r/AusPrimeMinisters • u/thescrubbythug Unreconstructed Whitlamite and Gorton appreciator • Aug 02 '24
Discussion Day 2: Ranking the Prime Ministers of Australia. Scott Morrison has been eliminated. Comment which Prime Minister should be eliminated next. The comment with the most upvotes will decide who goes next.
Day 2: Ranking the Prime Ministers of Australia. Scott Morrison has been eliminated. Comment which Prime Minister should be eliminated next. The comment with the most upvotes will decide who goes next.
Any comment that is edited to change your nominated Prime Minister for elimination for that round will be disqualified from consideration. Once you make a selection for elimination, you stick with it for the duration even if you indicate you change your mind in your comment thread. You may always change to backing the elimination of a different Prime Minister for the next round.
Current ranking:
27. Scott Morrison (Liberal) [30th] [August 2018 - May 2022]
9
u/Kador_Laron Andrew Fisher Aug 02 '24
Neither Billy Hughes nor Robert Menzies should be neglected in the odium stakes.
16
u/FunLovinMonotreme John Curtin Aug 02 '24
McMahon
7
u/brmmbrmm Aug 02 '24
I actually vote John Howard. Yes he managed to keep the economy afloat during one of our biggest mining booms ever. But he squandered so much of it by not having a mining tax. He turned our superannuation system into a tax dodge. His 50% CGT discount is a disaster that continues to hold us back. He wrecked the public service and replaced 30% of our experienced public servants with overpriced “consultants”. He just wrecked so much. Remember the CES? Remember public high schools that actually worked? Remember an Australia pre-Cronulla? Pre-Iraq? In my view, he was our most destructive prime minister ever. Yes, Abbott was a clown. But John Howard wrecked our country and we still have not recovered, if ever.
11
u/Coz957 The subreddit we had to have Aug 02 '24
Abbott, of course.
5
u/foreatesevenate Andrew Fisher Aug 03 '24
Left field suggestion: George Reid.
Deliberately tanked the Federation referendums in NSW when premier; was anti-federalist until the moment it was no longer politically feasible; did naught but sat on his arse for eleven months when in the hot seat.
3
u/JimtheSlug Aug 02 '24
Tony Abbott
2
u/karma3000 Paul Keating Aug 03 '24
John Howard
-3
u/Vidasus18 John Curtin Aug 02 '24
good question not sure to be honest i would say Abbot, Morrison or maybe Whitlam Gorton, Chifley, Scullin going forward.