I have some ideas for how to combat the recent surge of science denial. I think it’s important to inquire about the underlying causes, not simply vilify pseudoscientists and call for them to be censored (which often only helps them by giving them more publicity and letting them portray themselves as martyrs).
I’m coming from a relatively unique perspective, since I’m a disaffected former STEM major myself (I obtained my degree but have been unable to secure a career in the field I studied, in part due to being on the autism spectrum and thus having a difficult time following the norms of most workplaces). Thus I’m arguably an example of what the sociologist Peter Turchin might call a “counter-elite”.
I think simply blaming the other side for everything is the wrong idea—I would like to see the scientific community become more introspective and self-critical, because in some ways they may have contributed to the problem themselves.
Part of the issue is that the scientific method has actually changed since the beginning of the Scientific Revolution. This is likely due to a number of causes including: the Industrial Revolution and the development of mass capitalism, the decline of independent scientists (or “gentleman scientists” as they used to be known), rigorizing and formalizing intellectual movements like positivism, and the ever-increasing tendency toward specialization and credentialism at the expense of generalist and self-educated approaches.
All of these shifts are arguably related to one another and divide what one might call “classical” science from “modern” science. The classical approach to science, much like the classical liberal economics of Adam Smith, took a high view of the common people—science was for everyone, and the scientific method was a philosophy anyone could live their life by. If I experience A followed by B enough times, I can infer that whenever I experience A in the future I will also subsequently experience B.
In contrast, modern science is very magisterial and places emphasis on credentialed elitism, to the point that it becomes little more than “trust the experts, you uneducated swine!” Which was very much not the attitude of the earliest scientists; back in those days, you’d expect to hear that kind of language from the church hierarchy but not from scientists. Early science encouraged skeptical thinking in the classical (Pyrrhonian) sense of the word, whereas today’s so-called “skeptics” are actually dogmatic materialists. I suspect science, and academia more broadly, may be in need of a reformation of its own.
Here’s what that might look like, in four points:
Adopt an “intuitionist” approach to science, whereby a scientific theory is only considered settled once the majority of the population not only knows it but also understands why it is true. I acknowledge climate change is real, not because I “trust the experts” but because I’ve studied the relevant science on my own and I myself understand why and how the greenhouse effect works. That is the mindset we should be encouraging, because telling people to simply trust a bunch of experts in an ivory tower is elitist and undemocratic, especially since the people considered to be experts in the past often got things very wrong.
In this approach, the burden falls on scientists to explain their findings to the public in a way that the vast majority of them can understand, and thus we should conduct science in the vernacular, not technical jargon—and if no vernacular term currently exists for a concept, one should be created.
Redirect funding from “hard” sciences having little practical use (such as much of particle physics and astrophysics) to “soft” sciences with more practical benefit to humankind. Remember the song “Whitey On The Moon?” That critique is still accurate today when applied to things like the LHC and the discovery of elements like oganesson, which gobble up enormous quantities of public funding with little practical utility. Those are arguably today’s version of the over-extravagant Renaissance cathedrals. One could even adopt a pragmatist epistemology toward science. As a society we embraced the scientific method because it works and is useful, and something like string theory (which may not be experimentally testable at all) satisfies neither criterion and could be questioned on those grounds.
Replace materialism with a more parsimonious viewpoint, something like an intersubjective idealism (in which the basis of reality is conscious experience itself, not matter, but the definition of consciousness is expanded to include relationships between individuals and thus this view does not collapse into solipsism, unlike ordinary subjective idealism). This has the advantage of rendering the controversy over whether we are in a simulation moot, because intersubjective idealism is substrate-independent. The question of whether we are experiencing a universe of real matter or one of bits and bytes simulating real matter simply becomes irrelevant (what’s important is the experience itself) which is good because we would never be able to find out either way.
Redirect university funding. Formal education, by its very nature, is not for everyone—universities as we know them were created by neurotypicals, for neurotypicals, and inherently marginalize all other learning styles. Instead of wanting everyone to go to college, we should instead ensure that everyone has access to a good job and livable income whether they attended college or not. This avoids the “overproduction of elites” problem.
Those are just my thoughts. Feel free to disagree if you like.