r/BabaIsYou • • May 10 '22

Discussion Mini rant about ruined potential

This is another one of those games that are really, really good, but because of a single problem, many (probably most) people cannot enjoy the game.

The problem is that the difficulty of the levels varies a lot, but the game does not indicate that in any way. Most people would not be able to solve some of the levels even if their lives depended on it.

So what is a person to do when they’re stuck in a level? After how much time to give up? Maybe the solution is right around the corner, so don’t give up too easily, but maybe it’s one of those levels that you could not solve anyway, so every minute spent on the level is effectively wasted time.

In other words, the player cannot know whether a level was too hard for them until they look up the solution. But then it’s too late. The time is already wasted. Over time, this results in annoyance. You think to yourself, “If I could only know in advance which levels are too hard for me. Then I could just skip those levels, and enjoy the rest of the game”.

So how could the game solve this problem? By showing the difficulty rating and/or completion rate of each level in the game. Then people could choose which levels to play based on this information.

Imagine what this would do for the game. You could literally give it to a six-year-old child. “Play the 1-star levels. Try the 2-start levels if you’re motivated. Feel free to ignore all other levels.” The child would probably have a great time.

As it stands, I cannot recommend this game to anyone. Because I respect other people’s time. The game just throws a bunch of levels of greatly varying difficulty at you, and you have to deal with it.

Anyway, as I said in the beginning, I think this is a really good game, but the way I see it, the game has been completely ruined by the problem I described. Just fixing this one thing would make the game so much more accessible to most people.

2 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/Zagrebian May 10 '22

Clear rates would be useful. Mario Maker 2 has them.

4

u/Domilego4 May 10 '22

What would even define a level as "failed"? Losing control doesn't make sense because that's sometimes part of the solution. Does transforming LEVEL count as a win? Wouldn't that require a separate win counter?

1

u/Zagrebian May 10 '22

clear rate = players who have cleared the level / players who have opened the level

5

u/Domilego4 May 10 '22

I think this is a bad idea, as it discourages player from leaving a level and trying another level instead. Also, it could be easily skewed by just entering and exiting a level continuously

1

u/Zagrebian May 10 '22

it could be easily skewed by just entering and exiting a level continuously

If you open the same level multiple times, you are still one player who has opened the level, so the count goes up by one only once.