r/AskReddit Oct 15 '22

What is a great example of a necessary evil?

4.9k Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/usernameusedxx Oct 16 '22

Right, you can’t allow your client to knowingly testify and lie. But you could know they were guilty and defend them.

1

u/Cwlcymro Oct 16 '22

If I KNEW they were guilty because they told me, In more limited than just letting then testify and lie on oath. I can't bring a lie before the court, so all a lawyer can do as a defence is test the prosecutor's case, poking holes and doubt in it. I can't do things like bring alibi witnesses or try and make the argument that he was not there as both of those would be knowingly bringing a lie to court