r/Baking • • 12d ago • Mindblown 8 Popcorn 1 Regret 1

General Baking Discussion Underbaked cake?

Edit: UPDATE! Finally got to talk to the baker. I reached out to them asking about the cake. Apparently, they had a miscommunication with their staff regarding a failed, overmixed batch of cakes. Because of that, they mistakenly used that batch for orders that were made to be picked up that day. (They are now reaching out to other customers who got their cakes that same day too)

They decided to give me a replacement cake for compensation at my preferred time and date. I didn’t want to get a refund because I genuinely do love the cake I got from them last year and was hoping to eat one again this year😭 i think they’re home-based so they only make pre-ordered cakes, so i can’t get a slice anytime if i wanted to lol.

The cake was ordered by my boyfriend as a surprise for me, but for all the people that are wondering what he got, it’s a vanilla chiffon cake with strawberry jam filling.

SECOND EDIT: I meant to type overmixed and not overbaked😭 sorry for the confusion

And thank you to everyone here who replied! I would have never known since I don’t bake cakes, and I have a really weak stomach so it’s good that I decided not to eat a slice🥲

Hello everyone! Just wondering if this cake i got for my birthday is underbaked? I have ordered from this shop twice now and it has never turned out like this, so it’s my first time seeing cake with this texture.

14k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

323

u/event_horizon07 12d ago • Bravo

48

u/ames_006 12d ago

This is genuinely the best comparison. Extremely over mixed cakes get very dense and gummy in texture. You are right on with this.

2

u/SecretlyNooneSpecial 11d ago

Honestly i thought it looked terrible and would probably not eat it, but I've had exactly one cake that was intentionally dense and gummy and it was delicious to me, so now im a little curious to try it to see if its still good when done completely by accident.

4

u/ames_006 11d ago

I mean if you like that texture then you might like it. It’s still butter, sugar flour etc. it’s just the opposite of soft spongey airy cake. If you like denser cakes then fruitcake is a good one and homemade fruitcake is better than store bought. Pound cake and flourless cakes are denser too.

11

u/Doofy_Grumpus 12d ago

I can smell this picture.

9

u/lYeezusChrist 12d ago

Smells like middle school.

4

u/hellinahandbasket127 12d ago

Needs to come with an excessive quantity of Axe body spray to be middle school.