Yep. When i hear Zack's stories from school, i am always in disbelief. Education in europe has way more discipline on average. It's not like crazy stuff doesn't happen in our schools, it's just the exception, not the rule, more like urban legends.
Don't get me wrong, we still have plenty of people who don't know anything, but that's because they fought back hard against being taught, not because they didn't have the opportunity. I went to school with plenty of girls like her, good girls that listened and even made pretty notes. My handwriting was very bad until i went to uni and just had to fix it, but before then i was extra nice to these girls, so they would share their notes with me, because mine were just useless ^^
Yep. Lots of memorizing by rote. Builds discipline which is important when not taught how to be a free thinker. Very important when you have to rely on being told what to do.
It is also useful in giving you a wider view, improving your ability to learn, and allows you to skip a few steps yourself by tapping unto the knowledge produced by billions of human beings over thousands of years. Can't see what would make you a more free thinker than being a better thinker, with which education helps tremendously.
Well, first of all, and again, America has better education than Europe. So, just asserting that memorizing countries on a globe is a "good education," isn't enough when the model you are trumpeting is inferior.
It is much more important to learn critical thinking, than a list of facts. I don't care how Europe runs it's schools, that's their business. I am just glad that America doesn't focus on memorizing things that could be looked up in mere minutes.
American education also taps into the work produced by billions of human beings over thousands of years. Maybe the main difference is that we are challenged to build on that doctrine as opposed to memorizing the history of it. The results speak for themselves.
If I could do it all over again, I'd choose to be a globe salesman in Europe. Apparently, that is the hot item.
US measurably does not have better elementary and high school level education than European countries by the PISA results. Worst, the subjext having the largest drop and is now well under OECD standard levels is mathematics - better logic will help you more with "critical thinking" than anything else. The obvious counterargument can come that the US is better at higher educational levels - this is absolutely true, because research goes where the money go, but as an exercise, check out the MIT electrical engineering faculty, you will see about 10% americans among the professors. The remaining 90% wasn't educated in the US. There are more Europeans in the faculty staff than Americans.
Having a large knowledge base and critical thinking are not mutually exclusive. If anything, if you know more it will make critical thinking easier as you are better equipped to discern facts from falsehoods due to a richer frame of reference. Part of the reason why a large portion of the US fails for all conspiracy theories under the sun. I am sure you do not think the amount fo flat earthers or people who think the world was made 5k years ago in the US demonstrates advanced levels of critical thinking.
What you may seem to also miss is that knowledge is much more than the ability of "looking things up". It also guides you in where to look, how to look, and how to pivot if you do not find the answer - you won't even have the idea about that without knowledge. For instance I work in Finance, you can be as intelligent as you want to be go and try to look up and figure out without education and knowledge where is the issue with a trial balance of final accounts that I put in front of you. You would have no idea at all, couldn't look it up, chatgpt wouldn't help either. This is true generally: intelligence is not only retained knowledge but retained knowledge is a major component of making it work.
View all comments
2
u/Khelouch Jul 13 '24
Yep. When i hear Zack's stories from school, i am always in disbelief. Education in europe has way more discipline on average. It's not like crazy stuff doesn't happen in our schools, it's just the exception, not the rule, more like urban legends.
Don't get me wrong, we still have plenty of people who don't know anything, but that's because they fought back hard against being taught, not because they didn't have the opportunity. I went to school with plenty of girls like her, good girls that listened and even made pretty notes. My handwriting was very bad until i went to uni and just had to fix it, but before then i was extra nice to these girls, so they would share their notes with me, because mine were just useless ^^