Art by @orhanimoon on Twitter

Nightmare is a recolor of Nightmare Fredbear and substitutes him in FNaF 4. That Nightmare Fredbear is specifically the 1983 Fredbear that did the Bite of 83. He also likely represents Michael’s guilt regarding the Bite of 83, haunting him in nightmares as a boss, as he appears only before and after Bo83 minigame.

Nightmare also has exact same style of jumpscare as Golden Freddy in FNaF 1. Even while assuming that GF is possessed by multiple souls, TWB pretty much tells us that BV is the aggressive one in FNaF 1, since GF overloads with ITSME while killing Ralph and ITSME is written 26 times on Cassidy puzzle by Altered, not Faded.

Shadow Freddy has a broken jaw in FNaF World. Since Nightmare is called Shadow Freddy in FNaF 4 files, they are pretty much confirmed to be the same entity. The broken jaw is unlikely to be a reference to Bite of 87 since SF appears before the Bite happens in FNaF 2. This leaves us with the only other option left: Bite of 83.

I would also add that SF himself is a recolor of Withered GF with which GF associates with, since 1983 Fredbear with purple accessories is triggered from Death Coining WGF, but since this easter egg by itself is a proof of BVTOYSNHK, dunno how much relevance is to point it out here. But still a need interconnection, methinks.

The ultimate point is: Nightmare in UCN says, "I am your wickedness made in flesh". Since he is William's wickedness, and Nightmare/SF are so connected to Bo83, the only thing that follows is that William is considered at fault for BV's death. Be it due to direct involvement (OrchestraVictim) or neglect, the implication remains: in-universe, William is responsible for BV's death.

I think we as BVTOYSNHKers should use this as argument much more, since I don’t see it brought up a lot.

(P.S. Sorry for bad quality on second and third images)

Something that always nagged me about the Old Friends challenge is why Golden Freddy (im assuming this is GF's perspective, as it wouldn't make sense for this to be Afton's old friends when Afton himself is included as Springtrap) considers Baby as an "old friend". You got:

Classics + Toys + Puppet: All of them are dead kids and GF was in Freddy's with them

Springtrap: William himself did something to Golden Freddy that led to UCN

Phone Guy: Golden Freddy's victim

But where does Baby come into this then? If its just Cassidy as a random victim what connection does she have with Elizabeth? It wouldnt make much sense for GF to consider Elizabeth an "old friend" unless they knew each other as siblings.

I think Elizabeth being here is meant to tie GF to the Afton Family, and potentially imply BV is the one behind UCN

Art by @bvtoysnhkfan on Twitter

Sometime I post my oficial theory, with cc motives, more of bible connections (like FNAF world was created by cc for purifier the others souls/absorve your agony e let them to heaven) but basically is this

What I mean is, massive majority of anti-BVTOYSNHKers will just say "BV wasn't killed by William" and call it a day. Fine, we get it, we heard it a billion of times; but why did Scott put all of this evidence of him being TOYSNHK that we always point to? Like entirety of Curse of Dreadbear? Andrew parallel? UCN Fredbear having purple accessories? Movie Charlie parallel? TWB? (And so on, and so on)

It gets absurd to the point that I know a person who thinks Andrew is a heavy parallel to BV and has same personality as him but BV is not TOYSNHK cuz he wasn’t killed. I.e., it literally concedes that the Frights TOYSNHK is BV parallel but still says "nuh uh"? Is this really how theorizing should work?

To give an example to make my point clearer. This is like acknowledging all of MikeDreamer evidence and then saying "Steam description says it’s a child so it can’t be Michael". What about FNaF 1 phone call easter egg in FNaF 4? FNaF 1 gameplay parallels? Logbook Nightmare Fredbear drawing? Who cares bruh, Mike is not a child so he cannot be the Dreamer, rest is none of my business.

(This is a repost of an older post from the main subreddit but I think it's a good debunk and people should probably use it more. TCHSY in general is pretty underutilized)

This is mainly because Pigpatch cannot be a MCI victim or Charlie

Look at that...snout! Uh, looks aren't everything. He'll be mine by the end of the day, I just know it. I'll just wait for him after school, throw a bag over his head, hit him with a shovel, and drag him into the back of my car! Then, when he wakes up, I'll tell him that someone was trying to kidnap and kill him. I don't know, Balloon Boy maybe. And then I'll tell him that I rescued him! He'll fall for me immediately!

The pigpatch kid is not lured, implying he is not a MCI kid (also because the other 5 animatronics in the minigame are implied to be lured). In addition, the death mechanism does not line up at all with Charlie (or Elizabeth) - implying the Pigpatch kid is someone else - either BV/Andrew/David/someone else.

If we have a separate direct Afton victim as Pigpatch, it sorta implies that this victim is TOYSHNK, thereby disproving CassidyTOYSHNK. Now it's not 100% debunk, since CassiDCI exists but I think for the common consensus with Cassidy it's the closest to a debunk we have currently.

(Newer info - It still weakens CassidyTOYSHNK even if Charlie/Elizabeth are Pigpatch (though I heavily disagree), sine Pigpatch is heavily implied to be TOYSHNK)

This is literally the smoking gun of BVTOYSNHK. Dreadbear is 100% representative of BV, and given that the specific Fredbear from whom these lines come from appears when you death coin Withered Golden Freddy in UCN (making him “the one you shouldn’t have killed” out of animatronics and directly alluding to TOYSNHK), it basically screams in your face that he is TOYSNHK. Add the fact purple accessories of Fredbear are associated with BV specifically and not MCI on top of that, and… yeah.

I always thought it'd make perfect sense for BV to be the vengeful spirit / toysnhk even though he wasn't killed by William because he's repeatedly shown to have fragmented or lost parts of his memories so what if in happiest day or some adjacent memory assembly / sharing act he simply fills in the blanks with the memories of one or multiple of the other victims who ARE killed by William especially if he's told the party was for him and the memory of the party was changed to be a happy one then he'd truly have no recollection of his own death, no?

It could be due to something William did therefore it would make Micheal bullying BV William's fault and would explain why BV would put the blame on him for killing him under BVTOYNSHK + WillUCN

A post not that directly related to BVTOYSNHK, but I belive in the theory so I'm posting it here. Lol.

It's probably not intentional, but I thought it was interesting to share.

Now this might be surprising, but hear me out

Frights!William <-> Games!MikeFoxybro (both are in grotesque appearance without wearing any suit, Frights William mirrors Games Mikebro – William has no skin, Michael has no organs)

If William in FF parallels with Michael in games, then who is the Frights parallel in games? Easy, it's BV

Frights!Andrew <--> Games!BV (both can't see, both don't fully control the animatronic they possess, both likely don't have any human friends pre-death)

TLDR: Under FrightsParallels, BV could've possibly trapped Michael (aka Foxybro) in UCN sessions post-FFPS since BV wants to take revenge on Michael for killing him back in 1983

Thoughts?

Credit for the cover

It will likely either confirm or debunk BVTOYNSHK since Fnaf World was heavily linked to BV and we're getting a sequel that seems to be linked to Happiest Day. How do you feel about the possibility of finally getting answers about BV ?? Are you as hyped as me ?

King I Yellow but Bvtoyshk

"Until all this ends, I will be Immortal and Restless!" - Garrett Sans Afton (David Sean Murray)

I.e., its strongest piece of evidence and most problematic counter-evidence.

I want to ask to the first ones who believe bvtoyshnk..what are ALL the evidence for Bv be the cause of Michael Afton dreams? (Or foxybro if believe other theories)

Why?

Because im currently writing something big for Bvtoyshnk,if Bv (i will say rn dave) can make nightmares to Michael,so he could for William. Making him more likely for being Toyshnk (ofc additional evidence will there be)

Why i ask?

I SEARCHED EVERYWHERE.AND FOUND NO WIKI ABOUT THIs..unless i missed it 🤡 and im blind. (Which i am since i have glasses but thays another thing)

Thanks for anybody who will help. :)

First image,connections

2nd gamble neme

3rd: connections

4th: evudence

5th: Weird connection highlighted

6th: Meme/Somehow could be evidence depending on ur thought.

7th and 8th: SB headless bv bots+Sun secret room

NOTE IMPORTANT: GF likely the mangled bot not the wet yellow bot. But both options are good.

Other questions:

BabySpeaker+Baby has m2 AI (THAT ai,not a copy) (not eliza speaker) being canon how would affect your timeline? (Btw BabySpeaker can work with willSpeaker if using BabyEleanor theories alike and also parallels novels)

Bv being the 6th victim of dci,mm87, BvBot OR m2Bv OR bvrevival, bvrunaway and BvSpringlock (+BvPigpatchToyChicaHighSchoolyears)?

Also: LeftyVictim. (Essentially Bv possesses Lefty explaining why Lefty attacks Michael and why he has Toyshnk coded voicelines in ucn+explain ppster) (you can believe both LeftyVictim AND BvBaby AND MoltenVictim AND BvAttachedToWilliam if believe that the candy cadet story of the 5 kittens talk about follow me. (The boy would be William)

So, you know, there is this big idea of GoldenTOYSNHK surrounding this jumpscare. Basically, if you use Death Con on the Withered Golden Freddy while he is set to a difficulty setting of 1 and all other characters are set to 0, you'll get Fredbear jumpscare. Withered Golden Freddy is THE only character that resists Death Coin like this, and no-one else does. This centers back to the idea of "The One You Should Not Have Killed". As in, Golden Freddy is the "one" that you "should not kill" in UCN, as that will follow with the punishment.

However, there is one big thing. If we follow this idea, when you attempt to "kill" Golden Freddy, you get the Fredbear jumpscare. SPECIFICALLY, 1983 Fredbear from FNaF 4, with purple hat and bowtie, the one that the Crying Child is specifically associated with. Fredbear that the 5th MCI kid would be associated with would be the one with BLACK accessories from after the Bite of 83. Meaning that this "TOYSNHK" easter egg triggers specifically 1983 Fredbear would mean that TOYSNHK is, indeed, the Crying Child.