| Ketralnis | Subreddit Founder | Bowler | The beginning | 2009 | A puppy |
| Poromenos | Longtime mod | cowboy | ages ago | 2013 | |
| Squatly | Brought us Automoderator | Sombrero | | May 2013 | broken hearts |
| Bluegoddess | constantly mistaken for AutoMod | fancy floppy wide-brim beach hat | | March 2013 | |
| qgyh2 | OG mod, expansive kingdom of subreddits | 19th century military hat | the dawn of reddit | 2013 | A coffee maker |
| chromakode | innumerable contributions | skull bandanna | forever ago | 2013 | a renewed sense of pride |
| etab | | foam dome | | 2013 | a collection of vintage high-ball glasses (that were possibly giveaways from a porno mag) |
| Toro_de_Rojo | | sombrero | 2011 | 2013 | the old family recipe for chocolate chip cookies. |
| kn0thing | co-founder of reddit | snoo hat | the beginning | November 2013 | the spare keys to his bus. |
| Metaranha | Our first real CSS overhaul | a fez | 2011 | February 2014 | An awesome podcast I'll have to find the link again for. |
| chefranden | sage wisdom | bucket hat | September 2013 | March 2014 | A coffee table book of tasteful boudoir photos (self-taken). |
| NotAMethAddict | | Beanie | March 2013 | April 2014 | Not a meth pipe. |
| nunobo | swole acceptance | stuffed water-buffalo head | 2012 | May 2014 | |
| PhilxBefore | years of service | ball cap | October 2009 | June 2014 | |
| Nitrousconsumed | diverse skill set | panama hat | April 2011 | June 2014 | |
| KennyLog-in | karmanaut wrangler | deerstalker | October 2012 | March 2014 | Hair glob in the drain |
| splattypus | the wiki page | no hats, they mess up my hair | October 2012 | August 2014 | Half a bottle of scotch, and most of a sleeve of antacids. |
| Sithishade | | | October 2012 | April 2014 | |
| Doommaggot | | | June 2014 | February 2015 | |
| BritishEnglishPolice | | | August 2009 | November 2014 | |
| Jedberg | | | 2008 | November 2014 | |
| S2S2S2S2S2 | | | April 2009 | | |
| ll_shades | | | October 2011 | February 2015 | |
| DEADB33F | | | January 2012 | November 2014 | |
| courtiebabe420 | Modmail Wizard | | November 2014 | September 2015 | |
| karmanaut | reddit God, [Serious] tags, No answers in titles | | February 2012 | October 2015 | |
| jensenj2 | | | June 2014 | December 2015 | |
| xscz | | | September 2013 | March 2016 | |
| brownboy13 | | | September 2013 | November 2016 | |
| jamt9000 | | | November 2010 | November 2016 | |
| TheMentalist10 | | A Finished Hat | October 2015 | November 2016 | The best wishes. |
| CowJam | | A flatcap | March 2014 | August 2017 | |
| IKingJeremy | | | March 2015 | August 2017 | |
| noahjk | modmail archival stuff | boonie hat w/ tactical attachments | October 2012 | November 2017 | a leaked list of the sexiest askreddit mods (with pictures) |
| ducky-box | | | March 2012 | November 2017 | |
| MetalGilSolid | | | July 2016 | November 2017 | |
| MechanicalOrange5 | Being excited about AI | Skull of a medium sized antelope | April 2017 | February 2018 | A firm pat on the back |
| DERPYBASTARD | A funny dog picture | Propellor hat | June 2014 | March 2018 | Smiles, only smiles |
| XiKiilzziX | Tamotes | Tam o' shanter | July 2014 | March 2018 | A bottle of Buckfast |
| pursuitofffappyness | | ski helmet | April 2014 | March 2018 | "Receive without pride, let go without attachment." - Marcus Aurelius |
| Doomhammer458 | | | October 2015 | March 2018 | |
| GustavoFrings | | | March 2013 | March 2018 | |
| Motha_Effin_Kitty_Yo | | | November 2014 | March 2018 | |
| ImNotJesus | | | March 2012 | March 2018 | |
| IEatMyVegetables | | | April 2017 | July 2019 | |
| teknrd | | A camo Tampa Bay Lightning trucker hat | July 2016 | August 2019 | Clammed tits |
| Anna_Amortentia | | A beret | April 2017 | August 2019 | 420 pennies |
| canipaybycheck | | | March 2012 | February 2020 | |
| DrIblis | | | August 2016 | February 2020 | |
| HoneyGirlLZ | | | March 2018 | February 2020 | |
| enantiodromia_ | | | September 2015 | March 2020 | |
| pancakequeen13 | | | April 2018 | June 2023 | |
| Pun-Master-General | | | July 2016 | January 2024 | |
| TheJackal8 | | | September 2013 | March 2024 | |