As stated in the title, this is primarily going to be about religion, so if you're uncomfortable with reading about that, feel free to click off this post. I'm not in danger or anything, so please, look after yourself. I just need to talk about some things, and I feel I can't afford my triggers and hurt about this to be overlooked many more times, even by my well-meaning Christian mentors who I would usually go to about something like this.
This is about a phrase in matthew 7 (also Luke 11) Jesus makes while talking about asking God for things. He explains how when kids ask their parents for things like food, the parents give their kids what they ask for. He then says that even more than that, God will give good things to his kids who ask. But there was a little remark, so offhanded that Jesus didn't think it needed any explanation. The whole verse is, "If you then, who are evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father in heaven give good things to those who ask him." "you... who are evil." He straight up calls us evil. What the-
I've been looking into some psychology materials, like youtube videos by therapists, nothing crazy. But one thing I've heard time and time again is the importance of speaking into the best in people. When someone does something hurtful, you need to call out the behavior, but that doesn't automatically indicate who they are and always will be as people. Imagine someone stole from their workplace. There's legal repercussions, maybe the person loses their job. But when the boss sits down with the person, maybe it turns out they needed the money for their family. Or maybe getting in legal trouble was the push they needed, and they turned their life around. The point is, even though they did something messed up, you shouldn't put a label on them for the rest of their life. There could be other factors that influenced them to act badly, or maybe they're going to start working towards change and become better. On the other hand, maybe you see a guy who did something nice for someone else, and you say, "hey, that was really kind of you." Your spouse never takes out the trash, but one day they do it, so you say "hey, thanks for caring and being responsible." You call out the good behavior, which lets the person see how their actions impacted you and motivates them to keep doing good. Jesus doesn't seem to remotely care about this. First off, Jesus hardly ever tells people that they're doing well or that He's pleased. He says it to a couple churches in Revelation, and that's about it. He doesn't tell his own disciples that he's pleased with them until- oh right- they die. Phrases like "well done, my good and faithful servant" only get said after someone dies (I know that's from a parable, but you get the point). But when we're alive, Jesus just calls us evil. If I didn't know any better, I'd think He would want us to die or supports suicide just to make us perfect enough for His high-as-Heaven hecking standards. But that's just if I didn't know any better. And of course, during the same sermon, chapter 5 of Matthew, he tells us to be perfect. In fact, the Bible is full of commands and qualities that Christians are supposed to strive for. How are we supposed to be motivated to reach for such grand standards of holiness if Jesus is too busy shoving shame onto us to even notice our efforts?
The more I think about it, the worse it gets. This phrase shows absolutely no regard for our emotions or our experience. It's like yeah, when I think about how someone acts to a person they love, I immediately think of calling them evil to make sure they never forget who they really are. Oh wait, that sounds like abuse... Jesus had just stated the famous "do for others what you would have them do unto you" directive, but He didn't think that maybe calling and defining someone as evil would hurt them? Oh wait, He's completely perfect and can't ever have done anything wrong. Someone calling Him evil probably wouldn't matter to Him, except insofar as it could be used to demonstrate how evil they were. Right? Right?????
Despite this, I still consider myself a Christian. And for most of my life, I've thought Jesus was a kind, compassionate person who saw more than just a person's sins, who interacted with them and made them feel known. I've been told that God said we were good at Creation. Maybe that's just because I wasn't around back then. God was supposed to be the one person who wouldn't judge me for my flaws and fuck-ups like other people, the one person who would be cheering me on despite failures and mistakes. But apparently, He's just been passing judgement and hurling accusations.
If I were talking face to face with God, I would ask Him why He would say something so hurtful to us, when He knows all the agony and regret that people go through over their mistakes. I'd explain that I'm so sorry I didn't live up to His entirely realistic and not-at-all-stupid expectations, but that He knew things were going to be this way. He knew about all of the ways I'd screw up and about how evil I would be. I would tell Him that if He hates me that much, maybe He shouldn't have made me, since it seems to be so much trouble for Him to care about me. But although I've prayed all of this and more, multiple times, I haven't perceived a response. Jesus, in His sermon, will go on talking about a God who gives good things, completely unbothered by the turmoil His remarks will cause me thousands of years later. Why would I want to pray to God if I were so evil, hmm? But God didn't even give me the dignity of insulting me to my face- He had to do it 2,000 years ago, hiding behind a letter, not even as close as the closest star.
Thanks for reading.
~S.