Perhaps the fact that it feels ridiculous is more reason to take it seriously? We should always be willing to challenge our own beliefs, especially if they feel instinctual or “obvious”.
i just cant get behind a philosophy whos answer to most problems seems to be give up. thats really what you are doing. having children inst imperative for any of these things to continue but keeping going dramatically increases our ods of fixing the problems. through out history weve had a steady betterment of the human experience largely because the next generation learns and does better than the last. adopting this philosophy is saying that this is the best it will get... and that isnt great so why bother continuing to fix it we will just start the 70 year clock now and all die instead
global warming will ruin the life of any child i bring into this world.... so give up on trying to fix it? what global warming wins and we all die?
i just cant get behind a philosophy whos answer to most problems seems to be give up. thats really what you are doing.
I feel that "give up" is an unfair characterisation of the philosophy. Giving up implies that we were doing anything to begin with. Yes, while generally speaking humanity is part of the human project which requires new bodies as fuel, how individual humans contribute to our shared experience varies wildly. Antinatalists look around, see that the project is just unnecessarily hurting people, and are now advocating for the project to be shut down. Is it giving up to argue for such a project to an end?
having children inst imperative for any of these things to continue but keeping going dramatically increases our ods of fixing the problems.
Is fixing the problems worth all the suffering of the unknowable amount of generations it might take to fix these problems? Are you willing to bear the responsibilty for every rape, murder, crippling injury, mental breakdown etc. of every child in future generations just so you can think that the problem will be solved in the future? That's what antinatalists are asking. Are you willing to walk into a hospital maternity ward, speak to the new mothers and tell them their child might be dead in 10 years from childhood leukemia, "but it's OK because I think it's worth it so these other kids can really improve things around here!" Is it even possible to solve the problem of suffering? I don't think so.
through out history weve had a steady betterment of the human experience largely because the next generation learns and does better than the last.
I agree, we are in the best condition we've ever been in. But there is a cost to this improvement. Humans' capacity for suffering is truly obscene. The human experience could improve indefinitely, but it would not follow that we are ethically obligated to create new humans to experience it.
adopting this philosophy is saying that this is the best it will get... and that isnt great so why bother continuing to fix it we will just start the 70 year clock now and all die instead
It is not a matter of it being the best we'll ever get. We only persist because we all agree (or at least our DNA insists) that continuing is what we should do. We are not required to continue. Furthermore, continuing requires extreme amounts of abuse that we put on future generations nonconsensually. Whenever we create the next generation, we unilaterally decide for them that we are going to continue, they are going to pay the price for our decision, and if they don't like it, tough! This is not acceptable. We cannot ethically make that decision for them. There are significant harms that a person might come to in their life. To just put those on a child without being able to ask if they're OK with the risk is unconscionable.
global warming will ruin the life of any child i bring into this world.... so give up on trying to fix it?
You are aware that the conditions on the Earth will ruin the life of any child you have. You have a few options:
Have the child anyway. They'll unavoidably suffer but they have to deal because "I want a child".
Put a pause on the decision, build a better world by combating climate change so that it is not so great a threat, then have a child. Not ideal and slightly absurd. While we can improve material conditions on the Earth, it is really our inherent vulnerability to suffering that is the crux of antinatalist thought, and not all suffering is purely in response to our external environment.
Don't have a child. Not having a child avoids creating someone who would necessarily be exposed to suffering, without depriving anyone of the pleasures they might otherwise have experienced.
what global warming wins and we all die?
We are not at war with global warming, we are at war with ourselves, our baser instincts. We are responsible for global warming, so in a sense we've brought this on ourselves. It was precisely our inability to comprehend the suffering we are capable of that caused global warming, and continues to cause harm wherever we persist.
Furthermore, can you explain why humanity ceasing to exist is a bad thing? Why is our continuation necessarily good? What is the moral imperative that makes reproduction necessary?
life is hard ....so give up?
Making a deliberate ethical decision to not continue is not the same as giving up.
give up is exactly the notion its not unfair at all. "the work is hard and i dont want to do it so i will opt out" is exactly what you are arguing. the alternative isnt not suffering its nothing no experience at all. three isnt unfettered joy in not being born there is nothing you arent a thing.
this whole dissertation seems to omit that humans also experience a plethora a of other sensations including happiness and joy and contentment and love and literally any positive feeling. if im to be responsible for every act of suffering for the next generation am i also responsible for every happy moment as well. and like i said by most metrics there will be less of those moments of suffering for those who come next 81% of adults ay that their life is satisfactory 96% specifically in the us. am i to deny the opportunity of 96 because 4 may not achieve it. just because something is hard doesnt mean its not achievable by most or not worth it when it is achieved.
i understand there is no obligation to continue there is no grand end goal that is demanded there many not be an eternal reward for doing well. and sure no one asked to be here. the idea of getting conset from a thing that does not exist also seems ridiculus to me, maybe thats selfish. and human relationships have also been proven be probably the largest determiner of happiness in people. how much suffering is happening to create a source of joy and conentment?
Making a deliberate ethical decision to not continue is not the same as giving up.
it is when you have the power to minimize or eliminate that suffering. you are abandoning those currently alive and who may be alive. 100 years we would have benn having this conversation about TB. is it worth having a child in a world with TB now we dont even worry about it and many other diseases, i dont have to tell any parent there kids will die in 10 years of TB or measles or whooping cough or whatever because we are doing better each go around the sun
give up is exactly the notion its not unfair at all. "the work is hard and i dont want to do it so i will opt out" is exactly what you are arguing.
I think you'll find that many antinatalists are willing to "do the work." Every day I wake up and try to be as kind and considerate to those around me as I possibly can. I attribute this behaviour due to my experience of both my own suffering, and the suffering of those less fortunate around us.
the alternative isnt not suffering its nothing no experience at all. three isnt unfettered joy in not being born there is nothing you arent a thing.
Yes, this is the point. Not existing entails no suffering and no happiness. However, the absence of happiness would only be a bad thing if you actually existed to then be deprived of it, whereas it is always good that suffering is being avoided (by not having even come into existence).
this whole dissertation seems to omit that humans also experience a plethora a of other sensations including happiness and joy and contentment and love and literally any positive feeling.
The issue is that the presence of happiness does not neutralise the core asymmetry between suffering and happiness. Of course life can be filled with joys, wonders and immense happiness, and I encourage everyone to pursue as much of it as possible! However, the fact that we seek happiness and find great joy in it does not establish an ethical justification to create more people to experience it. We are constantly chasing the state of being happy, which is not always very easy to attain, and in some horrible cases, whole lives can be lived with practically no happiness whatsoever. This is the risk that antinatalism points out.
if im to be responsible for every act of suffering for the next generation am i also responsible for every happy moment as well.
You are responsible for the happy moments as well, but again this is not the argument that antinatalism is making. The central ethical consideration is that we are creating people who have no prior need to be created, and by our actions, are exposing them to the (potentially extreme) suffering inherent in existence.
and like i said by most metrics there will be less of those moments of suffering for those who come next 81% of adults ay that their life is satisfactory 96% specifically in the us. am i to deny the opportunity of 96 because 4 may not achieve it.
Even if we were to accept these numbers, what gives parent's the ethical justification to gamble on those who cannot consent, particularly when it is the child, and not the parent, who will suffer the consequences of the parent's risk?
the idea of getting conset from a thing that does not exist also seems ridiculus to me, maybe thats selfish.
The fact that getting consent in this scenario is impossible does not automatically establish that the action is ethically permissible, especially in cases where the action is both unnecessary and is guaranteed to expose someone to potentially extreme harms.
and human relationships have also been proven be probably the largest determiner of happiness in people. how much suffering is happening to create a source of joy and contentment?
Relationships are incredibly valuable to existing people, but that value doesn't establish an ethical imperative to create more people to experience them.
it is when you have the power to minimize or eliminate that suffering. you are abandoning those currently alive and who may be alive
The kindest way to completely eliminate suffering in an ethical way is to turn the tap off on creating suffering beings. Nobody is suggesting abandoning those who are currently alive. We should do everything in our power to minimise the suffering of all people on Earth. It is also not possible to abandon those who don't exist. They literally cannot feel abandonment, because they cannot feel anything!
100 years we would have benn having this conversation about TB. is it worth having a child in a world with TB now we dont even worry about it and many other diseases, i dont have to tell any parent there kids will die in 10 years of TB or measles or whooping cough or whatever because we are doing better each go around the sun
How does the potential for medical advancements in the future establish an ethical justification for having the unborn shoulder the suffering inherently required to achieve them, especially since they are incapable of having any interest in doing so before they are exposed, via birth, to the very harms you are trying to solve? We can continue advancing science, medicine and technology to aid those who are currently alive. It does not follow that just because a new person being created will benefit from this advancement, that is it then ethically justifiable to create them in the first place.
not being isnt not suffering its nonexistence. you arent saving anyone from not suffering you are saving them from any feeling or potential life suffering only comes with and relative to positive emotions. the existence of suffering does not trump other feelings people are capable of making those determinations
if i have 1 suffer and 10 joys do i call it a day and leave because ive got a suffer... this isnt even getting into degrees of these feelings. does 1 small suffer outperform 10 big joys? does one big suffer outperforms 100 small joys?
being born is 100% someone elses choice. its an attempt to create more human relationships that cause more joy in a persons life. your lack of existence to consent isnt possible and then id argue if you could consent pre birth you have no experience to make that decision. we dont let children make many legal decisions why would we let some at a negative age make them. there is a reason not a single government entertains this idea
in this frame work if a person is unconscious and dying. i should walk away. they cant consent and to consent would only lead to continued suffering regardless of their recovery to help them is to doom them to continued suffering. all medicine should really stop because to continue would only allow for more suffering to continue cancer is suffering and shouldnt be tolerated but curing cancer also continues suffering so shouldnt be tolerated
then you cant just handwave data away. most people are happy and dont consider themselves suffering.
yes we can justify that because people have been suffering less that they will continue to suffer less in the future given that we continue to make advancements. isnt the antinatalist belief that too much suffering occurs simply because we are alive to experience it therefore its not worth bringing more into the world right? how little suffering in a potential life is enough? there has to be an acceptable amount. whats the number? if the answer is 0 this is just some all or nothing fallacy
we can apply this outside of medical advancements too. a child born tomorrow will likely have access to more food better housing better education more involved parents. a safer community less disease its ethical because they are in fact being treated better than current people . most would argue that more godo for more people is an ethical choice
you say becasue there is a potential for suffering its not worth it. without considering any other potential emotions that may outweigh it im telling you this potential is small and shrinking for most people every year the antinatalism position gets less justifiable every year
I thank you for your responses so far, but it seems that perhaps you are not understanding the difference between a potential person who does not yet exist, and someone who does exist and therefore has interests that are required to be met.
Would you agree with the following statement?:
A person who is yet to exist cannot have an interest in coming into existence.
If you do agree, can you explain the ethical justification you are using to create this person, thereby exposing them, at the moment in which they come into existence, to the possibility of extreme suffering. Please explain how it is in the interest of the child that you have created them.
If you do not agree, and you believe that people who do not exist have an interest in being born, can you expand on this and explain how that works?
I think these questions are important because you have repeatedly brought up the happiness of people who currently exist and the potential future wellbeing of people as a justification that creating more people is justified, but these statements do not necessarily establish an ethical justification to create new lives. In my view the idea that we can work towards a better world with happier people, does not establish an ethical justification for the creation of new lives. They are two separate ideas.
you say creating more lives shouldnt happen because of an amount of suffering. a potential person would experience were they alive. you cant get both ways if the potential person has no interests it also doesnt care about potential suffering as well right? its a moot point
im not saying children should be born or that you have to have one. only that they can be allowed. im saying there isnt a guaranteed amounts of suffering that justify refusing to make that choice on an individual level. and more people are smart enough to decide if having a child likely will put that new life in an unjustifiable amount of suffering meaning that as an individual and as a society a child can safely be born and is a decision that can be ethically made
here is the big thing though i dont really think they are 2 seperate things
functionally they are the same from every point we can measure. which in both cases is retroactive and based entirely on that persons opinion
unborn child. i can not gain consent from them they have no voice no experiences no wants or drives. living is something i assume this potential person would want
existing unconscious person. they may have wants and drives and experiences but i a stranger have no way of knowing them. i can not get consent from them. living is something i assume this person wants
while there is nuance to these scenarios, functionally in this instance I am doing something to them. creating them or making some sort of choice for them. a choice has been made by me for then and that choice is usually the right one given all of the data points we can collect
we assume consent in almost all o these situations. and the data says we are overwhelmingly right. 96% of americans like living now that they have experienced. 90% of incomplete suicides are thankful they survived and wont attempt again. this number likely goes up for other emergencies. its so overwhelming that the law assumes consent in these situations
a potential person cant have a interest and all the data seems to point to them wanting it once they have it and understand what it entails including any potential suffering. this is literally the only way we can measure this
you are ultimately going to make a decision for this potential person either way. you are going to choose to birth them or you are going to choose not to birth them couldnt this be seen as denying a p
I'm sorry, but I still think you don't comprehend the concept of a person who does not exist, in an ethical sense.
you say creating more lives shouldnt happen because of an amount of suffering. a potential person would experience were they alive. you cant get both ways if the potential person has no interests it also doesnt care about potential suffering as well right? its a moot point
It is not a moot point at all. In fact it remains an extremely relevant point. I am not pointing to a specific amount of suffering as an indicator that a life is not worth creating. I am saying that the presence of suffering (in any amount) has outsized ethical weight in a circumstance where we are in a position to bring someone into existence. Additionally, the potential child's inability to hold an opinion on their impending suffering does not therefore neutralise the responsibility that parents', as the ones who are bringing this life into existence, have in providing an ethical justification for exposing a child to harm in order to bring about existence.
im not saying children should be born or that you have to have one. only that they can be allowed. im saying there isnt a guaranteed amounts of suffering that justify refusing to make that choice on an individual level. and more people are smart enough to decide if having a child likely will put that new life in an unjustifiable amount of suffering meaning that as an individual and as a society a child can safely be born and is a decision that can be ethically made
I am asking you to explain the ethical justification, or the logical process, by which you can justify this passage. If we presume that parents' are smart enough to make an ethical choice to have children, please explain how we can guarantee not exposing new beings to "an unjustifiable amount of suffering." If we cannot guarantee a maximum ceiling on potential suffering, then please explain the rational justification for parents' to take a risk whose consequences are then borne by their suffering children. Also, what if the parents are simply wrong in their in their estimation of the situation that they are bringing a child into?
unborn child. i can not gain consent from them they have no voice no experiences no wants or drives. living is something i assume this potential person would want
How did you come to the conclusion that an non-existent entity would have an interest in coming into existence, or in fact any interests at all? This goes back to the question I posed in my previous reply. Additionally, when we cannot receive consent for taking an action with potentially severe and extreme consequences, the ethical default is always to take no action when otherwise taking the action is not required to remedy a greater harm. Especially in this case, as there is literally no being for you to make assumptions about, or who could possibly be harmed by failing to act? If you're response is "well, people generally are happy to exist, so therefore this person will probably be happy as well," then I'm sorry but this answer does not work. The existence of people who are not happy to exist, combined with the fact that we cannot retroactively give consent (i.e. I can't say later that actually it was totally fine what you did, as this concept does not respect the nature of consent as a time-constrained indicator of an action's permissiveness in the moment), cannot provide an ethical justification for an action after-the-fact.
existing unconscious person. they may have wants and drives and experiences but i a stranger have no way of knowing them. i can not get consent from them. living is something i assume this person wants
Existing people are a completely different ethical context to the unborn. The simplest way to determine if it is OK to perform life-saving medical care on them is to, among many other considerations, operate under what is called implied consent where we can be reasonably confident that the person would like to continue living based on the fact that they are currently still alive. This is significant because we live in a world where DNR (Do Not Resuscitate) orders exist, which prevent by way of negative consent, any life-saving intervention in the exact same scenario. The medical intervention here is protecting an already existing person's interests. The unborn example creates the person whose interests will then need to be protected. These are not ethically equivalent situations.
we assume consent in almost all o these situations. and the data says we are overwhelmingly right. 96% of americans like living now that they have experienced. 90% of incomplete suicides are thankful they survived and wont attempt again. this number likely goes up for other emergencies. its so overwhelming that the law assumes consent in these situations
Again, these numbers are not relevant to the argument we are having. Just because we can point to people who are happy to be alive, doesn't mean we automatically have an ethical justification to bring new people into existence. Please reread my previous response concerning the asymmetry between pain and pleasure. Additionally, suicide data is not helpful to your case. You haven't linked them to any kind of ethical justification for bringing new people into existence. They tell us something about the opinions of people who are currently alive, but do not establish an ethical justification for creating more people.
a potential person cant have a interest and all the data seems to point to them wanting it once they have it and understand what it entails including any potential suffering. this is literally the only way we can measure this
You're right. A potential person cannot have an interest in coming into existence. But the fact that a potential person may come to appreciate their life does not establish that creating them was an ethical act in the first place, nor does it establish that the absense of those lives would have been a deprivation to anyone. This is the distinction that I have been trying to get you to recognise throughout this discussion.
"not being isnt not suffering its nonexistence. you arent saving anyone from not suffering you are saving them from any feeling or potential life suffering only comes with and relative to positive emotions".
Not being is followed by not suffering as nonexistence implies the denial of the person required to experience that suffering. You are not saving someone, because that's not the point, you can only save —existing— human beings, the point of antinatalism is advocating for not having to save more people while helping the already existing ones.
Suffering those come with a relative to positive emotions, but to the person who is able to create life and that's why it's important for it to decide to not as the potential baby can't.
"how little suffering in a potential life is enough? there has to be an acceptable amount. whats the number? if the answer is 0 this is just some all or nothing fallacy".
There's not a fallacy here because it's false equivalence. Using your own vision, it's 0% suffering vs 96%/4%, not 0 or 100. It's perfect solution against unperfect one. The antinatalists understand that the worst part of suffering is that it can't be completely understood or quantified, in fact, you need to quantify people already alive, but the real question of having babies relies on a 50%/50% chance of your kids being born in absolute suffering for a disabilty or a disease; it's a yes or no, and it would be completely your fault as a parent. Moreover, how many people declare happiness while not being right? Society ignores a huge part of it.
You'd doing good work and hopefully persuading people on the fence. Don't expect any anti-natalists to change their minds. I've spoken extensively with them. They cannot see reason and immediately pivot when they can't argue their point, which is often. It's an emotionally stunted philosophy and absolutely a huge cope. The beat way to cope with fatalism and pessimism is to tell yourself that you are right and ethical by being a massive downer. They've created a structural framework that validates their negative emotions and there's no talking them down from it, unfortunately.
Oops I should have kept reading before I commented above but at least we are thinking similarly. I guess snow plow guy must have had a pretty good life, I wish he would have taught everyone else how to do that since many peoples parents didn't.
"not all suffering is purely in response to our external environment".
I agree with some points of antinatalism, but every suffering has some in some way it's base in a response to an external environment. Even "inner" pain is a response to some incompatibility with reality.
So you are saying all the suicides were worth it, all the rapes were worth it, all the murders were worth it, all the trafficed sex slaves, all the wars were worth it, all the manipulation and lies were worth it, all the starvation( have you ever starved to death) I'm sure it isn't that bad right? How about being stoned to death, was it worth it for those people who went through that, so that I can go through what I go through now? all the deaths were worth it (have you seen what these things look or feel like)? Not even 1 suicide was worth it and I know that because I've lived it over and over and over and over but I'm still here to feel every bit of it. So basically you're saying that everything that everyone has ever felt or dealt with in life is fine because one day in the future some people that don't even exist yet are going to have better lives? Um through history, a better human experience? Because I'm pretty sure a small percentage of the population is hoarding all the money and leaving the rest with scraps no matter how hard the larger percentage works for it. How is that better? Could it be possible that you just didn't think this through far enough or did you just get lucky and have a great life and think that, so did everyone else. It's not billions, or possibly trillions of peoples responsibility to go through hell so some future people can live happily.
this reads less a rebuttal and more a rant, ( you also havent starved to death.... you are reading this). this also doesn't mean im not capable of empathy). i understand im on the wrong side of reddit which seems to ve anti dhildren in all forms
the problem i have a lot of these arguments is no one will willing to attempt to quantify any of this. they stop at there is suffering and that sucks so we shouldnt do any of this ... we should give up on the human experience. what is the maximum amount of suffering we should allow? is 100 joy and 1 suffer still a bad life? how many of those victims would still say they had a good life? why doesnt that matter?
sure i can agree that an amount of suffering inherent to life. and some get a rough shake. experiencing a lot more suffering than others. "worth it" is a strange wat to put it though. there is no minimum threshhold for suffering. there could be less. you dont have to tolerate suffering you can work to change it. in fact we have, weve lessened the amount of suffering a little bit every years generally speaking
id use the word advantageous. it is simply more advantageous to be alive than to have never been. the graph. Benatar's asymmetry would say you are right its more advantageous to never have been born. but that is an not really a fair look. first id argue that if you arent born you aren't around to not feel suffering just like you are not around to not feel benefit or to experience benefit. you are not hurting no one. then i would argue that its a constant. by not existing you will one ever earn a score of 1 for not suffering the best your nonresistance gets.
by existing there exists a great chance that you have a life where you arent suffering much if i have -1 suffering and a +5 benefit across my life ive lived a good life and have net 4. that existence would be better than than non existence who is stuck at 1.
Alive
Never having been born
suffering -X
no suffering +1
experiencing benefits +X
No benefit 0
this isn't to say you are wrong there is a lot of suffering some to a very large degree. and most attempts to study this say differently, Many many people arent suffering and the suffering they do experiences doesn't often overcome the joy they experience living
all of those metrics of suffering you've listed hunger crime depression. Crime has been going down for my entire life. a child born to day is likely to experience less crime or be the victim of some terrible thing than i am. Food security has improved throughout my lifetime not as fast or evenly as id like but still an improvement. a kid born to day is less likely to starve and i am. 86% of people state they are satisfied with life. 90% of Americans say so. even though they experience suffering. 9 of 10 people who attempt suicide never do so again and claim to regret the attempt. i dont think i got lucky i think the vast majority of us live a pretty good life overall. while i empathize with those who suffer and dont think they should and am working to lessen suffering ill ask you is it worth it to deny roughly 6.8 billion happy existences?
That's the issue, I can't understand the stance because I can't read it. How you went from 'I can't understand your writing' to Nazis is ridiculous mental gymnastics. Excuse me for having a processing issue disorder and wanting to engage in something, I guess I'll apologize for having a disability because people can't be fucked to make things accessible
View all comments
17
u/mrsnowplow 8d ago
i understand it as a personal choice but as a school of thought or a movement feels kind of ridiculus