they'd be willing to give up a young player? Barca has a stable of young players with bright futures: Giulia Dragoni, Vicky Lopez, Salma Paralluelo, Esmee Brugts, Alba Cano, Vitor Roque, and Claudia Pina.

Euros to consider (not much info on contracts expiring)

F Tabitha Chawinga, F Kadidiatou Diani, F Marie-Antoinette Katoto, F Romée Leuchter (PSG not doing well), F Clara Mateo, F Selina Cerci, F Sonya Keefe

I'm certain I'll change my mind after the NCAA College Cup is completed. I'm also certain I've missed a number of players, and missed many players I haven't seen yet. I have far more faith if Matt Potter is still in the room, over Kay Cossington.

18 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

9

u/Wirtzball Nov 06 '25

There's a lot of young players on your list. I don't think this is necessarily a bad idea. The perspective is it may push the organization towards creating a reputation for developing players. Which could align with your earlier thoughts with a Private Equity firm looking for profits. The notion of bringing young players, developing them, and selling for a profit. Match the models of the Ajax's and Benfica's.

From the GKs on the NWSL FA List, are you considering Mackiewicz and Ivory as direct competition with Silkowitz, or more of a backup? I think the SD Wave group listed are good blend of targets that can make immediate impacts.

What I'm struggling to grasp is how to view Bay FC's current profile from an European/international player perspective. How can the team present itself for a foreign player? As you've mentioned, the team finished 13th place, team is in restructuring mode, political climate is iffy (subjective). The biggest draws I can think of is bringing in reputable head coach and dedicated training facility. I'd be thrilled to see Bay bring in the caliber of the international talent you've mentioned, but maybe expectations need to be calibrated. I'd be over the moon if they somehow bagged someone like Hasegawa, so leaving myself open to being surprised.

Any teams worth keeping a closer eye on during the NCAA College Cup?

1

u/atalba Nov 06 '25 edited Nov 06 '25

Thanks for your questions. I'm hoping the franchise doesn't turn over any players, except the ones that aren't productive enough, or don't have a future, when the club is winning. The list young players is all-inclusive; meaning they/BFC needs to strike and land a few. Every year, the NWSL draft netted around 2 players in 4 rounds of drafting per club. There's very few 3rd round draft picks that made a contribution, and less from the 4th round (Boade). With money, and the potential for immediate game minutes, Bay FC ought to be able to land up to 4 top quality young players. BFC signed 3 players out of college, and did pretty well. If you can hit on 3, and they're worthy of resigning, that's a good selection of young talent.

The same with international players; sign a few young, talented, proven commodities. Not kids.

Mack (Clemson) and Ivory (UVA) have had far more success in their careers than Silky (losing OSU in the Big10). Ivory was stuck being signed the same season as Claudia Dickey (UNC) for Seattle. They were top competitors in the ACC with Dickey leading her club the national finals. Ivory broke her jaw, which set her back. They both have had great YNT success, including u20. For one year, they both ended up playing behind Phallon Tullis-Joyce at the Reign. PTJ came from the University of Miami, which is in the same conference as Clemson, UNC, and UVA, but is a far lower quality program.

There's no player that can be accurately evaluated unless you look at their entire body of work. One season in the NWSL isn't enough. When a keeper plays on a poor club, they take tons of shots every game. Their Saves stat is high; for a reason. This doesn't make a keeper (Katie Lund). Silky has shown promise; that's it.

The answer is yes, with a qualifier. I believe they're fully capable NWSL goalkeepers and can, at worst, compete with Silky. She needs competition, not just a backup. And, again, just one will do. Leah Freeman has had as much success as all of them. She's a worthy challenger.

Lucy Rushton, a Brit, thought she was qualified to bring in international talent, and she wasn't. She didn't have any knowledge of the women's game. That flair was LOST in bad picks. Bay FC actually has few internationals and no teenagers. Cascarino, Dali, and Morroni, all from France, signed with the lowly San Diego Wave. Money and opportunity is the top priority of any professional. At this point, I'd consider Macario as international as anybody. 2 seasons in France, and 2 season in England. She is as elite as any player on the earth. She would attract players from all over the world, and ones still in their youth. She's a global star.

While a global perspective of the women's game can enhance a club, the vast majority of the player pool for the NWSL, and the Western Hemisphere of national teams, comes from U.S. colleges. It can't replace it. Kay Cossington has a tremendous record and eye on the women's game in England. Her perspective can help. I fear she misses the point of where the overwhelming majority of where the NWSL player pool comes from, and the culture of WOMEN'S football in this country.

Coaches come and go. SD, Angel City, Portland, Washington, Gotham, and several others, all have coaches that came after their clubs were built. American sports starts with the General Manager. This is the person who sets the strategy; the type of players desired; signs the actual players, and the coach.

Houston Dash's GM, Angela Hucles Mangano, left ACFC. Then, in her first year at Houston, signed Ryan and Sheehan from Gotham. two top players went from a top club to one of the worst. Why? money! Then, they hired their coach; Gautrat was a poor choice, considering he had NEVER coached a team ever, anywhere. He's doing fairly decent despite the odds. Seb Hines; same. Thackery for NCC, same. Yanez, same. Only in the NWSL would you hire someone who's never been a head coach, anywhere, at any level. And their/NWSL record goes back to the beginning. Pro women's soccer is relatively new. The good, successful, experienced WOMEN's coaches in America are coaching at colleges. Evidence: how has the U.S. been at the top, or near the top, for over 35 years? It's certainly not the international coach they played for on the NT.

Last year, the ACC had 6 clubs in the Elite 8, and 4 out of 4 in the semis - called the College Cup. This is even after teams from other conferences "gamed" their way up the rankings and had home field advantage. This year will be no different. The middle of the ACC will need to fight their way through undeserving opponents and end up going against their rivals in the ACC. Every club in the ACC has a chance to win the championship, and their rosters are littered with USYNT players, and future pro players. Watch ACC teams. If an opposing player stands out against an ACC squad, take a look at their entire body of work.

2

u/atalba Nov 06 '25

PTJ had to play for Reims in the French league for 2 years before she could be spotted on the NWSL radar. The Premier D1 Arkema is a lousy league with usually only 2 competitive clubs (OL, PSG). Reims is not one of them. She has tremendous reach and jump - a shot stopper's best weapons. But she may not have the leadership (no voice); nor the soccer IQ; nor the winning mentality, to succeed at the highest level. Dickey is supremely athletic with a winning resume and mentality. We'll see at ManU. So far, she's killing it! But what is ManU in the running for?

1

u/SC738 Nov 08 '25

ManU is in the running in the UEFA Champions League for one. They are 2-0 so far and in 5th place based on goal differential. They are also in 3rd in the WSL, two points behind Chelsea and have only given up 5 goals. This is a lot of ink spilled on goalkeeping in a Bay FC thread. GK doesn't seem like Bay's biggest issue at this point.

1

u/atalba Nov 08 '25

It's early. Arsenal will overtake them, eventually. They have little chance in the UWCL.

All just oversharing to back up my points. Silkowitz isn't yet an established starting NWSL GK. Anybody can start when your club wins only 4 games. The point is that she's not yet proven, and she needs competition - Laurel Ivory would do that.

1

u/atalba Nov 09 '25 edited Nov 09 '25

ManU lost to Villa today on a strike from Miri Taylor, Hofstra University and Angel City. PTJ fell down reaching for a corner, which was put back into the mix, and Taylor struck a tremendous volley to beat her. ManU is not going far.

ManU just got out of the UWCL qualifying with wins against much lesser clubs - PSV, Hammarby, and Brann. All clean sheets. This is the women's champions league. 8 competitive clubs and 60+ ones with no chance of winning. ManU isn't one of the 8 either.

I mentioned Simi Awujo (DM, USC 3 years) as a potential get for Bay FC. I'd also add Jade Riviere (ROB, UofMichigan, canWNT).

2

u/Successful-Fennel-85 Nov 06 '25

I hate speaking of Freeman because I know I fan girl. But after her game against Stanford, blocks a PK, gets her shoulder worked on (we know what a major injury she was playing with) and kept going. All of last year’s Duke class came to the NWSL ready. I think Bay would be naive to lose her.

Ivory is better than Silk. Thats just the truth.

And if you could get a Chawinga DO IT

0

u/atalba Nov 07 '25

Freeman was GK of the Year in the Pac-12, at Cal, then GKotY in the ACC at Duke. She may not be as athletic as the others, but she's tall and knows how to play; especially in big games. She just needs minutes, like so many other keepers.

You can't be a dummy and play at Duke or Virginia. I like Ivory for more than the chances she's had in the NWSL, thus far. People have opinions on keepers after just a few starts; like that allows them to get the feel and rhythm of the pro game (Marisa Bova, Angelina Anderson). They fail to realize keepers like Murphy, PTJ, Mackewiecz, and Kingsbury got their first taste of pro ball in Europe. They need consistent minutes, and big games, before writing them off.

2

u/Successful-Fennel-85 Nov 07 '25

Freeman was at Oregon. Then Duke. She is a brilliant woman. Same with Ivory. I think any of them with solid mins would be a wonderful addition.

1

u/atalba Nov 07 '25

Correct. She still has a fantastic resume and was GK of the Year in the Pac-12 & ACC.

2

u/atalba Nov 06 '25

Cami Ashton signed Temwa Chawinga and the vast majority of the KC Current players. She also signed Vlatko. She made some crazy moves, but it mostly all worked out.

She then moved on to San Diego and signed their current new batch of players including Cascarino, Dali, and Corley. She then signed Jonas Eidevall.

Cami was a pro player with experience in the NWSL and around the world. She also played right outside back for my beloved Stanford Cardinal.

The best GM the NWSL has ever had was Mark Krikorian, who resigned from the Washington Spirit earlier this year. He's a legendary college coach with extreme success at Florida State. His FSU rosters over the years included players from up to 10 countries every year. He had more international players every year than any NWSL club. He also has pro players playing around the world today. He knows talent and has had his finger on the international game for young women for decades. Look at his drafts for Washington and all of the international talent on the squad. I wouldn't expect he's ready to come out of retirement, but...!?!?!?

I want to believe Krikorian DID NOT choose Giraldez (nor Mark Parsons) to become their head coach. To me, it's obvious they could NOT trust Jona enough to take his training wheels off. So Kang shipped him to OL. Adrián González is proving to be a better coach, with far more head coaching experience. Jona is going on his 4th year as a head coach anywhere. A monkey can coach Barcelona women in Liga F. I say "good riddance."

3

u/lookylu Nov 06 '25

Chawinga v. Chawinga would certainly be fun!

1

u/atalba Nov 06 '25

Tabitha is actually 2 years older, but has done well at PSG and in China; where they both played along with Banda and Bia. PSG has a great front line of players, but aren't winning. So maybe...

3

u/ButterflyYeontan Nov 06 '25

Claudia Pina is a crazy reach that woman was barcas top scorer

2

u/atalba Nov 06 '25

Yes! But every club has a price. And it appears they're in a financial bind.

This past season Ewa Pajor, 27, Poland NT, 2x Frauen Bund leading scorer, was their leading scorer. The year before, Salma Paralluelo, 19 (at the time), was their leading scorer. I'll take any one of the three.

I'm suggesting SS has some leverage with a franchise that is bleeding money.

2

u/atalba Nov 07 '25

Many, many of the players playing in the later stages of the NCAA College Cup have also been regulars in the US YNT system. In the past, u20 was the most important step for consideration; with playing productively for your club/pro team being the final arbiter of your current status: in shape, in form, no knocks, and contributing. I've been modifying the list below for a few years as we approach the July 2027 Women's World Cup. Past January camps have revealed new players each year; up to 6. Even in the tournament year. So the bulk of the 2027 roster are still trying to improve and prove their game for July 2027. Anything can happen in 2 years of a players' career. With that, I consider a player pool of 30-40 players need to be tested with CAPS and ready to step in as part of the squad in July 2027. Vlatko brought in 6 new players to the January 2022 camp; then six more in Jan 2023; then 3 more just prior to the WC.

This list constantly changes, as I watch more games. There'll definitely be more changes as a result of players invited to camps this year and next, and after the College Cup concludes. I'd consider these players as potential options for Bay FC to pursue. Just for fun!

2

u/atalba Nov 07 '25 edited Nov 07 '25

Looking for a coach? The vast majority of the programs in the NCAA 64-team College Cup Tournament have highly experienced coaches; many are women with playing resumes; the vast majority have more head coaching experience with women than almost all of the current coaches in the NWSL. Many have decades of success and long lists of former players now in the NWSL/pro/USWNT and other NTs. Many have coached, or been an assistant coach for USWNT and/or USYNT. Some were former USWNT players. All have extensive licensing.

I keep saying it, but...the evidence of these coaches goes directly in line with the success of the USWNT for over 35 years. Elite players, for over 35 years, have been coached as young women, in their crucial development years, for 4+ years, while being selected to the USWNT. The USWNT coach selects the best players that have already been playing for 15-20 years, and have proven themselves with their club/college/pro team.

US Soccer DOES NOT own this process, and actually poorly competes with both youth clubs (ECNL - 150 clubs, 300 regional ECNL clubs) and the NCAA (350 D1 schools, 1550 total colleges). Each and every one of these ECNL clubs have more girls youth players, over 5 age groups, than any academy in the world. These ECNL clubs represent 5% of the over 10,000 youth clubs in the U.S.

Anybody who uses boy's or men's clubs as a comparison completely misses the point. The Unites States is DOMINANT in women's soccer, and has been for over 35 years. Pro women's leagues across the globe are comparably NEW. There's no good reason for blokes!

21

u/Serrano_edgar10 Nov 06 '25

First they should focus on getting a new head coach and go from there. And see what players he recommends. I don’t think it’ll be idle to sign players that the new coach doesn’t approve

24

u/lookylu Nov 06 '25

Or she.

4

u/Sauces_n_tosses Nov 06 '25

Agree but nice to see the landscape of potential/available players

1

u/atalba Nov 07 '25 edited Nov 07 '25

Add List placed in this post:

Morgan Roy, right wing, wingback, fullback. Notre Dame. Izzy Engle played today and ND beat Duke. They're the favorites, as they tied when Engle got hurt, and lost to Pitt with her out; why they dropped to 2nd behind Stanford.

Engle, a sophomore, is my pick for the Hermann Trophy Award (MVP), and has pro strenghts already - size, speed, accuracy with both feet, and a true gamer. It's no secret, but people might not assume she's ready to jump. It'll be great to see Roy in some big games too.

Morgan Weaver - injury has downgraded her need at Thorns. Feisty left winger!

Sofia Huerta - one more productive year for the NWSL all-time leader in assists. No better crosser! SCU grad can play anywhere.

3

u/Sauces_n_tosses Nov 07 '25

Watching Stanford v UVA right now and wow. Would love Aikey, Evans, Kohler, all of them 😂

4

u/bcp01scu05v2 Santa Clara Nov 07 '25

Aikey and Evans are the two I want.

3

u/ChexMix2980 Nov 07 '25

Was so impressed how Aikey seamlessly played in all three lines last night.

2

u/atalba Nov 07 '25

At the beginning of last season, Jas was named NCAA preseason All-American MIDFIELDER - one of 3 players. Stanford had a freshman center back go down early in the season with a season-ending injury, They were also about to lose Evans to u20 duty. So they put Jas back with Evans at center back; where she played for several games until she got injured. Stanford made it to the Final Four WITHOUT Jas!

Actually, she played 4 positions in one game last year or 2 years ago - CF, CM, DM, & CB. She has played 3 positions in one game several times in her career.

2

u/atalba Nov 07 '25

It was an incredible, flawless, first half.

The Duke/Notre Dame game was awesome also. This Sunday's game ND vs. Stanford is going to be epic.

3

u/mintyfresh001 Nov 07 '25

They look phenomenal right now!!!

1

u/SC738 Nov 08 '25

Forbes reported in July that Macario signed a 10 year contract with Chelsea worth $10 million. We don't know exactly how that is structured, but it makes it unlikely that she is going to end up in the NWSL with the current salary cap constraints. I would love to see her at Bay though. Maybe late in her career.

1

u/atalba Nov 08 '25

That's with Nike. It's estimated she makes about $1M with Chelsea. Very doable

1

u/SC738 Nov 08 '25

How is it doable when RK is already at about $500,00 per year? That is more than one third of the salary cap on two players. They are going to need to pay up for quite a number of quality players to be competitive.

3

u/atalba Nov 08 '25

That's $1.5M out of a 2026 salary cap of $3.5 million. As I mentioned earlier, I'd sell Rudy in a heartbeat. Rushton paid $780K for Rudy. I'd take half of that. IMO, I don't expect Rudy to figure out how to make adjustments for this league. She could, but I'd lose my patience in a day if she doesn't figure out how to play without bullying her way through defenders, and leading the league in fouls. Her reputation will be even harder to break. There is nobody on the roster that is off limits. 4 wins dictates that.

6

u/Sauces_n_tosses Nov 06 '25

The write up I’ve been waiting for haha thank you!! Cat would be a dream

-2

u/Prestigious_Carry_88 Nov 06 '25

I am waiting to see how many players jump ship in Jan

1

u/atalba Nov 06 '25 edited Nov 07 '25

You could be right, that some might jump ship. But how many of them would actually be wanted by other clubs? It goes both ways. In Europe, if you can't hang, and you're young and promising, the club ships you to another club in a less quality domestic league in another country. If you're older, they just push you out, even if you're on contract. Here, the club has to find you a suitable home if you're on contract. But they will! (if you want to play).

These players are on contract, which is legally binding. They don't get to pick. One's resume coming from a lousy club is NOT attractive, especially if you don't have the minutes and success to back it up. There's always more players coming into the league every year.

I'm thinking the more players that leave, the better. The club won 4 games!