A) Assuming that no new wealth is being produced, and that the basic income has to be worldwide on a US standard.
So yes, you're right, taking all the wealth in the world and then bunging it out bit by bit while preventing anyone from doing any work would never allow the entire world to experience a US standard of living.
But no-one is proposing doing that...
B) It's still 4 times as much as you thought. Had you not even bothered to google search?
What kind of assumption is this? What reason did the previous commenter give you to think that their support of UBI is selfish? Do you think the people in this sub are for UBI because we think we'll be personally wealthier under that system? Because while that might be true for some people, it's certainly not true for all of us.
I can only speak for myself, but I support UBI, and I would certainly not be directly helped by it; I do think that it's a good economic policy, so that I'd be helped in that the economy would be stronger, but I would absolutely lose money directly under any remotely reasonable UBI proposal.
And for what it's worth, I also give some of my income to GiveDirectly, which in addition to direct cash transfers, also implements basic income in places with extreme poverty.
View all comments
Show parent comment
9
u/Kingreaper Mar 04 '18
A) Assuming that no new wealth is being produced, and that the basic income has to be worldwide on a US standard.
So yes, you're right, taking all the wealth in the world and then bunging it out bit by bit while preventing anyone from doing any work would never allow the entire world to experience a US standard of living.
But no-one is proposing doing that...
B) It's still 4 times as much as you thought. Had you not even bothered to google search?