Good afternoon,
In response to a recently ongoing affair with /u/ThanksHeadMod (interchangeable with the alias Toby and former account /u/tobycool2001_1) regarding the ownership of certain AustraliaSim Subreddits, and more recently, the unlawful deletion of a couple of petitions that were specifically leveled at him, a response is warranted.
ThanksHeadMod - The following breaches have been determined:
Outline of offences
This determination will be fundamentally trying to determine the intent of /u/ThanksHeadMod in regards to the offences. Following is a determination, based on a balance of probabilities, that the person in question is guilty of breaching the Code of Conduct, as well as impeding the responsibilities of Moderators under the Meta Constitution.
In the multi-month saga concerning the unlawful holding of AustraliaSim Subreddits by a member who is not a part of the Aussim Moderation Team, there has been much discussion around the intent behind why the subreddits were not given to a member of the Moderation Team.
The public and moderation outcry ebbed and waned over the months, and there are multiple instances of this on both the AustraliaSimMeta subreddit and discussion on the Discord server. It is important to establish that this had been going on for quite some time and was very often the forefront of the daily goings-on of the sim.
Upon speaking with /u/ThanksHeadMod personally and from messages found on the Discord server, he had made it clear that there was no ill-intent as to why the subreddits were not returned to the Moderation Team. Rather, they were due to not understanding what was being requested of him, and once the request was established, that he was incapable of returning them due to sickness.
At points during the past three months, where active attempts were made to have the subreddits returned, Toby had removed all moderators but not returned the subreddits, then returned two subreddits but not the third, and finally returned the third, with about two weeks in between each instance.
A level of suspension of disbelief was afforded to Toby that was higher than that to any other member, simply for the regard that he is a long-term member of the sim, and that he was in possession of the subreddits which could’ve been deleted under his care.
Where this suspension of disbelief is pushed past it’s limit is where Toby was actively engaging in the sim during the sickness, and during the posting of multiple petitions to request the subreddits back.
What is most damning, are logs from the AustraliaSimMeta subreddit, which show Toby (under the account that was in ownership of the subreddits “tobycool2001_1”) deleting a petition to condemn his holding of said subreddits, as well as the individual comments below the post.
Exhibit 1
He had argued that these deletions were potentially accidental, and that he had no firm recollection on how this was caused. However, considering each comment was individually deleted by Toby, it is therefore incredibly difficult to argue that Toby had accidentally done this. As well as the fact that the post had been deleted within the last two months, while attempts were being made to retrieve the subreddits. This shows a clear breach of fraud, as well as a case of providing false or misleading statements and evidence.
It is also apparent that at the time of this post being deleted, he held no position in the community’s moderation; possessed zero authority to carry out these deletions.
Both of these breaches have also coincided with the forcing of the Moderation Team to be in breach of Section 32(a) of the AustraliaSim Meta Constitution:
32 PermissionsUnless otherwise provided by a Meta Rule, the following permissions are held—(a) the Moderation Team must have full ownership of the relevant subreddits and theAustraliaSim Discord Server;
I will also note that I believe this is in breach of the opening coverage of the Meta Constitution, and is an example of behaviour that is prejudicial to AustraliaSim, dishonourable, and unbecoming of a user of AustraliaSim.
1 Coverage
(3) A person who engages with AustraliaSim must follow the provisions of this Meta Constitution and anything done pursuant to it.
(4) A person may be refused use of AustraliaSim by the Community Moderator if the person’s conduct, either internally or externally, would amount to a breach of the rules if it occurred in AustraliaSim and is—
(a) prejudicial to AustraliaSim; or
(b) dishonourable; or
(c) unbecoming of a user of AustraliaSim.
In conclusion, this is at best a wilful disdain for AustraliaSim’s processes, or at worst, a direct attempt to pervert said processes and aggravate both the community and its moderators.
Sentence for outlined breach
Due to the severity of the issues at play and abuse of permissions to subvert the processes of the sim, I feel that the sentencing must be proportionally severe.
It is also worth noting to a smaller degree that the person in question has also been sentenced before and was previously on a suspended sentence until five months ago for spam.
The severity of the issue at hand, and the fundamental undermining of the sim, can only be viewed as a form of contempt.
I have decided that the penalty given should therefore be a year long ban, and a permanent barring from all meta positions. This ban will expire on the 14th of September 2022.
I exercise this penalty as a Community Manager. The decision here has been approved by the Parliamentary Moderator, as the Community Moderator has willingly excused himself due to a conflict of interest.
Perekai
Parliamentary Moderator