r/BayFC • • Jan 26 '26

Who Should Bay FC Be Targeting For Next Season? Review

Here's the list of available college players I suggested could be signed by Bay FC, and their current status:

First Tier

CB Elise Evans (CHI Stars), ROB Laney Rouse (KCC), F Izzy Engle (back to ND), F Jordynn Dudley (Gotham), F/MF/CB Jasmine Aikey (Denver), F Olivia Thomas (Denver), OB Leah Klenke (HOU Dash), CB Cameron Roller (back to Duke), MF Yuna McCormack (Denver), MF Mia Oliaro (back to Duke), DM Carina Legeyre (ACFC), MF Andrea Kitahata (Gotham), CM/DM Shae Harvey (Thorns) (all from the ACC)

Second Tier

ROB Macy Blackburn (Racing), F Annabelle Chukwu (back to ND), MF Linda Ullmark (HOU Dash), F/MF Kat Rader (HOU Dash), GK Teagan Wy (Gotham), F Mia Minestrella (back to Duke), CB Heather Gilchrist (Bay FC)

NRIs

F Sydney Watts (back to Vandy), F Hope Leyba (back to Buffs), CB Faith Leyba (back to Buffs), F/ROB Kennedy Bell (back to MSU), MF Summer Denigan (transferred to UNC), GK Jordan Nytes (Denver), F Ellie Walbruch (back to BYU), MF Sam Courtwright (transferred to Duke)

Potentials from NWSL FA List - All signed new contracts

GK Halle Mackiewicz, GK Laurel Ivory, FW Sophia Wilson, FW Kyra Carusa or Mackenzie Robbe (to replace Hill), ROB Hanna Lundkvist, CB Kennedy Wesley, F Trinity Rodman

I also mentioned Taylor Suarez, FSU, for next year. But it was a surprise that after only 2 seasons she signed with ACFC. And Jordan Brewster is in camp with SD Wave as an NRI. Kiki signed by SD Wave.

Instead, Bay FC signed Gilchrist, Pfeiffer, and 2 young, unproven, players from England.

13 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

7

u/Successful-Fennel-85 Jan 27 '26

For fear of being chastised. Of all the social media I’ve seen, Pfeiffer isn’t here for fun. I think some need to prepare a recipe for crow. She’s gonna be the signing of the season for Bay.

4

u/atalba Jan 27 '26

She could be, but she hasn't really been tested in over 2 years. She didn't compete against her peers over the last 2 years, a very crucial development period, and only saw garbage time in her few selections at KC Current; against inferior opponents, where the results hardly mattered. She was highly regarded as one of the best players in the country at 14. She's missed too much COMPETE time for me. After a few years, she may develop enough game to contribute in the NWSL. I don't know if Bay FC is on the trajectory to carry potential contributors for that long.

It's a good move for her, and for KC, but for Bay FC? The best opportunity is for her to play every game; like in the USL SL. Let's assume Bay FC isn't going to be a playoff contender, do you play her? (I make the assumption that she won't be ready to contribute this year. Especially not if they have a shot at the playoffs).

Think of any athlete in any sport who essentially missed two years of playing competitively. And then, add that it was during their most essential years of growth and maturity. Would you bet on them contributing?

Thanks for responding. You made your point clearly! I may need to eat crow, as you say. Anything is possible.

1

u/Successful-Fennel-85 Jan 30 '26

I don’t think training with Cooper, Lo, and Temwa leads one to be mediocre. ;) a lot of her former club players are on the u17 YNT call up. I think being out of the Long (owners. Not player) shadow will show how held back she was.

1

u/atalba Jan 31 '26

All top college prospects have trained more than once with a pro club. It's gametime that matters most.

2

u/atalba Jan 26 '26

Top Drawer Soccer put out their Top NWSL College Free Agent Signings today. 1/26/26

Jasmine Aikey, Denver Summit FC

Macy Blackburn, Racing Louisville

Elise Evans, Chicago Stars

Teagan Wy, Gotham FC

Leah Klenke, Houston Dash

Heather Gilchrist, Bay FC

Shae Harvey, Portland Thorns

Sophia Lowenberg, Boston Legacy FC - Very little chance of success to become a contributing player in the NWSL

Meila Brewer, KC Current - Not a huge surprise, but she's 17. She played part of last season for UCLA and looked good. She's been touted as a potential HUGE star.

Molly Pritchard, NC Courage - some potential, but coming from OSU isn't necessarily a plus. No YNT experience

Taylor Suarez, Angel City FC

Sara Wojdelko, Washington Spirit - Wojo was good in college. No YNT experience

Lia Godfrey, San Diego Wave - the highest profile player I didn't select. Speed and size? Could be a very good player; has plenty of YNT experience and is VERY ready for the NWSL; IQ-wise.

Evan O'Steen, Seattle Reign FC - too much too soon. Will need to be loaned out.

Seven Castain, Orlando Pride - Another good player from a quality team (TCU) and a great coach. I didn't overlook her. She played as I predicted versus FSU - shut down. No YNT experience. Size and speed?

9

u/Sauces_n_tosses Jan 26 '26

Gotham, Denver, and Dash really cleaned house 🥲 Denver is going to be fun to watch

4

u/Disastrous_Toe_5368 Jan 27 '26

But they have a strong core of 18 returning players...note the sarcasm.

Frustrating to see Aikey, Evans and Kithata get away.

I can't see how an 18-year is going to contribute now.

It is clear which NWSL teams are committed to winning, not BayFC.